Awards, labels and "No. 1" claims in France: what to prove

Using a quality label, an industry award or a "No. 1" claim in France? What you must be able to prove, what the DGCCRF can demand, and the penalties.

Awards, labels and "No. 1" claims in France: what your business must be able to prove

In France, an award badge, a quality label or a "No. 1 in sales" claim is a commercial claim like any other. The business displaying it must be able to show that it is accurate, current and understood by customers in its true scope. Displaying a certificate or quality label without the necessary authorisation is a misleading commercial practice in all circumstances. Misleading practices are criminal offences punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine for an individual, five years and €750,000 when committed online, with fines five times higher for companies.

Updated: November 2026. Key provisions: Articles L. 121-1 to L. 121-5, L. 122-1 to L. 122-5, L. 132-1 to L. 132-8, L. 433-3 to L. 433-6 and L. 512-15 of the French Consumer Code; Article 131-38 of the French Criminal Code; French Supreme Court (Cour de cassation), commercial chamber, 24 June 2026, No. 24-16.770.

These rules apply to every business that sells to customers in France, including foreign brands and online sellers. Checks are carried out by the DGCCRF (the French authority for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control) and its local offices, the DDPP. If your claims are already being questioned by the authority, a lawyer for DGCCRF and DDPP inspections can review what is expected of you before you reply.

Would you like to discuss your situation? Book a consultation:

CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION

Why awards and labels fall under the misleading practices rules

An award is a statement about your product or your business

A commercial practice is misleading when it relies on false claims, or claims likely to mislead, about matters such as the substantial qualities of a product, "the results and main characteristics of tests and checks" carried out on it, the scope of the advertiser's commitments, or "the identity, qualities, aptitudes and rights of the trader" (Article L. 121-2 of the Consumer Code). An award says that a third party judged your product better than others. A label says that a set of specifications was met and checked. A "No. 1" claim states a market position. Each can be true, false, or true but presented in a misleading way.

A practice is also misleading when it omits, hides or provides "in an unintelligible, ambiguous or untimely manner" information that the customer needs (Article L. 121-3). Award cases often turn on this: the distinction exists, but the year, the category or the conditions of the award are missing, and customers draw a broader conclusion.

The overall impression counts

Authorities and courts look at the message as an average, reasonably attentive customer receives it (Article L. 121-1), across all channels: website, packaging, social media, in-store displays and sales scripts. A precise caption on the website does not cure a shop poster where the caption has disappeared.

Business-to-business claims are covered too

The misleading practices provisions "also apply to practices aimed at professionals and non-professionals" (Article L. 121-5). A software vendor claiming to be "HR solution of the year" in a brochure for HR directors, or a manufacturer presenting itself as "No. 1 in Europe" to its distributors, is subject to the same rules.

Practices deemed misleading in all circumstances

Displaying a label without authorisation

Article L. 121-4 lists practices deemed misleading per se, without any need to show an effect on customers. Point 2 covers displaying "a certificate, a quality label or equivalent without having obtained the necessary authorisation". Point 4 covers claiming that a trader or a product "has been approved, endorsed or authorised by a public or private body" when this is not the case, or failing to comply with the terms of the approval. Points 1 and 3 cover false claims about codes of conduct. These rules come straight from the EU Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (2005/29/EC, Annex I).

The common scenarios are rarely deliberate fraud: a retailer reusing a supplier's label for another product range, a franchise network displaying the head office's label when each outlet must be audited, or a business continuing to show a logo after its licence has expired.

Sustainability labels

Directive (EU) 2024/825 added to the EU blacklist "displaying a sustainability label which is not based on a certification scheme or not established by public authorities". Member States had to adopt their measures by 27 March 2026 and apply them from 27 September 2026. As at 15 November 2026, Article L. 121-4 of the French Consumer Code had not yet been amended on Légifrance to reflect this point. Environmental and social labels nonetheless remain subject to the general misleading practices rules, which French courts read in the light of the directive.

Certification, label, award, ranking: four different legal realities

Certification

"Certified" has a precise meaning in French law. Certification is the activity by which a body distinct from the manufacturer, importer, seller or customer attests that a product or service conforms to the characteristics described in a certification standard (Article L. 433-3). Only accredited bodies may certify (Article L. 433-4). Any reference to certification must state the name of the certification body or the guarantee mark, the name of the standard used and how it can be consulted (Article R. 433-2). Failing to do so is a minor offence of the fifth class (Article R. 453-1). Agricultural, food and seafood products follow a separate regime (Article L. 433-8).

