DREETS injunction on logistics penalties: risks and appeals

French DREETS injunction on logistics penalties: daily penalty up to 0.1% of worldwide turnover, 1% cap, and how to appeal the order and its collection.

Can the French authorities impose a daily penalty on a retailer over logistics penalties?

Yes. Under Article L. 470-1 of the French Commercial Code, inspectors of the French competition and consumer authority can order a retailer, after an adversarial procedure, to bring its logistics penalty clauses and practices into line with the law, and attach a daily penalty of up to 0.1% of worldwide turnover. The total collected cannot exceed 1% of that turnover. The order and the later decision collecting the penalty can both be challenged before the French Minister for the Economy and the administrative court, which has full power to review them.

Updated: November 2026. Key provisions: Articles L. 441-17, L. 441-19, L. 442-1, L. 442-4, L. 470-1, L. 470-2, R. 470-1 and R. 470-2 of the French Commercial Code; Articles L. 521-1, R. 312-1, R. 421-1 and R. 421-7 of the French Code of Administrative Justice.

The DGCCRF (the French authority for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control) investigates commercial relations between suppliers and retailers. At regional level, its inspectors work within the DREETS (regional directorates for the economy, employment, labour and solidarity). On 10 March 2026, inspectors of the DREETS for the Hauts-de-France region ordered a national retail chain to stop its unlawful logistics penalty clauses and practices by 10 September 2026, with a daily penalty of €104,167 for up to 360 days. This guide is written for retailers, buying groups and central purchasing entities, including those based outside France that buy for the French market. If you are facing such a procedure, a lawyer for DGCCRF and DDPP inspections can tell you which time limits are already running. The figures in the worked examples are fictional.

Would you like to discuss your situation? Book a consultation:

CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION

The March 2026 injunction and earlier cases

What the official notice says

The DGCCRF published a three-paragraph notice. Inspectors of the DREETS Hauts-de-France ordered the retailer, on 10 March 2026, to stop "its unlawful clauses and practices in respect of logistics penalties towards its suppliers" by 10 September 2026. The order carries a daily penalty of €104,167 for each day of delay, for a maximum of 360 days from 11 September 2026, which amounts to €37,500,120 at most before the statutory cap is applied. The retailer therefore had six months to comply. The notice ends with a reminder to the whole sector: any logistics failure attributed to a supplier must be proven by the retailer when the penalty notice is sent, and the retailer's loss must be demonstrated.

The notice cites no statutory provision and gives no detail of the clauses or the amounts deducted. Linking the order to Article L. 470-1 is therefore our analysis: it is the provision that allows a daily penalty to be attached to an order concerning a restrictive commercial practice. As of 15 November 2026, we found no official publication on what happened after the September deadline, whether compliance, collection of the penalty or an appeal. The order looks forward ("stop"); it does not, by itself, require refunds to suppliers.

A practice in place since 2022

Official sources show regular use of this tool. A ministry press release of 22 February 2022 announced a daily-penalty injunction against a retailer over logistics penalties, with three months to comply. A press release of 4 November 2022 reported a survey of more than 200 suppliers and injunctions with penalties "of several million euros" against two retailers. The activity reports of the DREETS Hauts-de-France mention, for 2023, a penalty collection of €1.6 million notified (subject not stated) and, for 2024, a procedure "in the final phase of liquidation" of €700,000 over logistics penalty clauses and practices. The DGCCRF's 2024 activity report states that a central purchasing entity was charged €650,000 for late compliance of its logistics contracts. In short, the authority does collect these penalties when compliance is late.

The legal basis: Article L. 470-1 of the Commercial Code

Who can issue the order

Article L. 470-1 allows inspectors authorised under Article L. 450-1, II, to order "any professional", after an adversarial procedure and within a reasonable time, to comply with its obligations under Title IV of Book IV of the Commercial Code, to stop any unlawful conduct or to remove any unlawful clause. Title IV covers commercial negotiations, payment terms, logistics penalties and restrictive commercial practices. The same article covers the EU Platform-to-Business Regulation (EU) 2019/1150. Relations with wholesalers within the meaning of Article L. 441-4, II, fall outside the logistics penalty rules (Article L. 441-17, IV).

