Retention money in construction: bond, guarantee or escrow

5% retention money in private contracts: the 1971 Act, mandatory escrow, one-year time limit, and how to replace it with a bond or escrow account.

On every contract it signs, a construction company almost automatically accepts a few lines of text that tie up 5% of its turnover for at least twelve months. This is known as the retention money. Multiplied across numerous projects and extended by delayed releases, it becomes the primary source of dormant cash flow for SMEs in the construction sector.

The legal framework for this retention is actually much more favorable to companies than common practice suggests. The Act No. 71-584 of July 16, 1971, which applies to private construction contracts as defined in Article 1779-3° of the Civil Code, strictly regulates it: a 5% cap on progress payments, a mandatory requirement to place funds in escrow with a third party, automatic release one year after project completion, and the nullity of any clause to the contrary. On construction sites, these three obligations are violated daily, yet companies rarely face the consequences.

This guide details this mandatory framework, the three instruments available to avoid it without damaging business relationships - personal and joint surety bonds, first-demand guarantees, and notarized escrow agreements - as well as the method for recovering unreleased retentions and the clauses to negotiate before signing. It is intended for general contractors, tradespeople, SMEs, and mid-sized construction firms, including technical specialists such as elevator installers, HVAC engineers, and electricians, as well as professional project owners. Our business lawyers in Paris provide support for both contract negotiations and disputes over final contract balances.

Retention money: the forgotten cash reserve for construction companies

5% tied up on every contract, with no interest

The project owner retains 5% of the price without paying any interest, even though the company has already incurred labor, material, and subcontracting costs. On a 400,000 euro (excl. tax) contract, 20,000 euros of gross margin remain locked up for at least one year after completion - equivalent to the entire project profit for a company with a net margin of around 3 to 5%. The difficulties of collecting unpaid invoices in the construction industry only add to this structural capital immobilization.

The cumulative effect on an SME's cash flow

Take an HVAC SME with 6 million euros in turnover across thirty private contracts: if retention is applied everywhere, 300,000 euros are permanently held by third parties. Since releases are delayed by one year after each completion and new projects are constantly starting, this stock never clears: it becomes a permanent outstanding balance, financed by overdrafts or factoring, with annual carrying costs reaching tens of thousands of euros without ever appearing in general accounting.

A significant abandonment rate in practice

A large portion of retention money is never claimed. In addition to losses due to negligence, there is deliberate abandonment, where companies feel that legal action for 10,000 euros is not cost-effective or fear damaging a business relationship. This calculation is almost always wrong: the 1971 Act puts the company in a very strong position, making an amicable resolution more likely than one might think. Abandonment is a learned behavior.

The mandatory framework of the Act of July 16, 1971

Scope: private construction contracts

The Act of July 16, 1971, applies to construction contracts as defined by Article 1779-3° of the Civil Code, meaning private contracts concluded between a project owner and a contractor. The scope is broad: new construction, renovation, technical finishing work, and equipment replacement, provided the service falls under a contract for work. Public procurement contracts are subject to the separate regime of the Public Procurement Code, and a subcontractor is better off securing the arrangement contractually rather than relying on its automatic application.

A 5% cap on progress payments

Article 1 of the Act states that progress payments on the final value of construction contracts may be subject to a retention of no more than 5% of their amount, contractually guaranteeing the execution of the work to satisfy, if necessary, any reservations made upon completion. Three key points emerge from this. The 5% rate is a ceiling, not a statutory rate: nothing prevents negotiating 3%, and nothing authorizes exceeding 5%. The base is the amount of the progress payments. Finally, the purpose is clearly defined: to guarantee the execution of the work and the resolution of any reservations, and nothing else.

A retention that must be stipulated in the contract

Retention is never a matter of right in a private contract: the text specifies that it guarantees contractually the execution of the work, which implies an express stipulation. A project owner who withholds 5% without such a clause is committing a partial non-payment, which is immediately due with late interest. This limited purpose is also an underutilized tool: construction delay penalties fall under a separate mechanism, and the company must insist that the reason for withholding funds relates to specific reservations identified in the handover report.