Private labels and network charters

Many "labels" are private signs created by an association, a trade federation or a company, whose use depends on a licence and a set of rules. For the business displaying one, two documents matter: the current authorisation to use it and the rules defining its scope.

Awards such as "product of the year"

Industry awards rely on very different methods: laboratory tests, consumer panels, mystery calls, online votes or professional juries. Most require an application, and many a participation fee or a licence fee to use the logo. None of this is unlawful. The risk arises when the presentation suggests a judgment that is broader, more recent or more independent than the one actually made.

Rankings and "No. 1" claims

"No. 1 in sales" or "market leader" states a measurable fact. It needs an identifiable source, a period and a scope. When the claim compares goods or services by identifying a competitor, even implicitly, it is also comparative advertising, which must compare "essential, relevant, verifiable and representative" characteristics objectively (Article L. 122-1).

What you display Legal nature What you must be able to produce Consumer Code
"Certified product" with a certification body's logo Certification by an accredited body Valid certificate, standard, name of the body, how to consult the standard L. 433-3 to L. 433-6, R. 433-2
Quality label or trade association logo Private sign used under licence and rules Current authorisation, rules, proof that your products or outlet are covered L. 121-4, points 1 to 4
"Product of the year", "customer service of the year" Award given by a third party, often after a paid application Contest rules, year and category, method, logo licence L. 121-2, L. 121-3
"No. 1 in sales", "market leader" Factual claim about market position Source, period, scope (country, channel, category), calculation method L. 121-2
"No. 1 ahead of brand X" Comparative advertising Proof of the material accuracy of each element, available within a short time L. 122-1 to L. 122-5

What the French Supreme Court decided on 24 June 2026

The case

In a judgment of 24 June 2026 (No. 24-16.770, published in the Court's bulletin), the commercial chamber of the Cour de cassation ruled on a dispute between award organisers. The company running a "customer service of the year" contest sued two competitors that awarded a rival "customer relationship of the year" trophy, alleging unfair commercial practices and seeking an injunction and damages. The Paris Court of Appeal had dismissed the claim on 5 April 2024.

The rule

The Court dismissed the appeal. Relying on the definition in Directive 2005/29/EC and on the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union (RLvS, C-391/12, 17 October 2013), it held that when a trader's practice is not directly connected with the promotion, sale or supply of its own products to consumers, it is not a commercial practice within the meaning of Articles L. 121-1 et seq. of the Consumer Code. Designing and awarding the trophies did not concern the promotion or sale of a product to consumers. The Court declined to refer a question to the Court of Justice.

What it means for businesses that display an award

The judgment does not validate award badges in general. No award-winning business was a party to the case. When a business displays an award on its website or packaging to win customers, that communication is directly connected with the promotion of its own products, and the misleading practices rules apply in full. The Court also recalled that, under EU case law, where a trader's practices are carried out by another business acting on its behalf, the rules may apply to both. Agencies running the campaign are therefore exposed as well.

The proof you will be asked for

What the authority can demand

When investigating misleading practices, officials may require the person responsible for the practice to provide "all the evidence capable of substantiating the claims, indications or presentations, including where that evidence is held by a manufacturer established outside France" (Article L. 512-15). This comes on top of their general power to obtain documents of any kind (Article L. 512-8), explained in our article on DGCCRF requests for documents. Importers and distributors that display the manufacturer's award must therefore be able to obtain the supporting documents quickly.

What a criminal court can demand

The criminal court may order the parties and the advertiser to produce all useful documents, with a daily penalty of up to €4,500 for late production (Article L. 132-6). Refusing to provide the supporting evidence is itself punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine (Article L. 132-7).

Comparative claims: proof "within a short time"

For comparative advertising, the advertiser "must be able to prove within a short time the material accuracy" of what the advertisement states (Article L. 122-5). Comparative claims are also prohibited on packaging, invoices, transport tickets, means of payment and admission tickets (Article L. 122-4). A "better than brand X" claim printed on a box is unlawful even if it is true.

