French retailer charged unlawful logistics penalties? What suppliers can recover: proof, five-year limit, designated courts and group actions.

A supplier can recover logistics penalties that did not comply with Article L. 441-17 of the French Commercial Code, but not automatically. An administrative injunction ordering a retailer to stop unlawful penalty practices does not refund anyone: each supplier has to identify the unlawful deductions, claim them within the five-year limitation period and bring the case before one of the designated commercial courts.
Updated: November 2026. Key provisions: Articles L. 441-17, L. 441-19, L. 442-1, L. 442-4, L. 444-1 A, L. 110-4 and D. 442-2 of the French Commercial Code; Articles 1302 to 1302-3, 1347-1, 1352-6, 1352-7, 2224, 2240 and 2241 of the French Civil Code; Article 16 of Law No. 2025-391 of 30 April 2025 (group actions).
Logistics penalties are the sums French retailers charge suppliers for late, incomplete or off-slot deliveries. Since 1 April 2023 they have been strictly regulated, and the authorities now enforce those rules. This guide is written for manufacturers and brand owners, in France or abroad, who supply French retail chains and want to know what they can claim back, over what period and how. If the commercial relationship is at stake, the claim should be prepared with a commercial contracts and distribution lawyer in Paris. All examples are fictitious.
CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION
According to the announcement published by the DGCCRF (the French authority for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control), officials working within the DREETS Hauts-de-France (the regional directorate for the economy, employment, labour and solidarity) ordered a national retail chain on 10 March 2026 to stop its unlawful logistics penalty clauses and practices towards suppliers by 10 September 2026. The order carries a daily penalty of €104,167 for each day of delay, for up to 360 days from 11 September 2026. The DGCCRF reminded retailers that any logistics failure attributed to a supplier must be proven by the retailer when the penalty notice is sent, and that the retailer's loss must be demonstrated.
The announcement cites no article. The French Commercial Code allows authorised officials, after an adversarial procedure, to order a business to comply with its obligations, stop any unlawful conduct or delete any unlawful clause, with a daily penalty where the breach can lead to a civil fine (Article L. 470-1). As of 15 November 2026, no official publication reports on what happened after the September 2026 deadline.
The injunction looks to the future. It orders the retailer to stop certain practices; it does not order repayment of past penalties and it does not decide which deductions, at which supplier, were unlawful. It is an administrative decision against the retailer, not a judgment on your claim. To get money back, the supplier must act itself and show, penalty by penalty, that the law was not complied with.
The Minister for the Economy and the public prosecutor may also go to court against the retailer. They can ask for the practices to stop, for unlawful clauses to be declared void and for undue benefits to be returned, provided the victims are informed of the action, and they can seek a civil fine of up to the highest of €5 million, three times the undue benefits or 5% of the retailer's turnover in France (Article L. 442-4, I). A supplier has no control over whether or when such an action is brought, or which sums it covers.
When a retailer sends a penalty notice, it must at the same time provide proof of the failure and proof of its loss. The supplier then has a reasonable period to check and, if need be, dispute the claim. The DGCCRF guidelines (November 2023 version) state that this period must be at least one month from receipt of the notice and its supporting documents. A notice without supporting evidence, or one that asserts a loss without demonstrating it, does not meet the requirement.
Penalties must be proportionate to the loss, up to a cap of 2% of the value of the products ordered in the product category where the failure occurred. According to the DGCCRF guidelines, the base is all products ordered in that category and the cap is calculated order by order, not annually. On a fictitious order of €40,000 of dry biscuits, the cap is €800: a €1,500 penalty exceeds it by €700. No penalty may be charged for a failure that occurred more than one year earlier. This rule limits what the retailer can charge; it is not a time limit on your claim.