Public policy status: the nullity of contrary clauses

Article 3 of the Act is the cornerstone of the system: any clauses, stipulations, or arrangements that would have the effect of circumventing Articles 1 and 2 are null and void, regardless of their form. Consequently, a retention increased to 8%, a clause authorizing the project owner to keep the funds, a two-year deferred repayment, and any advance waiver of the benefits of the Act are all null and void.

The obligation to deposit funds with a third party: the most violated rule in the construction industry

The project owner cannot keep the funds in their own account

Article 2 of the Act requires the project owner to deposit with an escrow agent a sum equal to the amount withheld. In the vast majority of construction projects, the project owner simply chooses not to pay 5% of the progress payments: the funds never leave their account, no escrow agent is appointed, and no certificate is issued. The retention is then merely an unpaid debt falsely presented as a secured guarantee.

An escrow agent accepted or appointed by the president of the court

The escrow agent must be accepted by both parties or, in the absence of an agreement, appointed by the president of the court. The law does not provide an exhaustive list: a notary, a bank opening a specifically designated account, the Caisse des Dépôts et Consignations, or any other accepted professional third party. The text adds that if the withheld sums exceed the deposited amount, the project owner must top up the deposit: it therefore tracks the progress of the construction work.

Practical and legal consequences of failure to deposit

Case law draws a radical conclusion from this: a project owner who has failed to make the deposit cannot rely on the retention of guarantee scheme and must return the funds, notwithstanding the failure to resolve outstanding issues. A ruling by the Court of Cassation on December 18, 2013 (No. 12-29.472) is cited as the reference for this solution, which has since been confirmed by consistent case law. The first question in any case is therefore: where are the funds?

The one-year period: what no clause can extend

A single starting point: the acceptance of the work

The period runs from the acceptance of the work, the act by which the project owner declares that they accept the work with or without reservations, within the meaning of Article 1792-6 of the Civil Code. It does not depend on the resolution of reservations, the final statement of account, or the commissioning of the work. Two situations require vigilance: tacit acceptance, when the project owner has taken possession and paid the bulk of the price, and partial acceptance by lot, with each triggering its own time limit.

The nullity of clauses for deferred "final acceptance"

The most common clause involves inventing a concept of "final acceptance" distinct from the actual acceptance, and then setting the release date relative to that: one year after the resolution of reservations, two years after acceptance, or two years and one month after final acceptance. All of these fall under Article 3. A clause setting the return date at two years after acceptance is void without the need to demonstrate intent to defraud: the text targets arrangements that have the effect of evasion, so the effect alone is sufficient.

Relationship with the guarantee of perfect completion

The two mechanisms are constantly confused. The guarantee of perfect completion under Article 1792-6 of the Civil Code is a legal obligation incumbent upon the contractor for one year from the date of acceptance: to repair defects reserved or reported during that year. The retention money is a contractual financial mechanism. The coincidence in duration explains the confusion, but the expiration of the retention does not release the company from its guarantee of perfect completion, and the existence of defects does not authorize the retention of funds beyond one year without a formal objection.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       
Aspect of the rulesWhat the Act of July 16, 1971 requiresWhat clauses try to imposeSanction
Retention rateA maximum of 5% of the amount of interim payments (Article 1).7%, 8% or 10% of the contract, sometimes combined with a deduction for the shared site expenses account (compte prorata).Void for the portion exceeding 5%: immediate refund of the excess.
BasisThe amount of interim payments on the final value of the construction contract.A percentage of the total amount including VAT, revisions and amendments included.Dispute over the excess, which must be refunded as an irregular retention.
Holding of fundsDeposit with a stakeholder accepted by both parties or appointed by the president of the court (Article 2).Funds kept in the project owner's current account, with no designated third party.Loss of the benefit of the regime: release is due even if the reservations have not been lifted.
Start of the time limitAcceptance of the works, with or without reservations.A “final acceptance”, the lifting of the last reservation or the signing of the final statement of account.Void: the time limit is recalculated from actual acceptance.
DurationOne year from acceptance, with no possible extension.Two years, two years and one month, or even the expiry of the two-year warranty.Void: release is due from the first day of the thirteenth month.
Blocking the releaseReasoned objection notified to the stakeholder or guarantor by registered letter with acknowledgment of receipt.Mere verbal refusal, blocking email, silence about the reservations.Irregular objection: the full release remains due.