Common mistakes that turn a real award into a misleading claim

  • The ageing award: a 2023 award displayed without a date in 2026, especially after the product has changed, is information provided "in an untimely manner".
  • The extended scope: an award won by one model, category or outlet displayed across the whole range or network.
  • The paid contest presented as an independent verdict: paying to enter is lawful; presenting the result as a market-wide independent selection may mislead about the scope of the award.
  • The suspended official sign: continuing to display a public quality sign after it has been suspended, or for activities it does not cover.
  • The "No. 1" built on customer reviews: the comparison base must be sound, and claiming that reviews come from genuine customers without taking steps to check them is itself deemed misleading (Article L. 121-4, points 27 and 28).

Penalties and procedure

Criminal penalties

Misleading practices are punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine. The fine can be raised, in proportion to the benefits derived, to 10% of average annual turnover over the last three years, or 50% of the cost of the advertising or practice. Online, the penalties rise to five years and €750,000 (Article L. 132-2). Imprisonment rises to three years when the practice led to contracts (Article L. 132-2-1). For companies, the maximum fine is five times that for individuals (Article 131-38 of the Criminal Code). Managers face a ban of up to five years on running a business (Article L. 132-3), and the court orders publication of the judgment and may order corrective advertisements (Article L. 132-4). The offence is committed "as soon as the practice is implemented or produces its effects in France" (Article L. 132-1), which covers foreign sellers targeting French customers.

Offence or measure Legal basis Maximum
Misleading commercial practice Consumer Code L. 121-2 to L. 121-4, L. 132-2 Individual: 2 years and €300,000 (5 years and €750,000 online), or 10% of turnover, or 50% of advertising costs. Company: five times the fine
Practice followed by contracts Consumer Code L. 132-2-1 Imprisonment raised to 3 years
Refusal to provide supporting evidence to the court Consumer Code L. 132-6, L. 132-7 2 years and €300,000; daily penalty up to €4,500
Reference to certification without the required details Consumer Code R. 433-2, R. 453-1 Fifth-class minor offence
Compliance order Consumer Code L. 521-1 Daily penalty up to €3,000, €300,000 in total

Administrative routes

Not every case reaches court. After an adversarial procedure, officials may order the business to comply, with a daily penalty of up to €3,000 and €300,000 in total (Article L. 521-1). As long as prosecution has not started, the authority may also propose a criminal settlement with the prosecutor's agreement, including for misleading practices (Article L. 523-1). If an administrative fine is later imposed on another ground, see our guide on how to challenge a DGCCRF fine.

What is at stake in your reply

Correcting the material quickly usually helps, but a poorly documented correction can read as an admission. Sending too much may open other issues; sending too little leaves the claim unsupported. Which documents to send, how to present the method behind the award and what position to take on the legal qualification are decisions to make with counsel, case by case.

Frequently asked questions

Can I put a "product of the year" badge on my packaging in France?

Yes, if the award was genuinely won for that product, you hold the right to use the logo, and the year and category are clearly shown. You must be able to produce the contest rules, the results and the licence agreement on request.

Do I need evidence to claim "No. 1 in sales"?

Yes. The claim needs an identified source, period and scope, and the DGCCRF can demand all evidence substantiating it (Article L. 512-15). If the claim identifies a competitor, even implicitly, you must be able to prove it within a short time (Article L. 122-5).

What is the penalty for displaying a label without authorisation?

It is a practice deemed misleading in all circumstances (Article L. 121-4, point 2), punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine for an individual, five years and €750,000 online, with fines five times higher for a company.

Is a paid award unlawful?

No. Paying to enter a contest or to use an award logo is lawful. The risk lies in presenting the award as a broader or more independent judgment than it is.

What did the French Supreme Court decide on 24 June 2026?

That organising and awarding trophies is not, for the organiser, a commercial practice towards consumers, because it is not directly connected with the promotion or sale of its own products. The judgment does not cover businesses that display the award to sell their products: their communication remains fully subject to the misleading practices rules.

Do these rules apply to business-to-business marketing?

Yes. Articles L. 121-2 to L. 121-4 also apply to practices aimed at professionals (Article L. 121-5).

Key actions

  • Before using an award or label: collect the licence, the rules, the results and the scope, and show the year and category next to the logo.
  • Before claiming "No. 1": identify the source, period and scope, and check whether the claim is comparative.
  • When a label expires or is suspended: remove it from every channel, including marketplaces and printed material, and keep dated evidence of the removal.
  • When the DGCCRF asks for substantiation: note the deadline, list every medium concerned and have the reply reviewed before sending it.

Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.