Two regimes, depending on the sanction

Where the breach carries an administrative fine, such as late payment, failure to comply with the order exposes the company to a fine of up to €3,000 for an individual and €15,000 for a company (Article L. 470-1, II). Where the breach carries a civil fine, the inspectors can attach a daily penalty (Article L. 470-1, III). Imposing logistics penalties that do not comply with Article L. 441-17 is a restrictive practice under Article L. 442-1, I, 3°, and such practices can lead to a civil fine ordered by the court at the request of the Minister for the Economy or the public prosecutor (Article L. 442-4). Logistics penalties therefore fall under the daily-penalty regime.

This regime dates from Law No. 2022-1158 of 16 August 2022, in force since 18 August 2022, and was unchanged as of 15 November 2026. The Law of 18 August 2026 on agriculture amended Article L. 442-1, not Article L. 470-1. Despite what is sometimes written, this is not a new power: it has been applied and penalties have been collected.

What inspectors check under Article L. 441-17

Article L. 441-17 sets the rules a retailer must follow when it penalises a supplier for late, incomplete or non-compliant deliveries:

  • the contract must allow a sufficient margin of error given the volume of deliveries;
  • when it sends a penalty notice, the retailer must provide, at the same time, proof of the failure and of the loss suffered, and the supplier must have a reasonable time to check and dispute it;
  • only failures causing stock shortages justify penalties, unless the retailer demonstrates and documents a loss in writing;
  • penalties must be proportionate to the loss and cannot exceed 2% of the value of the products ordered in the category concerned;
  • no penalty may be imposed for a failure that occurred more than one year earlier, and none in case of force majeure;
  • penalties may not be deducted automatically from the supplier's invoice;
  • the retailer cannot require payment of penalties faster than its own payment terms for goods.

The DGCCRF's guidelines, updated in November 2023, add that the 2% cap is calculated order by order on all products ordered in the category, that a penalty is "imposed" on the date of the final invoice, and that the supplier should have at least one month from receipt of the notice and supporting documents to dispute it. Inspectors typically compare the contracts with the law, then test a sample of notices, invoices and payments.

Before the order: the adversarial phase

No order can be issued without a prior adversarial procedure. The statute does not fix its length, unlike the 60 days allowed before an administrative fine under Article L. 470-2. If the authority intends to publish the order, or to publish a later failure to comply, the company must be told during this phase, and publication is at its expense (Article L. 470-1, I and III, 2). Article R. 470-1 lists the media: press, online, or display for no more than two months, with the full order or a summary notice.

The amount of the daily penalty must be "proportionate to the seriousness of the breaches" and take account "in particular of the extent of the disturbance caused". The written response is the first place to discuss the findings, the compliance period, the amount and publication, with figures. A response that admits facts without context, or promises compliance that cannot be delivered on time, weakens the rest of the file. Deciding what to dispute and what to correct at once is where counsel makes the most difference; our article on the DGCCRF notice of intended fine explains how written observations work in a related procedure.

What is at stake: the two caps

The daily penalty cannot exceed 0.1% of worldwide turnover excluding tax for the last closed financial year. If the company's accounts are consolidated or combined, the turnover of the consolidating entity is used, so a subsidiary may be assessed on the whole group's turnover. The order must state the start date, the duration and the amount. The penalty runs from the day after the compliance deadline. The total collected cannot exceed 1% of the same turnover. At the maximum daily rate, that cap is reached after ten days of delay; at a lower rate, it takes longer, and the cap may be reached before the end of the stated duration.

Worked example (fictional). A retailer has a consolidated worldwide turnover of €600 million. The maximum daily penalty would be €600,000 and the cap €6 million. Suppose the order sets €25,000 per day for up to 180 days. If the retailer updates its logistics agreements and payment system 45 days after the deadline, up to €1,125,000 can be collected. If the delay covers the whole period, the theoretical total of €4.5 million stays below the cap. At €60,000 per day, the cap would be reached on day 100.