The client's objection: the mechanism that blocks restitution

A substantiated objection, notified by registered letter

Upon the expiration of the one-year period, the deposited sums are paid to the company or the bond is released, even if the reservations have not been lifted, if the client has not notified the depositary or the guarantor of their substantiated objection by registered letter with acknowledgment of receipt. Three cumulative conditions must be met: the notification must be made to the depositary or the guarantor and not just to the company, it must take the form of a registered letter with acknowledgment of receipt excluding email, and it must be substantiated by failures related to the reservations made at acceptance.

The lack of prior judicial oversight

The point that unbalances the system is the lack of any filter. The depositary who receives a formally compliant objection has neither the power nor the mandate to assess the validity of the reasons: they block the funds and await an agreement between the parties or a court decision. A bad-faith client can therefore block the restitution with a simple letter. This risk has its limits: unfounded objections expose the party to damages for abusive resistance, and an improperly formed objection can be dismantled as soon as a copy is obtained.

The obligation to summon and the cost of inaction

Once the objection has been notified, the burden of initiative lies with the company: it is up to them to petition the court to obtain the release of the funds. Inaction carries a triple cost: financial carrying costs, the degradation of technical evidence, and the risk of the five-year statute of limitations under Article 2224 of the Civil Code. A formal notice from a lawyer sent in the weeks following the expiration of the deadline is inexpensive and is often enough to resolve the situation.

The three alternatives to the retention bond and how to choose between them

The common logic: replacing an asset freeze with a commitment

The three alternatives are based on the same idea: rather than tying up 5% of the price, the company provides an equivalent security and collects the full amount of its progress payments. Article 2 expressly establishes the first of these: the retention is not applied if the contractor provides, for an equivalent amount, a personal and joint guarantee issued by a financial institution. This right belongs to the company, meaning that any clause prohibiting such substitution is open to challenge.

Guarantee, demand guarantee, and escrow: three risk management approaches

The personal and joint guarantee is an accessory commitment: the bank pays what the company owes and can raise defenses based on the contract. The demand guarantee is an independent commitment: the guarantor pays upon a simple compliant request, without debating the merits, which exposes the company to unjustified calls. The specific issues related to demand guarantees justify vigilance regarding the drafting of the commitment. The contractual escrow occupies an often optimal intermediate position: the funds leave the company's cash flow but also leave the client's assets, and no bank agreement is required.

How to make a practical decision

The decision depends on three factors. First, the status of surety bond lines: if they are available and inexpensive, the bond remains the preferred instrument since it does not tie up any cash. Second, the balance of power: when faced with rigid contract terms, an escrow is easier to get accepted than a clause modification, as it does not challenge the principle of the guarantee, only the method of its constitution. Finally, the amount: a flat fee of 1,000 euros excluding tax represents 20% of the retention on a 100,000 euro contract, but only 4% on a 500,000 euro contract.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       
CriterionPersonal and joint surety bondFirst-demand guaranteeContractual escrow
Legal natureAccessory personal security, expressly provided for in Article 2 of the 1971 Act.Autonomous undertaking by the guarantor, independent of the construction contract.Deposit of a disputed item with a third party (Articles 1956 et seq. of the Civil Code).
Cash flow impactOptimal: no cash outflow, the company collects 100% of interim payments.Optimal on the face of it, but the facility uses up the overall bank credit limit.Intermediate: funds tied up, but outside the project owner's assets.
Indicative costAnnual fee of around 0.5% to 2% of the guaranteed amount, plus arrangement fees.Generally higher fee, often with a counter-guarantee.Flat fee of around 1,000 euros excluding VAT, regardless of the amount held in escrow.
Risk of abusive callLow: the guarantor can raise defenses arising from the construction contract.High: payment upon a compliant demand; the company's recourse only after the debit.Low: the third party only releases funds under the conditions set by the agreement.
RequirementsApproval from a financial institution and a dedicated bonding facility.Stricter bank approval, reserved for companies with good credit ratings.No bank approval needed: available to young companies and those with maxed-out facilities.
Acceptance by the project ownerHard to refuse in a private contract, since the law expressly provides for this option.Very well accepted: it is the instrument most favorable to the beneficiary.Well accepted if presented as performance of the deposit obligation.

