Repeated tenders in France: new liability rule since 2026

Since 20 August 2026, French law makes buyers liable for repeated tenders whose frequency or terms create a significant imbalance for the supplier.

Are repeated tenders now unlawful in France?

Not as such. Since 20 August 2026, Article L. 442-1, I, 6° of the French Commercial Code makes a business liable, and obliges it to compensate the harm caused, when it subjects "a commercial partner to competitive procedures or repeated calls for tender whose frequency or terms are such as to create a significant imbalance in the rights and obligations of the parties". The provision was added by Article 54 of Law No. 2026-796 of 18 August 2026. Buyers may still put suppliers in competition; what the law targets is the use of tenders, through their pace or their organisation, as a lever that unbalances the relationship.

Updated: November 2026. Key provisions: Article L. 442-1, I, 1°, 2°, 5° and 6° and II of the French Commercial Code (as amended by Law No. 2026-796 of 18 August 2026, Article 54); Article L. 442-4 of the same code.

The rule applies across all sectors: Article L. 442-1, I covers "any person engaged in production, distribution or services". It concerns retailers, but also manufacturers consulting subcontractors, shippers retendering transport contracts and companies re-quoting maintenance providers every quarter. It matters to foreign suppliers selling to French buyers and to foreign groups buying in France. For advice on purchase or supply agreements, see our page for a commercial contracts lawyer in France. The examples below are fictitious.

Would you like to discuss your situation? Book a consultation:

CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION

What the new point 6° says

A new restrictive practice

French law lists "restrictive practices" (pratiques restrictives de concurrence) that make their author liable in the negotiation, conclusion or performance of a contract: obtaining an advantage without consideration (1°), subjecting the other party to obligations creating a significant imbalance (2°), unlawful logistics penalties (3°), discriminatory terms (4°) and bad-faith negotiation causing the annual signing deadline to be missed (5°). Law No. 2026-796, published in the Official Journal on 19 August 2026, added point 6°, in force since 20 August 2026.

The key words

"Subjects" implies that the partner undergoes the procedure rather than chooses it. "Competitive procedures or calls for tender" covers formal tenders, informal consultations, online reverse auctions and requests for quotation. "Repeated" targets a succession of procedures. "Frequency or terms" sets two alternative tests: pace or method. Finally, the practice must be "such as to create" a significant imbalance: the imbalance need not have materialised yet.

What the text does not say

There is no threshold: the law does not say how many tenders a year become unlawful or what response times are acceptable. There is no specific administrative fine; like the other practices in Article L. 442-1, I, point 6° is enforced in court under Article L. 442-4. It does not, in principle, apply to facts before 20 August 2026, which remain subject to the rules then in force, such as the significant imbalance test of point 2°. No published decision has yet interpreted point 6°.

Who is concerned

All buyers, not only retailers

Point 6° was adopted in a farming law, and much commentary links it to negotiations between suppliers and French retail chains. It sits, however, in Article L. 442-1, I, which applies to any business engaged in production, distribution or services. A carmaker retendering machined parts every six months, a hotel group re-quoting its laundry providers every quarter, or a shipper running successive reverse auctions among hauliers may all be concerned if the frequency or terms create a significant imbalance.

Private-label products and suppliers as buyers

In food retail, private-label products are often awarded by tender, and the Commercial Code already requires such tenders to include certain commitments from the retailer (Article L. 441-7, I bis). Point 6° adds protection against the repetition of the tenders themselves. The rule also works the other way: an SME that suffers repeated tenders from its customers often runs its own tenders with its suppliers and subcontractors, and must apply the same care.

A single tender?

The text refers to "competitive procedures or repeated calls for tender". One reading attaches "repeated" to both terms, which would exclude a single, isolated consultation, even a badly run one; another sees repetition in a single procedure run in successive bidding rounds. The point is unsettled. Its practical weight is limited, since an unfair single tender remains exposed to points 1° and 2° and to the general rules on pre-contractual liability.

