A "photos are not contractual" clause does not stop French consumers claiming under the legal guarantee. It is an unfair term that can cost €75,000.

Many online shops state in their terms that "photos are not contractual" (photos non contractuelles), that "colours may vary" or that "product descriptions are not guaranteed". Against a French consumer, such clauses offer no protection. The photo and description are part of what the customer is entitled to expect: the goods must match "the description" (Article L. 217-4 of the French Consumer Code), and the legal guarantee of conformity is a mandatory rule that cannot be waived (Article L. 219-1). A clause used to reject any complaint about a gap between the product and its presentation lets the seller alone decide whether the goods conform and removes the customer's right to compensation. It is on the black list of unfair terms (Article R. 212-1, 4° and 6°), it is deemed not written, and its mere presence in the terms can lead to an administrative fine of up to €75,000 for a company (Article L. 241-2).
Updated: November 2026. Key provisions: Articles L. 217-3 to L. 217-7, L. 219-1, L. 212-1, R. 212-1, L. 241-1, L. 241-2, L. 241-5 and L. 521-1 of the French Consumer Code.
A purely informative note, for example that colours depend on screen settings, is acceptable as long as it is not used to refuse complaints. Between that note and an exclusion clause, French law gives sellers legitimate tools: accurate descriptions, stated tolerances, and specific information on a deviation that the customer expressly accepts. These rules are enforced by the DGCCRF (the French authority for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control). If such a clause has been flagged in your terms, a lawyer for DGCCRF and DDPP inspections can help you assess the risk.
CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION
These clauses all try to strip the product presentation of any binding value. They appear in terms and conditions, in a footer on product pages, on the delivery and returns page or in order confirmation emails. Typical examples are "photographs and illustrations are not contractual", "colours are indicative and cannot give rise to any claim", "product descriptions are supplied by our suppliers and we do not guarantee their accuracy", "dimensions and weights are approximate and not contractual", "the manufacturer may change product specifications without notice", and "the seller cannot be held liable for errors on product pages". They usually come from templates, business-to-business contracts, terms drafted for another country, or supplier data feeds. We discuss the UK versions of these clauses in our guide to unfair terms and French consumers for UK sellers.
For contracts concluded since 1 January 2022, Article L. 217-4 provides that goods conform to the contract if, among other things, they correspond to the description, type, quantity and quality provided for in the contract, and are delivered with all the accessories that must be supplied. In an online sale, the description is first of all the product page: title, text, technical data and the photos showing colour, shape, finish and accessories. The customer has not seen the product and buys on the strength of that presentation.
Article L. 217-5 adds objective criteria: goods must have the qualities and characteristics that the consumer can reasonably expect for goods of the same type, having regard to public statements made by the seller, by anyone earlier in the chain of transactions, or on their behalf, including in advertising or on labelling. The seller is not bound by a third party's public statements if it proves that it did not know of them and could not reasonably have known, that they had been corrected in comparable conditions, or that they could not have influenced the decision to buy (Article L. 217-5, II). These exceptions concern statements by others. They do not cover a product page that the seller publishes on its own site, even if the content was copied from a supplier.
The seller is liable for lack of conformity existing at delivery that becomes apparent within two years (Article L. 217-3). A defect that appears within 24 months of delivery, or 12 months for second-hand goods, is presumed to have existed at delivery unless proven otherwise (Article L. 217-7). The whole regime is a matter of public policy (Article L. 219-1), so a clause cannot take away what the law grants. A colour difference visible when the parcel is opened is a lack of conformity at delivery: the customer does not even need the presumption.
Article R. 212-1 lists terms that are irrebuttably presumed unfair and therefore prohibited. Point 4° covers terms that give the trader alone the right to decide whether the goods delivered conform to the contract, or the exclusive right to interpret any term. A "photos are not contractual" clause used to reject a complaint does exactly that. Point 6° covers terms that remove or reduce the consumer's right to compensation for any breach by the trader: "we do not guarantee the accuracy of descriptions" excludes liability for failing to deliver conforming goods. Point 3° covers terms reserving to the trader the right to change unilaterally the characteristics of the goods, which is what "specifications may change without notice" does. No case-by-case imbalance needs to be shown: the presumption cannot be rebutted.
Unfair terms are deemed not written, and the rest of the contract continues to apply (Article L. 241-1). Terms offered to consumers must also be drafted clearly and are interpreted, in case of doubt, in the way most favourable to the consumer (Article L. 211-1). A vague colour note, halfway between information and exclusion, will be read in the way that preserves the customer's rights.
Explaining that colours depend on screen settings is accurate and useful, provided the note is not drafted or used to refuse complaints. It protects against claims based on slight display differences, not against a product of another colour. Sellers may also define in the product description what they commit to: "length 180 cm, tolerance plus or minus 1 cm" or "shade may vary slightly between dye batches" makes the description more precise. A reasonable, numerical tolerance shown on the product page before purchase sets the promise; a general "approximate dimensions" note leaves the seller alone to judge the acceptable gap, which point 4° prohibits.
