France's Conseil d'État, 27 October 2026: a €590,000 late payment fine stands. Buyers must request missing invoices. What to keep as evidence.

A French buyer cannot avoid a late payment fine by arguing that its suppliers' invoices arrived late. The statutory period runs from the date the invoice is issued, and French law requires the buyer to request any invoice it has not received. On 27 October 2026 the Conseil d'État (France's highest administrative court) refused to hear an appeal against a €590,000 fine built on that reasoning.
Updated: November 2026. Key provisions: Articles L. 441-9, L. 441-10, L. 441-11, L. 441-16 and L. 470-2 of the French Commercial Code; Conseil d'État, 27 October 2026, No. 516079; Lyon Administrative Court of Appeal, 26 March 2026, No. 25LY00835.
Payment terms between businesses in France are policed by the DGCCRF (the French authority for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control), mostly through its regional offices within the DREETS (regional directorates for the economy, employment, labour and solidarity). They impose administrative fines themselves, without going to court, and publish them. If your French subsidiary or your company trading in France is being inspected, a lawyer for DGCCRF and DDPP inspections can tell you which arguments still carry weight. The worked example below is fictitious.
CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION
The facts come from the judgment of the Lyon Administrative Court of Appeal of 26 March 2026, which we have read in full. The regional DREETS inspected a retailer's payments for 2021. Its inspection report is dated 20 July 2022. On 6 March 2023, the regional director imposed a fine of €590,000: €400,000 for breaching the general payment periods of Article L. 441-10 of the Commercial Code, and €190,000 for breaching the 30-day period that applies to transport services (Article L. 441-11, II, 5°). The decision was also published as a notice on the DGCCRF website for nine months.
The Lyon Administrative Court dismissed the company's challenge on 28 January 2025, the Court of Appeal dismissed its appeal on 26 March 2026, and the Conseil d'État refused to admit its appeal on points of law on 27 October 2026.
Appeals to the Conseil d'État first go through an admission stage, and admission is refused where no ground is serious (Article L. 822-1 of the French Code of Administrative Justice). That is what happened here: the court listed the company's criticisms of the appeal judgment, including the dismissal of its argument based on its suppliers' failure to send invoices, and held that none justified admission. The decision is unreported and does not lay down a new rule. It does, however, leave in place a very explicit appeal judgment.
Between businesses, the agreed payment period cannot exceed 60 days from the date the invoice is issued. By way of exception, the parties may agree on 45 days end of month from the invoice date, provided this is expressly stipulated in the contract and is not grossly unfair to the creditor. If nothing has been agreed, payment is due within 30 days of receipt of the goods or performance of the service (Article L. 441-10, I).
Article L. 441-11 sets shorter or different periods for several sectors. The one most often found in inspections is 30 days from the invoice date for road haulage, vehicle rental, freight forwarding, customs brokerage and similar activities (Article L. 441-11, II, 5°). In the Lyon case, this rule alone cost the company €190,000.
The Court of Appeal put it plainly: any late payment, "even by one day", is a breach of these mandatory maximum periods. Payment is deemed made on the date the funds are made available to the supplier, not the date of your transfer order (Article L. 441-9, I).
In the general case, the clock starts on the invoice date. An invoice issued on 2 March with a 60-day term must be paid by 1 May, even if it only reaches your accounts payable team on 25 April. In the Lyon case, the inspection report recorded that 2,756 invoices had reached the company after their payment deadline, according to the group's own accountant. The company argued that it could not pay what it had not received.
The Commercial Code requires the seller to issue the invoice on delivery or performance, and adds a short sentence that carries a lot of weight: "The buyer is required to request it" (Article L. 441-9, I). The Court of Appeal noted that the company had never requested the missing invoices. That was enough to dispose of the argument.
The company had launched a portal in March 2021 on which suppliers were invited to upload their invoices. The court held that the portal probably made dealings with suppliers easier but did not satisfy the buyer's duty to request invoices. Supplier portals, dedicated mailboxes or a clause in your purchasing terms are useful, but they do not replace a written request linked to a specific delivery that was not invoiced.
Finally, the court held that the company could not "seriously" try to excuse its own breaches by pointing to its suppliers' failings. A supplier that invoices late is itself exposed to a separate fine of up to €375,000 for a company (Article L. 441-9, II). Each party answers for its own obligations.