The retailer may not deduct penalties automatically from the supplier's invoice. According to the DGCCRF's questions and answers, such a deduction exists where the supplier disputed the penalty within the contractual period and the retailer still withheld it from payment. Only situations that caused stock shortages can justify penalties, unless the retailer demonstrates and documents a loss in writing. Circumstances beyond the parties' control must be taken into account, and no penalty can be charged in a case of force majeure. Refusing or returning goods is prohibited unless they are non-compliant or the delivery date was missed. Finally, the retailer cannot require payment of penalties on terms shorter than its own payment terms from receipt of goods; for the general rules, see our guide to payment terms between businesses in France.
These rules apply to penalties charged since 1 April 2023. Earlier penalties are governed by the previous version of the article, which must be reviewed case by case.
A refund claim is built line by line. For each penalty you need the notice and its attachments, the penalty invoice, your dispute and any reply, the remittance advice showing the deduction, the purchase orders broken down by product category, delivery data (booking slots, consignment notes, reservations) and the logistics agreement in force at the time. The law is rarely the difficulty; the volume and dispersion of the data usually are. How to structure the reconciliation should be settled with counsel before the first letter is sent.
Every supplier must report to the DGCCRF, by 31 December each year, the logistics penalties charged by its retailers over the previous twelve months and the amounts actually paid (Article L. 441-19). The guidelines ask for a month-by-month, retailer-by-retailer breakdown. Failing to file exposes a company to an administrative fine of up to €500,000, raised to €1 million for a repeat breach within two years. A supplier that files carefully already holds the basis of a claim; the next deadline is 31 December 2026.
A biscuit manufacturer with €9 million of turnover, €3.2 million of it with one national chain, received 412 penalty notices between April 2023 and September 2026, and €186,000 was withheld from its invoices. After reconciliation, €71,000 was deducted despite disputes filed in time, €54,000 exceeded the 2% cap order by order, €23,000 penalised delays with no stock shortage and no documented loss, and €38,000 appears justified. The claim therefore covers €148,000 plus interest. Deductions made in early 2022, under the previous rules, will become time-barred from early 2027 if the supplier knew of them when they were made.
A supplier's claim is subject to a five-year limitation period: obligations arising between traders in the course of business are time-barred after five years (Article L. 110-4, I, of the Commercial Code), and personal actions are time-barred five years from the day the claimant knew or should have known the facts enabling it to act (Article 2224 of the Civil Code). For a deduction from an invoice, that day is usually the date of the reduced payment. Each deduction therefore has its own starting point, and the oldest ones must be dealt with first.
Two events interrupt the period and start a new one: a court claim, even for interim relief and even before a court without jurisdiction (Article 2241), and an acknowledgement by the debtor of the claimant's right (Article 2240). The law gives no such effect to a mere letter of complaint, even sent by registered post. A negotiation that drags on can cost the oldest deductions if it is not managed with this in mind.
Anything received that was not owed must be returned (Articles 1302 and 1302-1 of the Civil Code). Under the Commercial Code, only the victim of the restrictive practice may have unlawful clauses declared void and claim restitution of undue benefits (Article L. 442-4, I); imposing logistics penalties that breach Article L. 441-17 is one of those practices (Article L. 442-1, I, 3°). Restitution may be reduced if the payment resulted from a fault (Article 1302-3), an argument a retailer may raise against a supplier that never disputed anything.
Restitution of money includes interest at the statutory rate (Article 1352-6). A recipient acting in bad faith owes interest from the date of payment; one acting in good faith owes it only from the date of the claim (Article 1352-7). Over three years, the difference is significant, and showing bad faith, for instance where penalties were maintained despite reasoned disputes, is a matter of evidence.
Imposing unlawful logistics penalties makes the retailer liable for the harm caused (Article L. 442-1, I). Beyond the refund, a supplier may claim separate, proven losses such as handling costs or the cost of financing withheld cash, and may ask the court to order the practices to stop. Retailers sometimes respond to a claim by offering a credit note or by setting off the amounts against other debts. Set-off only applies between debts that are certain, liquid and due (Article 1347-1); a disputed penalty is none of those, and automatic deduction of penalties is prohibited by Article L. 441-17. A settlement credit note can be a sensible outcome, but its wording should be reviewed before signature.