Notarized escrow agreements: how they work

The legal basis for escrow in the Civil Code

Conventional escrow is governed by Articles 1956 and following of the Civil Code. Article 1956 defines it as the deposit made by one or more persons of a disputed item into the hands of a third party who undertakes to return it, once the dispute is settled, to the person deemed entitled to receive it. The code provides that the escrow may not be free of charge, which allows for the remuneration of the third party, and that the depositary cannot be released before the end of the dispute, except with the consent of the interested parties or for a legitimate reason.

A solution that is both compliant and negotiable

The law requires that the retained sum be deposited with a custodian accepted by both parties. The notarized escrow fulfills this exact role of custodian : the notary is a trusted third party, equipped with a specially designated account, subject to strict professional obligations and the auditing of their accounts. Using a notary is therefore not a way to circumvent the law, but rather its literal execution. This is what makes escrow a solution that is both compliant and negotiable, a decisive argument when dealing with a reluctant project owner.

Drafting the amendment, the role of the notary, and the cost

Implementation requires an amendment or a tripartite agreement identifying the contract, the escrow amount and its calculation method, the escrow agent, the allocation of costs, and the release conditions. The most protective wording follows the legal mechanism: automatic release one year after acceptance, unless a reasoned objection is notified to the escrow agent by registered letter with a copy to the company, with partial release proportional to the resolved defects. The notary issues a certificate of escrow to be attached to the first payment application, for a flat fee of around 1,000 euros excluding tax.

Case study: substituting an escrow for a retention bond on a technical contract

The situation

An elevator company is awarded a contract for the replacement and maintenance of three units in a shopping center, for approximately 350,000 euros including all taxes. The general and specific terms and conditions provide for a 5% retention bond calculated on the total amount including taxes, i.e., around 17,400 euros, refundable two years and one month after final acceptance. No signed purchase order has been returned, payment is stipulated by check, and the first progress payment must be issued in the coming days.

Key points to address

The chosen strategy is to propose the substitution of a notary-held escrow, presented not as a dispute but as bringing the arrangement into compliance with the 1971 Act. Five key points must be addressed before the first progress payment is issued.

  • The two-year restitution clause is contrary to the public policy provisions of the 1971 Act. Restitution set two years and one month after an alleged final acceptance circumvents the one-year release requirement and is void under Article 3.
  • The 5% base calculated on the tax-inclusive amount warrants discussion. The law refers to 5% of the amount of progress payments, which leads to calculating based on pre-tax amounts: the difference here represents nearly 3,000 euros.
  • Payment by check is inappropriate. It extends timelines, leaves no usable record of the date funds were made available, and complicates proof of partial payment: bank transfer must be required.
  • The substitution must be established no later than the day the first progress payment is requested. A progress payment issued before the escrow is set up will be subject to the retention, which will then be very difficult to recover.
  • The absence of a signed purchase order weakens the entire contractual framework. It opens a debate regarding the enforceability of the terms and conditions, which are favorable regarding retention but unfavorable regarding price and deadlines: it is better to formalize this via an amendment.

Implementation and residual risk

The company will send a letter proposing the substitution, accompanied by a draft amendment specifying that the escrow serves as a deposit within the meaning of Article 2, that the amount is calculated on pre-tax progress payments, that release occurs automatically one year after acceptance, and that payment is made by bank transfer. A residual risk remains: the client may attempt to withhold 5% from the final balance. The escrow changes the nature of this, with the company then dealing with an ordinary unpaid debt, subject to late payment interest and the 40-euro fixed indemnity under Article L. 441-10 of the Commercial Code.

Public contracts: the distinct regime of the Public Procurement Code

A similar but autonomous mechanism

Public contracts are not governed by the 1971 Act but by the Public Procurement Code which organizes the guarantee retention under articles R. 2191-32 and following. Article R. 2191-32 specifies that its sole purpose is to cover any reservations made upon acceptance and, where applicable, those made during the warranty period when defects were not apparent. It is neither automatic nor mandatory and must be provided for in the specific contract documents. The ceiling is 5% of the initial amount plus any modifications, with a reduced rate for small and medium-sized enterprises for certain contracts.

