Dark patterns in France: when website design breaks the law

Fake countdowns, pre-ticked boxes, late costs, hard-to-cancel subscriptions: how French consumer law and the DSA treat dark patterns, and the fines.

When does website design break French consumer law?

When it misleads consumers, pressures them or charges them for options they did not expressly accept. In France, a fake countdown, a cost revealed only at the last step or an obstacle to cancelling can be a misleading or aggressive commercial practice, a criminal offence punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine for individuals, with higher penalties for companies and for misleading practices committed online. Pre-ticked paid options and missing cancellation or withdrawal functions carry administrative fines, and online platforms are also bound by the Digital Services Act.

Updated: November 2026. Key provisions: Articles L. 121-1 to L. 121-7, L. 121-17, L. 132-2, L. 132-11, L. 132-22, L. 133-1, L. 215-1-1, L. 221-14, L. 221-21, L. 241-3-1 and L. 521-3-1 of the French Consumer Code; Articles 3, 19, 25, 29 and 52 of Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 (Digital Services Act).

"Dark patterns" (interfaces trompeuses) are interface designs that steer users towards choices they would not otherwise make. French consumer law does not define them, but most of them fall under rules that already exist, enforced by the DGCCRF (the French authority for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control) and its local offices, the DDPP (departmental directorates for the protection of populations). This article is for online sellers, apps, subscription services and platforms, in France or abroad, that sell to consumers in France. It explains which rules apply to which design choices, and what sanctions follow. If you have received a request or a notice, a lawyer for DGCCRF and DDPP inspections can assess your exposure.

Would you like to discuss your situation? Book a consultation:

CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION

What counts as a dark pattern

The problem is not always a false statement. The information may be accurate and the terms available, but the layout, the visual hierarchy or the order of the steps pushes the consumer towards a decision. The designs most often discussed include:

  • fake urgency or scarcity: a countdown that resets on each visit, a "last items" message unrelated to actual stock, a number of viewers with no basis;
  • pre-ticked boxes: insurance, express delivery or a paid add-on selected by default;
  • drip pricing: costs revealed only at the last step of the checkout;
  • obstruction: subscribing in two clicks but cancelling by phone, by registered letter or through a series of retention pages;
  • nagging: repeatedly asking for a choice the user has already made, for example through pop-ups;
  • misleading hierarchy: a greyed-out refusal button, or a secondary action styled as the main one.

Each design has to be assessed on its own facts. The table below shows the main legal bases and penalties.

Design practice Legal basis (Consumer Code unless stated) Maximum penalty
False limited-time offer or fake countdown L. 121-4, 7° (always misleading) Criminal: 2 years and €300,000; 5 years and €750,000 online (L. 132-2); companies: five times the fine
False information on market conditions or availability L. 121-4, 17° As above (L. 132-2)
Costs revealed late, material information hidden or untimely L. 121-3 As above (L. 132-2)
Undisclosed paid ranking; unchecked or fake reviews L. 121-4, 25°, 27° and 28° As above (L. 132-2)
Onerous or disproportionate obstacle to cancelling or switching L. 121-6 Criminal: 2 years and €300,000, up to 10% of average annual turnover; publication of the conviction (L. 132-11)
Pre-ticked paid option L. 121-17 Administrative fine: €3,000 (individual) / €15,000 (company) (L. 132-22); refund to the consumer
Order button without "order with obligation to pay" L. 221-14 Administrative fine: €15,000 / €75,000 (L. 242-10)
Missing or non-compliant online cancellation function L. 215-1-1; D. 215-1 to D. 215-3 Administrative fine: €15,000 / €75,000 (L. 241-3-1)
Missing online withdrawal function (since 19 June 2026) L. 221-21 Administrative fine: €15,000 / €75,000 (L. 242-13)
Deceptive or manipulative interface of a marketplace Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, Article 25; L. 133-1 Criminal: 2 years and €300,000; up to 6% of worldwide turnover for a company (L. 133-1)

Misleading practices

Misleading actions

Unfair commercial practices are prohibited. A practice is unfair when it is contrary to the requirements of professional diligence and materially distorts, or is likely to materially distort, the economic behaviour of a consumer who is reasonably well informed, observant and circumspect (Article L. 121-1 of the French Consumer Code). A practice is misleading, in particular, when it relies on claims, indications or presentations that are false or likely to mislead about, among other things, the existence or availability of the product, its price or the way the price is calculated, the promotional nature of the price, the conditions of sale, payment and delivery, or the consumer's rights (Article L. 121-2). Because the text refers to "presentations", the layout of a page, and not only its wording, can be examined.