Disputes under Article L. 442-1 are assigned to courts designated by decree (Article L. 442-4, III). For traders, Annex 4-2-1 to Book IV of the Commercial Code designates eight commercial courts: Marseille, Bordeaux, Tourcoing, Fort-de-France, Lyon, Nancy, Paris and Rennes, each covering the area of several courts of appeal. Appeals go to the Paris Court of Appeal (Article D. 442-2). Bringing the claim before a court that is not designated leads to a procedural dispute that costs months and may jeopardise the claim.
Since 1 April 2023, Article L. 444-1 A makes these rules apply to any agreement between a supplier and a buyer covering products or services sold in France. They are mandatory, and disputes over their application fall within the exclusive jurisdiction of the French courts, subject to EU law, international treaties and arbitration. A supplier based outside France can therefore rely on them against a French retail chain, and an arbitration clause or a buying office in another Member State calls for a specific review before any claim is filed.
Suppliers of the same retailer often faced the same clauses. Between businesses, the safest route remains individual claims run in a coordinated way: a shared method and shared background documents, but a separate claim for each supplier, calculated on its own notices and deductions. When several cases are pending before the same court, the judge may join them (Article 367 of the French Code of Civil Procedure). Coordination must respect confidentiality and avoid any exchange between competitors on prices or terms.
Law No. 2025-391 of 30 April 2025 created a general group action regime, in force since 3 May 2025. Under its Article 16, the action is brought on behalf of several natural or legal persons in a similar situation resulting from the same breach, or a breach of the same kind, by a person acting in the course of business; it may seek an end to the breach, compensation for losses of any kind, or both. A supplier company can therefore be a member of the group. It cannot bring the action itself: claimants are approved associations, associations registered for at least two years (for cessation only), farmers' and fishers' organisations for their members, qualified entities under Directive (EU) 2020/1828 and the public prosecutor (for cessation). Cases go to specially designated civil courts. A clause preventing participation in a group action is deemed unwritten. The regime is recent and, to our knowledge, has not yet been used for logistics penalties; how it fits with the designated commercial courts of Article L. 442-4 is unsettled.
The commercial risk is real, but the law offers protection. Abruptly ending an established commercial relationship, even partially, without written notice that takes account of the length of the relationship, makes the party ending it liable (Article L. 442-1, II). Where the length of notice is disputed, no liability arises for insufficient notice if eighteen months' notice was given, and termination without notice remains possible for the other party's failure to perform or for force majeure. A delisting that closely follows a refund claim will be examined in the light of that chronology. Timing matters too: a claim sent in the middle of the annual negotiation does not have the same effect as one sent outside it.
Yes, where the penalty breached Article L. 441-17: no proof of the failure and the loss with the notice, the 2% cap exceeded, a failure more than one year old, automatic deduction despite a dispute, or a penalty without a stock shortage or documented loss. Each penalty must be analysed separately.
Five years (Article L. 110-4 of the Commercial Code and Article 2224 of the Civil Code), usually counted from the date of each deduction. Only a court claim or a written acknowledgement by the retailer interrupts it.
No. It orders the retailer to stop unlawful clauses and practices, under a daily penalty. Repayment requires a claim by each supplier, or an action by the Minister or the public prosecutor under Article L. 442-4.
A supplier can be a member of a group action under Law No. 2025-391, but cannot file it: an approved association or the public prosecutor must do so. Coordinated individual claims, which the court may join, remain the usual route.
One of eight designated commercial courts (Marseille, Bordeaux, Tourcoing, Fort-de-France, Lyon, Nancy, Paris, Rennes), depending on the area, with appeals to the Paris Court of Appeal.
Yes, for products sold in France: Article L. 444-1 A makes the rules mandatory for any supplier-buyer agreement covering products or services sold on French territory, subject to EU law, treaties and arbitration. The details of your contract and the buyer's location still need to be checked.
Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.