Substitution and release

The retention is deducted in installments from progress payments, final partial payments, and the balance, and is reimbursed within thirty days from the expiration of the warranty period. The most notable difference concerns substitution: it can be replaced, at the contractor's discretion, by a first-demand guarantee or, if the buyer does not object, by a personal and joint surety, according to models set by the order of March 22, 2019. The hierarchy is therefore reversed compared to private contracts, where the surety is established by law.

Recovering an unreleased guarantee retention: the procedure to follow

Start with an audit of all accepted contracts

The first step is organizational: list all contracts accepted more than a year ago and, for each, record the date of acceptance, the amount retained, the identity of the fund holder, the existence of a deposit certificate, and any notified opposition. Files without a deposit are the priority category, as the technical debate is neutralized there. Next come irregular, late, or misdirected oppositions. The truly difficult cases are those where the deposit is regular, the opposition is correct, and the reservations are substantial.

The amicable and then judicial sequence

A request for release is sent to the project owner and the depositary, recalling the date of acceptance, the amount due, and the legal basis, while requesting the deposit certificate. In the absence of a response, a formal notice is sent by a lawyer. If the blockage persists, two fast-track routes exist: the summary provision order, based on Article 835 paragraph 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure before the president of the judicial court or Article 873 paragraph 2 before the president of the commercial court, and the payment order under articles 1405 and following.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                         
PhaseStepWhat it involvesIndicative timeframeIndicative cost
Amicable phase1. Audit of contracts accepted more than a year agoTable per contract: acceptance date, amount retained, holder of the funds, deposit certificate, any objection.1 to 3 weeks depending on the number of sites.In-house, or a fixed-fee portfolio audit.
2. Request for releaseLetter to the project owner and the stakeholder: reminder of the acceptance, the amount and the legal basis, and request for the deposit certificate.Reply expected within 15 days.Almost no cost.
3. Formal notice from a lawyerRegistered letter citing Article 3 of the 1971 Act, the nullity of contrary clauses and the consequences of failing to deposit the funds.Deadline of 8 to 15 days given.A few hundred euros excluding VAT depending on complexity.
Court phase4. Summary proceedings for an interim payment or order for paymentSummary proceedings for an interim payment where the obligation is not seriously disputable, or application for an order for payment (Articles 1405 et seq. of the Code of Civil Procedure).Order within 1 to 3 months depending on the court.Litigation fees, plus enforcement officer (commissaire de justice) costs.
5. Proceedings on the meritsAction for payment and lifting of the objection, with late-payment interest and damages for wrongful resistance.12 to 24 months, longer if a court-appointed expert is involved.Budget to be weighed against the amount at stake and the chances of success.

Negotiating the clause beforehand: points of vigilance before signing

The six parameters to lock down

All the energy spent recovering a blocked retention could have been saved with ten minutes of review before signing. Negotiating does not imply an overwhelming power struggle, but knowing what to ask for: six parameters deserve to be systematically locked down.

  • The ceiling must be expressly limited to a maximum of 5%, with the company able to propose 3% for technical contracts where the value of supplies is predominant.
  • The base must be defined as the pre-tax amount of the progress payments, which precludes any calculation based on the tax-inclusive amount.
  • The starting point must be the acceptance of the work as defined in Article 1792-6 of the Civil Code, excluding any notion of final acceptance or the lifting of the last reservation.
  • Formal requirements for an objection must be specified: a registered letter sent to the escrow agent before the one-year period expires, detailing the reservations and including a copy for the contractor.
  • Automatic substitution must be stipulated, allowing the contractor to replace the retention at any time with a bond, a first-demand guarantee, or an escrow account.
  • Payment terms must provide for a bank transfer to a designated account, within a timeframe compliant with legal caps and the automatic application of late payment interest.

Two complementary best practices

Two best practices can significantly improve a company's position. The first is to require, at the time of signing, the specific identification of the escrow agent in the contract: this two-line mention avoids later debates over the acceptance of the third party and provides a direct point of contact. The second is to set an alert for eleven months from the signing of the acceptance report to prepare the release request, and another for twelve months to send it. These automated steps eliminate almost all losses due to oversight, at no cost.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the repayment period for a security deposit?