The figures in the judgment show how the authority reasons. The 5,353 general invoices paid late (11% of invoices, 7% by value) gave the company a cash-flow advantage of €1,481,363.91; the 892 late transport invoices (29% by number, 38% by value) an advantage of €458,906.08. Against those figures and a €2 million ceiling, €590,000 was held not to be disproportionate.
The company also asked the Conseil d'État to refer a constitutional question: Article L. 470-2 of the Commercial Code does not require the authority to inform the company of its right to remain silent when it is invited to submit observations. The Conseil d'État restated the principle: the right to remain silent applies to any sanction that is punitive, and a person cannot be heard on the alleged breaches without first being told of that right. It nevertheless refused to refer the question, because the sanction procedure before a State authority such as the DREETS is a matter for regulations, not statute, "under the supervision of the competent court".
The practical consequence is that the right still applies; it is up to the court hearing a challenge to a specific fine to check whether it was respected. How and when your staff were heard, and what was written in your observations, matters. Before the decision, you have 60 days to consult the file and submit written and, where relevant, oral observations (Article L. 470-2, IV). Our page on the DGCCRF notice of intended fine and the adversarial phase explains that stage.
The maximum fine is €75,000 for an individual and €2 million for a company, raised to €150,000 and €4 million for a repeat breach within two years of the date on which a first sanction became final (Article L. 441-16). Clauses or practices that unduly delay the start of the payment period carry the same penalties. Late payment fines are always published on the authority's website and, at the company's expense, in a legal notices publication in the département where it is domiciled; failure to publish can lead to a daily penalty of €150 (Article L. 470-2, V). For the wider rules, see our guide to payment terms between businesses in France.
Every delivery or service received without an invoice should trigger a written request to the supplier, linked to the delivery note or order number, and kept on file. A general reminder sent to all suppliers once a quarter does not carry the same weight.
The receipt date does not change the legal starting point, but it is evidence. It lets you show which delays came from late or misaddressed invoices, and whether the issue date printed on an invoice matches the date it was actually sent.
Under Article 289 bis of the French General Tax Code, invoices between taxable businesses established in France must be issued, transmitted and received electronically through an approved platform. This applies to invoices issued from 1 September 2026, and from 1 September 2027 for invoices issued by micro, small and medium-sized enterprises (a decree can postpone that date to 1 December 2027 at the latest) (Law No. 2022-1157 of 16 August 2022, Article 26, III). Once invoices go through a platform, issue and receipt dates are traceable, which leaves little room for the "never received" argument.
An acceptance or verification procedure cannot in principle exceed 30 days from receipt, and cannot extend or postpone the payment period unless the contract expressly provides otherwise and the clause is not unfair (Article L. 441-10, III).
A distributor with annual turnover of €80 million is inspected on the previous year's payments. The inspector extracts 14,000 invoices and finds 1,200 paid more than 60 days after issue, with an average delay of 22 days and a cash-flow advantage of €310,000. The notice of intended fine proposes €120,000 and publication. The finance team explains that 400 invoices arrived weeks late because two suppliers kept sending paper invoices to a former head office.
Put that way, the argument will fail if the company never told those suppliers about its new billing address and never chased the missing invoices. The useful discussion lies elsewhere: whether the payment dates used are the dates funds reached the suppliers, whether credit notes and disputed invoices were handled correctly, whether any written reminders can be found, and how staff were heard during the inspection. Each point can reduce the number of breaches or the amount, and each needs to be prepared with counsel before the observations are filed.
As a rule, no. The agreed period runs from the invoice date and the buyer must request any invoice it has not received (Articles L. 441-10, I and L. 441-9, I of the Commercial Code). Written, dated requests can change the assessment, without guaranteeing that no fine will be imposed.
€2 million for a company and €75,000 for an individual, doubled for a repeat breach within two years of a first final sanction (Article L. 441-16). The decision is published.
No. Each invoice paid late is a separate breach. Early payments may only be relevant to the proportionality of the amount.
Yes. The Conseil d'État confirmed on 27 October 2026 that the right applies to punitive sanctions, while holding that the procedure is a matter for regulations. Whether it was respected is checked by the court hearing a challenge to the fine.
Three full years from the day of the breach, unless an act aimed at investigating, recording or sanctioning it takes place within that period (Article L. 470-2, II). In the Lyon case, payments made in 2021 were recorded in July 2022 and sanctioned in March 2023.
Two months from notification of the decision, extended by two months for persons residing outside France when the court sits in metropolitan France (Articles R. 421-1 and R. 421-7 of the Code of Administrative Justice). See our guide on how to challenge a DGCCRF fine in France.
Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.