Misleading omissions

A practice is also misleading if it omits or hides material information, or provides it in an unintelligible, ambiguous or untimely manner (Article L. 121-3). "Untimely" is the word that fits many design practices: the information is there, but it comes too late to matter. In an invitation to purchase, material information includes the main characteristics of the product, the trader's identity and address, the price including taxes and delivery costs, unusual payment or delivery terms, and the right of withdrawal. Where consumers can search products offered by different traders or by private sellers, the main ranking parameters must be shown in a specific section directly and easily accessible from the results page. Where reviews are shown, information on whether and how the trader checks that they come from actual users is material (Article L. 121-3).

Practices always regarded as misleading

Article L. 121-4 lists practices regarded as misleading in all circumstances, without any need to show their effect on the consumer. Several concern interface design:

  • falsely stating that a product will be available only for a very limited time, or on particular terms for a very limited time, to obtain an immediate decision (7°);
  • presenting rights given to consumers by law as a distinctive feature of the offer (10°);
  • giving materially inaccurate information on market conditions or on the possibility of finding the product, to induce the consumer to buy on less favourable terms (17°);
  • describing a product as costing nothing, or using similar terms, when the consumer has to pay anything other than the unavoidable cost of responding and of collecting or receiving the item (19°);
  • showing search results without clearly disclosing payments made to obtain a higher ranking (25°);
  • stating that reviews come from consumers who used or bought the product without taking the necessary steps to check it, or posting or commissioning fake reviews (27° and 28°).

A countdown that resets on each visit, or that is not linked to any real end of the offer, is likely to fall under 7°.

Penalties

Misleading commercial practices are criminal offences, punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine. The fine can be raised, in proportion to the benefits derived, to 10% of average annual turnover or to 50% of the cost of the advertising or practice. When the offence is committed through an online public communication service or a digital medium, the penalties rise to five years and €750,000 (Article L. 132-2). For companies, the maximum fine is five times that for individuals (Article 131-38 of the French Criminal Code). These practices are not punished by an administrative fine: they are criminal offences, which the authority can also settle through a criminal transaction with the prosecutor's agreement, as long as prosecution has not started (Article L. 523-1).

Aggressive practices and obstacles to cancellation

A practice is aggressive when, through repeated and insistent solicitations or the use of physical or moral coercion, it significantly impairs or is likely to impair the consumer's freedom of choice, vitiates their consent or hinders the exercise of their contractual rights (Article L. 121-6). Among the factors to be taken into account, the text expressly lists any onerous or disproportionate non-contractual obstacle imposed by the trader when the consumer wishes to exercise contractual rights, including the right to terminate the contract or to switch product or supplier. A cancellation path that requires a phone call, imposes several retention screens or demands a reason may be examined on that basis. Article L. 121-7 adds a list of practices always regarded as aggressive, including repeated and unwanted solicitations by telephone, email or any other remote means.

Aggressive practices are punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine, which can be raised to 10% of average annual turnover, and the court must order publication of the conviction (Article L. 132-11). Individuals may also be banned from commercial activity for up to five years, and companies face additional penalties (Article L. 132-12).

Pre-ticked boxes and additional payments

Express consent to any extra payment

Before a sales or service contract is concluded, the trader must obtain the consumer's express consent to any payment in addition to the price of the main item. Where an extra payment results from consent given by default, meaning that the consumer did not expressly refuse paid options they had not asked for, the consumer can claim a refund of the sums paid (Article L. 121-17). These rules are of public policy (Article L. 121-18).

A pre-ticked paid option therefore carries two risks: an administrative fine of up to €3,000 for an individual and €15,000 for a company (Article L. 132-22), and refund claims from each consumer concerned, which can weigh more than the fine on a large customer base.

The order button

For contracts concluded online, the trader must remind the consumer, before the order is placed, of the main characteristics, the price, the duration of the contract and any minimum duration. The button used to confirm the order must state clearly "order with obligation to pay" (commande avec obligation de paiement) or equivalent unambiguous wording, and accepted payment methods and delivery restrictions must be shown at the latest at the start of the ordering process (Article L. 221-14). Breaches can lead to an administrative fine of up to €15,000 for an individual and €75,000 for a company (Article L. 242-10).

Cancellation and withdrawal functions

Online cancellation

Where a contract was concluded online, or where the trader offers online contracting on the day the consumer cancels, cancellation must be possible online, through a function provided at no cost (Article L. 215-1-1). The function must be labelled "cancel your contract" (résilier votre contrat) or equivalent, must be directly and easily accessible from the interface used to conclude contracts, and may not require the consumer to create an account at the notification stage. A summary page must let the consumer check the details before a button labelled "notification of cancellation" or equivalent (Articles D. 215-1 to D. 215-3). The rule is sometimes called "three-click cancellation", but the texts set out steps, not a number of clicks. Breaches carry a fine of up to €15,000 for an individual and €75,000 for a company (Article L. 241-3-1). The rules are explained in detail in our article on consumer subscriptions in France.