In a private construction contract, the retention must be returned at the end of a period of one year from the acceptance of the work, whether with or without reservations, as stated in the signed acceptance report. At the end of this period, the escrowed funds are paid to the contractor even if the reservations have not been lifted, provided that no formal objection has been notified to the escrow agent by registered letter. In public procurement, reimbursement occurs within thirty days following the expiration of the warranty period.

Can the project owner keep the funds in their own account?

No. Article 2 of the Law of July 16, 1971, requires that an amount equal to the retention be deposited with an escrow agent accepted by both parties or, failing that, appointed by the president of the court. Keeping the funds in one's own account is a breach of a mandatory legal obligation. Case law draws a severe consequence from this: the project owner loses the benefit of the legal framework and must return the retained sums, regardless of whether the reservations have been lifted.

Is a two-year clause valid?

No, it is void. Article 3 of the law renders null and void any clauses, stipulations, or arrangements that would have the effect of circumventing Articles 1 and 2, regardless of their form. A clause setting the return period at two years, or two years and one month after a supposed final acceptance, deprives the contractor of the one-year release. It does not matter if it appears in the contract, in a set of specifications, or in general terms and conditions of purchase, and it does not matter if the contractor signed it: it is the effect of the clause that is penalized.

How can a security deposit be replaced by a bond or an escrow account?

The most robust approach in private contracts is a personal and joint guarantee from a financial institution, as expressly provided for in Article 2: once provided for an equivalent amount, the retention is not applied. If guarantee lines are unavailable, a conventional escrow is an effective alternative: an amendment designates an escrow notary, sets the amount and release conditions, and the notary issues a certificate to be attached to the first progress payment request. The request must be made before the first installment is issued.

What should you do if the retention is not released after one year?

Send a written request for release to the project owner and the escrow agent, citing the date of acceptance, the amount due, and the legal basis, while requesting the escrow certificate and any notified objections. If no escrow was established or if the objection is irregular, your position is very strong. In the absence of a response, a formal notice should be sent by a lawyer, followed by an application for an interim order or a payment injunction. You must act quickly: time degrades evidence and triggers the five-year statute of limitations.

Is the retention calculated on the pre-tax or post-tax amount?

Article 1 of the law provides for a retention equal to a maximum of 5% of the progress payments on the final value of the construction contract. The logic of the text leads to using a pre-tax base: value-added tax is not payment for the work but a sum collected on behalf of the Treasury. Many clauses, however, calculate the retention on the total amount including taxes, which increases the immobilized sum by approximately 20%. This point should be raised during negotiations and, failing that, upon release.

Do the retention of guarantee and the guarantee of perfect completion overlap?

These are two independent mechanisms that coexist without merging. The guarantee of perfect completion under Article 1792-6 of the Civil Code is a legal obligation of the contractor, who must repair any defects reserved or reported during the year following acceptance. The retention of guarantee is a contractual financial mechanism. Its release after one year does not discharge the company from its guarantee of perfect completion, nor from the two-year and ten-year warranties, and the existence of defects does not authorize the retention of funds without a regular, substantiated objection.

Conclusion

The retention of guarantee is one of the rare subjects in construction law where the imbalance observed in the field is the exact opposite of the legal imbalance. The Law of July 16, 1971, strongly protects construction companies: a mandatory cap of 5% on progress payments, an obligation to deposit funds with a third party, automatic release after one year, the nullity of any contrary clause, and the right to substitute a guarantee. Yet, these rules remain ignored on construction sites, bypassed by clauses providing for restitution after two years and neutralized by the inertia of the companies themselves.

Three reflexes are enough to turn the situation around. Before signing, negotiate the cap, the base, the starting point, the formalism of the objection, the right to automatic substitution, and the payment method. During execution, demand the identification of the escrow agent and their certificate, or propose a notarial escrow, which fulfills the exact function of the escrow agent provided for by law for a flat fee of around 1,000 euros excluding tax. After acceptance, set an alert at eleven months and send the request for release as soon as the one-year period expires, systematically questioning the actual status of the funds.

If several contracts accepted long ago have never resulted in a release, or if you are presented with a set of clauses providing for deferred restitution after two years, a quick audit of your portfolio often allows you to free up tens of thousands of euros in cash flow without initiating a conflict. Our firm assists construction companies and project owners in negotiating their clauses, setting up escrows and guarantees, and handling construction contract balance disputes.

Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.

Further reading:

‍