French law provides a precise mechanism for selling goods that depart from what can normally be expected, such as display models, end-of-line items with cosmetic flaws or seconds. Under Article L. 217-5, III, the consumer cannot challenge conformity on the basis of a defect in one or more particular characteristics of the goods when he was specifically informed that they deviated from the conformity criteria and expressly and separately agreed to that deviation when concluding the contract. A general clause in the terms, accepted with a single tick box, cannot meet this test by definition. The information must appear for the product concerned, and the acceptance must be distinct within the checkout. How to set this up on a site, and prove it later, depends on the case.
For products where each item is unique, such as solid wood, leather, stone or handmade ceramics, variation is part of the nature of the goods and of what the consumer can reasonably expect. Describe it on the product page in concrete terms (grain, knots, shade, small glaze irregularities) and show several items where possible. This describes the product; it does not cover a defect, a wrong dimension or a finish different from the one announced.
Before a consumer is bound, the trader must provide the main characteristics of the goods (Article L. 111-1, 1°) and, for distance contracts, the pre-contractual information of Article L. 221-5. Breaches carry administrative fines of up to €3,000 / €15,000 (Article L. 131-1) or, for distance sales, €15,000 / €75,000 (Article L. 242-10). Information on the legal guarantees before the sale is sanctioned more heavily, up to €15,000 / €75,000 (Article L. 131-1-1), and terms and conditions must describe the legal guarantees (Article L. 211-2; fine of up to €3,000 / €15,000 under Article L. 241-2-1). Where a photo or description gives a false impression of the product's essential characteristics, it may be a misleading commercial practice (Articles L. 121-2 and L. 121-3), a criminal offence punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine, or five years and €750,000 when committed online (Article L. 132-2). The "photos not contractual" note does not make an inaccurate visual any less misleading.
Product feeds, dropshipping and marketplace listings raise the same issue: descriptions the seller did not write become its own towards the customer. Retouched photos, 3D renderings and AI-generated images are not prohibited as such, but each must faithfully show the product that will be delivered, in colour, proportions, materials and finish.
Terms and conditions can be read in minutes from the authority's offices, without any visit. Under Article L. 241-2, the presence of one or more black-listed unfair terms in consumer contracts carries an administrative fine of up to €15,000 for an individual and €75,000 for a company, rising to 4% of average annual turnover, or €2 million where turnover data is unavailable, for widespread infringements following an EU mutual assistance request. The text targets the presence of the clause, not its use against a customer. Only black-listed terms (Article R. 212-1) are covered by this fine; grey-listed terms (Article R. 212-2) are a matter for the courts.
The authority can also order the trader, after an adversarial procedure, "to delete any unlawful or prohibited term" (our translation of Article L. 521-1) within a reasonable time limit, with a daily penalty of up to €3,000 capped at €300,000, and publish the order at the trader's expense (Article L. 521-2). Before any fine, the business must be informed in writing of the intended sanction and has one month to submit observations, with the assistance of counsel if it wishes (Article L. 522-5 and Article R. 522-2). This is the point at which the advice of a lawyer changes the outcome: the qualification of the clause, its exact wording, the date it was removed and how it was used with customers are all open to discussion. Our guide on responding to a DGCCRF compliance order explains that stage.
Before the courts, the clause is simply disregarded and the guarantee applies. Since 3 May 2025, in its current wording, Article L. 241-5 also allows a court to impose a civil fine of up to €300,000, or 10% of average annual turnover, on a seller who in bad faith obstructs the legal guarantee of conformity; it can be sought by the authority, consumer associations, the public prosecutor or the consumer. A trader who keeps using, in identical contracts, terms already held unfair against it by a final judgment faces a civil fine of up to €15,000 / €75,000 (Article L. 241-1-1).
A purely informative note, for example on screen colour rendering, is acceptable. A clause that removes any value from photos in order to refuse complaints is not: it is a black-listed unfair term (Article R. 212-1, 4° and 6°), deemed not written and liable to an administrative fine.
Yes, under the legal guarantee of conformity, if the difference goes beyond a slight display variation, since the goods must match the description (Article L. 217-4). Separately, online purchases carry a 14-day right of withdrawal.
For a black-listed term, up to €15,000 for an individual and €75,000 for a company (Article L. 241-2), and up to 4% of turnover for widespread infringements across the EU. The mere presence of the term is enough.
A general note is risky because it leaves the seller alone to judge the acceptable gap. A reasonable numerical tolerance, shown on the product page before purchase, defines what you commit to and is the better option.
Inform the customer specifically of the characteristic that departs from the norm and obtain express and separate acceptance when the order is placed (Article L. 217-5, III). A general clause in the terms is not enough, and the customer keeps full rights for any other defect.
Yes, when you publish it on your own product page: it is the description of your sale. The exceptions for third-party public statements do not cover your own page. Supply contracts should include a guarantee from the supplier on the accuracy of product data.
A "photos not contractual" clause gives sellers a sense of security it does not provide. Against a consumer, the photo and description are part of the promise, the legal guarantee of conformity is mandatory, and the exclusion clause is a black-listed unfair term: disregarded by the courts and fined for its mere presence. French law offers better tools: accurate descriptions, stated tolerances, clear information on natural variation, and the mechanism of a deviation expressly and separately accepted. The wider rules for selling online to French consumers are set out in our guide to French consumer law for UK online sellers. If such a clause has been flagged during an inspection, or you want your terms, product pages and customer service templates reviewed, Victoris can assist you from the analysis of the clauses to the reply to the authority.
Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.