Online withdrawal

Since 19 June 2026, for distance contracts concluded through an online interface, the trader must also provide, at no cost, a function allowing the consumer to exercise the right of withdrawal before the withdrawal period expires. The article provides for a decree on how the function is presented and used (Article L. 221-21). Breaches of the withdrawal rules carry a fine of up to €15,000 and €75,000 (Article L. 242-13).

Termination terms

Design and contract terms go together. Terms that subject termination to stricter conditions for the consumer than for the trader are presumed unfair, unless the trader proves otherwise (Article R. 212-2, 8°), and unfair terms are deemed not written (Article L. 241-1). A retention path built on such a term loses its contractual basis.

The Digital Services Act: online platforms and marketplaces

Article 25

Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, the Digital Services Act, has applied in full since 17 February 2024 (Article 93). Under its Article 25, providers of online platforms must not design, organise or operate their online interfaces in a way that deceives or manipulates users, or that otherwise materially distorts or impairs their ability to make informed decisions freely. The Commission may issue guidelines on specific practices, such as giving more prominence to certain choices, repeatedly asking for a choice already made, especially through pop-ups, or making it harder to terminate a service than to subscribe to it. Such guidelines explain the rule; they are not binding in themselves.

Scope and limits

  • Online platforms only. An online platform is a hosting service that, at the request of a user, stores and disseminates information to the public (Article 3(i)). On that definition, a website that sells only its own products is unlikely to be a platform; a marketplace that hosts third-party offers is.
  • Consumer law first. Article 25 does not apply to practices covered by the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (Directive 2005/29/EC) or by the General Data Protection Regulation (Article 25(2)). Towards consumers, most dark patterns therefore remain governed by the French rules described above.
  • Small businesses. The section containing Article 25 does not apply to platforms that qualify as micro or small enterprises, unless they have been designated as very large online platforms (Article 19). The same exemption applies to the marketplace obligations below (Article 29).

Marketplaces

Platforms that allow consumers to conclude distance contracts with traders have further duties: tracing the traders that use them (Article 30), designing their interface so that traders can give the required pre-contractual, compliance and product safety information (Article 31), and informing consumers who bought an illegal product or service (Article 32). These obligations are covered in our article on online marketplace obligations in France.

Sanctions in France

The Digital Services Act leaves penalties to Member States, which must ensure that the maximum fine for failing to comply with an obligation of the regulation is 6% of the provider's annual worldwide turnover in the preceding financial year (Article 52(3)). In France, a marketplace provider that breaches Article 25, or the obligations of Articles 30 to 32, commits a criminal offence punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine, which can be raised for a company, in proportion to the benefits derived, to 6% of worldwide turnover excluding tax for the previous financial year (Article L. 133-1 of the Consumer Code). Consumer protection officials investigate breaches of the regulation within the framework it sets (Article L. 512-66). Both provisions were introduced by Law No. 2024-449 of 21 May 2024.

Financial services sold online

Since 19 June 2026, a similar rule applies to any trader concluding financial services contracts at a distance. Its online interfaces must not deceive or manipulate consumers or impair their ability to make informed decisions. In particular, it must not present the choices offered in a way that steers the decision, repeatedly ask for a choice already made, or make unsubscribing more complex than subscribing (Article L. 222-16-3 of the Consumer Code).

Cookie banners: a separate regime

Reading or placing cookies and similar trackers on a user's device requires the user's consent, given after clear and complete information on their purpose and on the means to refuse, except for trackers used only for the communication itself or strictly necessary for a service the user has requested (Article 82 of Law No. 78-17 of 6 January 1978). This falls under French data protection law, enforced by the CNIL (the French data protection authority). An unbalanced consent banner is therefore first a data protection question, and it is not covered further here.

Measures aimed at the interface itself

Beyond fines, the authority can act on the site. After an adversarial procedure, officials can order a business to comply with its obligations or stop an unlawful practice within a set time, with a daily penalty of up to €3,000 (Article L. 521-1). Where a breach is found on an online interface and its author cannot be identified or has not complied with an injunction, the authority can order platforms, search engines and other intermediaries to display a warning to consumers. For offences punishable by at least two years' imprisonment that seriously harm the fairness of transactions or consumers' interests, it can also order the delisting of the interface, restrictions on access to it, or the blocking of its domain name for up to three months, renewable once, followed by deletion or transfer if the offence continues (Article L. 521-3-1).