Normal tendering or restrictive practice: the indicators

Frequency

Frequency is assessed against the relationship. Retendering a three-year contract at expiry is normal. Relaunching a tender every three months for the same scope, when the supplier had to invest in dedicated tooling depreciated over several years, is far less so. What counts: contract duration, the time needed to recover the investment required, real changes in needs between tenders, and sector practice.

Terms

The law also targets the way tenders are run: very short response times for complex technical bids, specifications changed at every round, criteria not announced or changed midway, extra rounds added after bids are submitted, reverse auctions relaunched until prices fall below cost, samples or studies required at every round without payment, and disclosure of one bidder's price to others. None of these is unlawful in itself; their accumulation, and their effect on the balance of the relationship, may be.

Tenders that are never awarded

A common warning sign is the tender that leads nowhere: the buyer collects bids, awards nothing and uses the prices obtained to demand a discount from the incumbent. Repeated, this turns competition into permanent renegotiation with no commitment in return. Proof lies in the chronology: tender dates, results notified or not, discount requests that followed.

Factor Normal competitive tendering Warning sign under point 6°
Frequency Tender at the end of the contract, at a pace consistent with its duration and the investment required New tender every three or four months for the same scope, with no change in needs
Rules Written tender rules, announced criteria, timetable kept Criteria changed midway, extra negotiation rounds added without warning
Response time Time suited to the complexity of the bid A few days to price a full technical file
Cost of responding Proportionate requests; heavy studies paid for or taken into account Samples, prototypes and studies demanded at every round with nothing in return
Outcome Contract actually awarded, result notified Tenders never awarded, used to extract a discount from the incumbent
Confidentiality Bids kept confidential One bidder's price shown to others to restart the bidding

Online reverse auctions

Reverse auctions on e-procurement platforms are lawful. They become an issue under point 6° when auctions follow one another on the same scope at short intervals, when the rules (duration, automatic extensions, reserve price, non-price criteria) change from one session to the next without notice, or when the buyer reruns an auction simply because it does not like the result. Suppliers should read the platform rules before bidding, keep successive versions and set in advance the price below which they will not go.

Links with other restrictive practices and with sudden termination

Significant imbalance and advantage without consideration

Point 6° borrows the "significant imbalance" concept from point 2°. Before 2026, a supplier facing endless tenders had to rely on that general provision and show that a specific obligation was unbalanced. Point 6° makes the procedure itself the object of scrutiny. Studies, prototypes or audits demanded at every round, without payment and with no serious prospect of award, may also fall under point 1° (advantage without consideration). Several grounds can be combined, provided the same loss is not claimed twice.

Established relationships and notice

Retendering a contract does not exempt the buyer from the rules on established commercial relationships. Article L. 442-1, II makes liable anyone who suddenly terminates, even partially, an established commercial relationship without written notice that takes into account, in particular, the length of the relationship; no liability for insufficient notice arises where 18 months' notice was given, and termination without notice remains possible for breach or force majeure. A supplier that loses a tender after a long relationship may therefore still be entitled to reasonable notice. When notice starts to run depends on the documents exchanged: an invitation to bid is not necessarily notice of termination.

What the buyer risks

Under Article L. 442-4, any person with an interest may ask the court to stop the practice and award damages; only the victim may seek annulment of unlawful clauses or contracts and repayment of undue advantages. The summary proceedings judge may order, if necessary under a penalty payment, the practice to stop or any other interim measure. The minister for the economy and the public prosecutor may also act, without any complaint from a supplier, and seek a civil fine of up to the highest of €5 million, three times the undue advantages obtained, or 5% of the turnover excluding VAT achieved in France by the author of the practices in the last closed financial year. The court systematically orders publication of its decision, at the expense of the party found liable. Disputes go to courts designated by decree, which must be identified before any action.