Worldwide turnover excl. tax, last closed year (fictional) Maximum daily penalty (0.1%) Cap on total collected (1%) Days to reach the cap at the maximum rate Days to reach the cap at €25,000 per day
€50 million €50,000 €500,000 10 20
€600 million €600,000 €6 million 10 240
€3 billion €3 million €30 million 10 1,200 (cap not reached within 360 days)

How to challenge the injunction

Review by the Minister, or by the author

Under Article R. 470-1, the order "may be challenged by the person concerned before the Minister for the Economy", and this appeal excludes any other hierarchical appeal. A request for review to the author of the decision (recours gracieux) is also possible. Filed within the time limit for going to court, these requests interrupt it (Article L. 411-2 of the French Code on Relations between the Public and the Administration); if you use both, file both within the initial period. Two months of silence amounts to a rejection. These requests do not stop the compliance deadline.

Full-jurisdiction appeal and urgent suspension

Article L. 470-1, III, provides that the order is subject to a full-jurisdiction appeal (recours de pleine juridiction): the court can in principle vary the decision, not only annul it. The application must be filed within two months of notification (Article R. 421-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice), extended by two months for persons residing outside France when the court sits in metropolitan France (Article R. 421-7). The competent court is in principle the one where the authority that took the decision has its seat, not where the company is based (Article R. 312-1). The appeal does not suspend the order. Once the main application is filed, the urgent applications judge can suspend it if urgency is shown and a ground raises serious doubt as to its legality (Article L. 521-1).

Challenging the order does not remove the need to prepare for compliance: without a suspension, the penalty starts running at the deadline. The two tracks should be run together and kept consistent. For comparison, consumer law injunctions follow different rules, explained in our guide to responding to a DGCCRF compliance order.

The deadline: proving compliance

The March 2026 order targeted "clauses and practices". Changing the template contract is not enough if notices still go out without evidence, if deductions remain automatic in the payment system, or if agreements already signed with suppliers stay as they are. Compliance covers documents (logistics agreement, purchasing terms, dispute procedure), systems (order-by-order cap, blocking deductions of disputed penalties) and the practice of buying, accounts payable and logistics teams. The statute allows collection for total non-compliance, partial compliance and late compliance. On the deadline, the company should be able to show what it did and when, with dated evidence.

Collection of the penalty (liquidation) and how to challenge it

If compliance is total, partial or late, the authority "proceeds" to collect the penalty under the conditions of Article L. 470-2, IV. The competent authority is listed in Article R. 470-2: the Director General of the DGCCRF, the head of its national investigation service, the director of a DREETS or DEETS (overseas), the director of a DDPP (departmental directorate for the protection of populations), or in French Guiana the director general for social cohesion, each or a named representative. Before deciding, the authority must inform the company in writing, tell it that it may consult the file and be assisted by counsel, and give it 60 days for written and, where relevant, oral observations. The decision must state its reasons.

Collection is not a mechanical "days times daily amount" exercise. The date and extent of compliance, the turnover used, particularly in a group, and the cap can all be discussed. Note one difference: for consumer law injunctions, Article L. 521-1 of the Consumer Code requires the authority to take account of "the circumstances of the case" when setting the amount collected; Article L. 470-1 of the Commercial Code contains no such sentence at that stage. It does, however, require proportionality when the penalty is set and provides a full-jurisdiction appeal against the collection decision, so proportionality can be argued before the court.

The collection decision can be challenged within two months before the administrative court, with an urgent suspension request if needed. Whether a prior administrative appeal is available should be checked on the decision itself: Article R. 470-1 covers the order and Article R. 470-2, II, covers fine decisions. The Minister then issues the payment order (titre de perception) for the amount collected (Article R. 470-2, IV), which has its own challenge procedure, explained in our article on the French fine payment order.