Measure What it involves Legal basis (Consumer Code)
Injunction Order to comply or to stop an unlawful practice within a set time, after an adversarial procedure; daily penalty of up to €3,000 L. 521-1
Warning message Ordered to platforms, search engines and other intermediaries when the author cannot be identified or has not complied with an injunction L. 521-3-1, 1°
Delisting, access restriction, domain name blocking For offences punishable by at least two years' imprisonment that seriously harm fair trading or consumers; blocking for up to three months, renewable once L. 521-3-1, 2°
Publication of an administrative fine Possible, at the expense of the business, if announced during the adversarial procedure L. 522-6
Publication of a conviction for an aggressive practice Ordered by the criminal court L. 132-11
Refund of extra payments Sums paid for options accepted by default L. 121-17
Unfair term on termination Presumed unfair and, if unfair, deemed not written R. 212-2, 8°; L. 241-1

Keeping a record of interface versions

Interfaces change constantly: product pages, checkout steps and banners are adjusted at each campaign, and some are tested in several variants at the same time. When the authority finds a breach, it relies on the state of the interface on a given date, usually documented by screenshots. A business that cannot show what users actually saw on earlier dates, which variant was shown to whom and for how long, has little to set against the period and scope that the authority retains.

Keeping that record is a matter of principle, not a defence in itself, and the same records can support the authority's case. Officials can require documents of any kind, on any medium (Article L. 512-8), and what is produced, and how, commits the business for the rest of the procedure. Those choices should be made with counsel, not by technical teams alone. For the wider framework of unfair practices, see our guide to unfair commercial practices in France.

Frequently asked questions

What are the penalties for dark patterns in France?

They depend on the legal basis. Misleading practices: two years and €300,000, raised to five years and €750,000 online, with fines of up to 10% of turnover in some cases and five times higher for companies (Article L. 132-2). Aggressive practices: two years and €300,000, up to 10% of turnover (Article L. 132-11). Administrative fines range from €3,000 / €15,000 for a pre-ticked paid option (Article L. 132-22) to €15,000 / €75,000 for a missing online cancellation function (Article L. 241-3-1). Marketplaces breaching the Digital Services Act face up to 6% of worldwide turnover (Article L. 133-1).

Is a countdown timer illegal in France?

Not in itself. It becomes unlawful when it is false: falsely stating that an offer is available only for a very limited time to obtain an immediate decision is always regarded as misleading (Article L. 121-4, 7°). A timer that resets on each visit, or that is not linked to a real end of the offer, is exposed.

Are pre-ticked boxes allowed in France?

Not for paid extras. The trader must obtain express consent to any payment beyond the price of the main item, and a consumer charged through a default option can claim a refund (Article L. 121-17). The administrative fine is up to €3,000 for an individual and €15,000 for a company (Article L. 132-22).

Do websites selling subscriptions in France need an online cancellation button?

Yes, where the contract was concluded online, or where online contracting is offered on the day of cancellation. The function must be provided at no cost, be labelled clearly, be directly accessible and lead to a summary page before notification (Articles L. 215-1-1 and D. 215-1 to D. 215-3). Since 19 June 2026, an online withdrawal function is also required for distance contracts concluded online (Article L. 221-21).

Does the Digital Services Act apply to an ordinary online shop?

Its Article 25 applies to providers of online platforms, defined as hosting services that store and disseminate information to the public at a user's request (Article 3(i)). A shop selling only its own products is unlikely to qualify; a marketplace usually does, unless it is a micro or small enterprise (Articles 19 and 29). French consumer law applies in all cases.

Who enforces dark pattern rules in France?

The DGCCRF and the DDPP enforce consumer law: they can impose administrative fines, issue injunctions and order measures against an online interface (Articles L. 521-1 and L. 521-3-1). Criminal offences are tried by the criminal courts. Cookie consent falls under data protection law and the CNIL.

The DGCCRF has asked for screenshots of our site over several years. What should we do?

The request is usually based on the power to require documents of any kind (Article L. 512-8). Your answer will shape the period and scope of the case, so the extent of what you produce, and how, should be decided with counsel before anything is sent.

Can an A/B test be a breach of consumer law?

Yes. Each variant shown to users is an interface in its own right and can be assessed on its own. A variant that misleads or pressures consumers does not become lawful because only part of the traffic saw it, although the share of users exposed and the duration may weigh on the assessment.

Key actions

  • Checkout and subscription paths: review urgency messages, default options and the point at which costs appear.
  • Cancellation and withdrawal: check the online functions against Articles L. 215-1-1, D. 215-1 to D. 215-3 and L. 221-21.
  • Digital Services Act: determine whether your service is an online platform or a marketplace, and whether the small-enterprise exemption applies.
  • Records: keep dated records of interface versions and variants, and decide with counsel what to produce if the authority asks.

Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.