Who acts What they can ask for Legal basis
The supplier harmed An order to stop the practice, damages, annulment of unlawful clauses or contracts, repayment of undue advantages Commercial Code, L. 442-4 I
Any person with an interest An order to stop the practice and damages Commercial Code, L. 442-4 I
Minister for the economy or public prosecutor Order to stop, annulment and repayment (victims informed), civil fine up to the highest of €5 million, three times the undue advantages or 5% of turnover achieved in France Commercial Code, L. 442-4 I
The court Systematic publication of the decision, penalty payments, interim measures in summary proceedings Commercial Code, L. 442-4 II
Competent court Courts designated by decree Commercial Code, L. 442-4 III

What suppliers should do

Build the file as the relationship goes on, not afterwards. List every tender received on the same scope since 20 August 2026: launch date, response time, specifications, announced criteria, number of rounds, result notified or not, and any discount request that followed. Record the cost of each response: sales and engineering time, samples, prototypes, travel. Ask in writing, at each tender, for the rules, the award criteria, the timetable and what will happen to your current contract; lack of an answer is itself evidence. Where the rules change midway, make written reservations without breaking off the commercial dialogue.

Example: a precision machining SME makes 35% of its turnover with an automotive supplier. Since September 2026, the customer has launched five tenders on the same parts, each with six working days to respond and a request for samples. None was awarded; after each, the buyer asked the SME to match "the lowest bid received" without disclosing it. Each response costs about €18,000 in engineering time and material. Several indicators targeted by point 6° are present: frequency, response times, no award, bids used to renegotiate. Whether to negotiate, go to mediation, alert the authorities or sue depends on the SME's dependence on this customer and on the evidence gathered; this is where advice from a lawyer makes the difference.

What buyers should do

Buyers need not give up competitive tendering. They should be able to justify the pace of their tenders (contract expiry, technical change, new needs, new suppliers), set contract durations in line with the investment asked of suppliers, issue written tender rules with announced criteria and a timetable that is kept, allow response times suited to the bid, keep bids confidential, pay for or take into account heavy studies, and notify an award decision. Purchasing teams rewarded on savings tend to multiply negotiation rounds; management should give them a clear framework and keep a written record of the reasons for each new tender. Framework agreements and general purchasing terms that let the buyer retender at any time while binding the supplier to its prices for a long period should also be reviewed in light of points 2° and 6°.

Frequently asked questions

Has French law banned repeated calls for tender since August 2026?

No. Article L. 442-1, I, 6° of the Commercial Code, in force since 20 August 2026, makes liable a business that subjects a partner to repeated competitive procedures or calls for tender whose frequency or terms are such as to create a significant imbalance in the parties' rights and obligations.

How many tenders a year are too many?

The law sets no number. Frequency is assessed against contract duration, the investment required from the supplier, real changes in needs and sector practice. The terms of each tender matter as much as their number.

Does the rule apply outside retail?

Yes. Article L. 442-1, I covers any person engaged in production, distribution or services, including manufacturing, subcontracting, logistics, transport and services.

Are online reverse auctions covered?

Yes, a reverse auction is a competitive procedure. It is not prohibited as such, but auctions rerun at short intervals on the same scope, or whose rules change without notice, may fall under point 6° if they create a significant imbalance.

What does a buyer risk?

An order to stop the practice, damages, annulment of unlawful clauses and repayment of undue advantages at the victim's request, and a civil fine at the request of the minister or prosecutor, capped at the highest of €5 million, three times the undue advantages or 5% of turnover achieved in France, with publication of the decision.

Can tenders run before 20 August 2026 be challenged?

Not under point 6°. Earlier facts can, however, be examined under the other practices of Article L. 442-1 then in force, such as significant imbalance or advantage without consideration.

Key actions

  • Suppliers: keep a dated log of every tender on the same scope, its rules, response time, outcome and cost; ask for the rules in writing and record reservations.
  • Buyers: justify the pace of tenders, publish written rules, keep the timetable, protect confidentiality and notify award decisions.
  • Both: review framework agreements and purchasing terms against points 2° and 6° of Article L. 442-1, I, and take advice before acting on a dispute.

Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.