Stage Time limit Legal basis
Adversarial phase before the order Set by the authority (not fixed by statute) Commercial Code, L. 470-1, I
Compliance period "Reasonable" period set in the order (six months in March 2026) Commercial Code, L. 470-1, I and III
Review by the Minister or by the author Within the two months for going to court, to interrupt them; two months of silence means rejection Commercial Code, R. 470-1; Code on Relations between the Public and the Administration, L. 411-2 and L. 231-4
Full-jurisdiction appeal against the order Two months from notification, plus two months for persons residing abroad Commercial Code, L. 470-1, III; Code of Administrative Justice, R. 421-1, R. 421-7, R. 312-1
Urgent suspension Once the main application is filed Code of Administrative Justice, L. 521-1
Daily penalty Runs from the day after the compliance deadline Commercial Code, L. 470-1, III
Proposed collection (liquidation) 60 days for observations, access to the file Commercial Code, L. 470-2, IV; R. 470-2, I
Appeal against the collection decision Two months from notification; urgent suspension available Commercial Code, L. 470-1, III; Code of Administrative Justice, R. 421-1
Payment order Its own time limits Commercial Code, R. 470-2, IV

Other exposure for the retailer

The administrative order is not the only risk. Under Article L. 442-4, the Minister for the Economy or the public prosecutor can ask the court to stop the practices, declare unlawful clauses void and order refunds of undue benefits, provided the suppliers concerned are informed. They can also seek a civil fine of up to the highest of €5 million, three times the undue benefits, or 5% of French turnover excluding tax. The court must order publication of its decision. These cases go to eight designated commercial courts (Marseille, Bordeaux, Tourcoing, Fort-de-France, Lyon, Nancy, Paris and Rennes), with appeals to the Paris Court of Appeal (Article D. 442-2 and Annex 4-2-1). Suppliers can also sue: only the victim can seek nullity of the clauses and refund of undue benefits in its own name.

Retailers must also report to the DGCCRF, by 31 December each year, the logistics penalties imposed over the previous twelve months and the amounts actually received, month by month (Article L. 441-19). Failure carries an administrative fine of up to €500,000 for a company, €1 million for a repeat breach within two years. Article L. 444-1 A makes these rules mandatory for any agreement covering products or services sold in France and gives French courts exclusive jurisdiction, subject to EU law, international treaties and arbitration. How fines of this kind are challenged is covered in our guide to challenging a DGCCRF fine.

Frequently asked questions

What is a DGCCRF injunction with a daily penalty on logistics penalties?

An administrative order, issued after an adversarial procedure under Article L. 470-1 of the Commercial Code, requiring a retailer to bring its logistics penalty clauses and practices into line with Article L. 441-17 by a set date. Because the breach carries a civil fine, the order can carry a daily penalty that runs from the day after the deadline.

How much can the daily penalty be?

Up to 0.1% of worldwide turnover excluding tax for the last closed financial year, assessed on consolidated accounts where they exist. The total collected cannot exceed 1% of that turnover, a cap reached after ten days at the maximum rate.

How do I appeal a DREETS injunction in France?

Ask the Minister for the Economy to review it (Article R. 470-1) or ask the author to reconsider, and/or file a full-jurisdiction appeal with the administrative court within two months of notification, four months if you reside abroad. An urgent suspension request can be filed once the main application is lodged.

Does an appeal stop the daily penalty?

No. Only the urgent applications judge can suspend the order, if urgency is shown and there is serious doubt as to its legality (Article L. 521-1 of the Code of Administrative Justice).

How is the penalty collected?

The authority listed in Article R. 470-2 informs the company in writing, gives access to the file and allows 60 days for observations (Article L. 470-2, IV). Its reasoned decision can be appealed to the administrative court. The Minister then issues a payment order.

Does the injunction require refunds to suppliers?

Not by itself: it orders the retailer to stop unlawful clauses and practices for the future. Amounts already deducted are recovered before the designated commercial courts, by the supplier or by the Minister, who can seek refunds if suppliers are informed (Article L. 442-4).

Key actions

  • Preliminary letter received: note the response deadline, collect contracts, notices and payment data, and discuss the findings, the compliance period, the amount and publication.
  • Order notified: calculate the two-month appeal period, decide on review, court appeal and urgent suspension, and start compliance work at once.
  • Deadline: keep dated evidence of what changed in contracts, systems and practice.
  • Collection notice received: use the 60 days to consult the file, document compliance and check the turnover and the cap.

Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.