Call centre, agent or lead provider: in France the business that profits from unlawful cold calls is presumed liable. Fines, contracts, proof, abroad.

In France, the business that benefits from the calls answers first. Article L. 223-1 of the French Consumer Code presumes that any business which has profited from marketing calls made in breach of that article is responsible for the breach, unless it shows that it is not at its origin. The call centre, agent or lead provider that placed the calls can be pursued as well, and the contract clauses between them do not bind the authority.
Updated: November 2026. Key provisions: Articles L. 221-16, L. 221-17, L. 223-1, L. 242-16, L. 512-8, L. 512-10, L. 522-5 and L. 522-7 of the French Consumer Code; Articles R. 223-1, R. 223-2, R. 223-4 and D. 223-9 of the same code, as amended by Decree No. 2026-662 of 23 July 2026; Article L. 134-1 of the French Commercial Code; Article 1199 of the French Civil Code.
Cold calling rules are enforced by the DGCCRF (the French authority for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control) and its local offices, the DDPP (departmental directorates for the protection of populations). Many groups and brands, in France and abroad, have French consumers called by an outside call centre, a subcontractor, a commercial agent or a lead provider, sometimes from another country. This article explains whom the DDPP can pursue in each set-up, what the business that benefits from the calls has to prove, and what contracts with providers can and cannot achieve. If you have received a request for documents or a notice of fine, a lawyer for DGCCRF and DDPP inspections can tell you where you stand.
CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION
Article L. 223-1 has contained a specific rule of attribution since 26 July 2020, when it was introduced by Law No. 2020-901 of 24 July 2020. The rule was kept, in the same words, when the article was rewritten with effect from 11 August 2026: any business that has profited from marketing calls to consumers made in breach of the article is presumed responsible for the breach, unless it shows that it is not at its origin. The same article provides that any contract concluded with a consumer following an unlawful call is void.
The text does not target the person who dials the number. It targets the business that profited from the calls: in practice, the business whose goods or services were offered and which receives the orders, appointments or contracts generated by the campaign. On a plain reading, it makes no difference whether the calls were placed by an independent call centre, a commercial agent, a business introducer or a chain of subcontractors. The presumption is a starting point, not a finding: the authority must still establish the breach, and the business keeps the right to show that it is not at its origin.
The presumption refers to breaches of Article L. 223-1 itself. Since 11 August 2026, that article prohibits calling a consumer who has not given prior consent, directly or through a third party acting on one's behalf. It bans marketing calls for services, equipment or works intended to adapt homes to ageing or disability, to save energy or to produce renewable energy, even with consent, except within a current contract; a call answering the consumer's own request for information is not treated as marketing if the conditions of Article R. 223-4 are met. It also refers to a decree for call days, hours and frequency, and a call made outside the authorised days and hours does not count as consented (Article R. 223-1, II). The other cold calling provisions, such as Articles L. 223-2 to L. 223-5, are covered by the same fine but, on the wording of the text, not by the presumption.
Since 11 August 2026, a consumer may be called for marketing purposes only with prior consent, given by a clear affirmative act, valid for one year at most and recorded (Articles L. 223-1, R. 223-1 and R. 223-2), or within a current contract and in connection with it. Calls are allowed from Monday to Friday, except public holidays, from 10:00 to 13:00 and from 14:00 to 20:00 in the consumer's time zone, with no more than four calls or attempts per consumer in thirty calendar days (Article D. 223-9). The former opt-out system, based on a national opposition list, ended on the same date. The consent rules are covered in a separate article; this one deals with who answers for a breach.
When the calls are made in-house, the business is the professional that calls, and it answers directly for any breach. The fine is imposed on the company, within the ceiling set for legal persons.
Under a service agreement, the call centre places the calls and the client receives the sales or appointments. Two businesses are then involved, and the client is exposed on two grounds: Article L. 223-1 prohibits calls made through a third party acting on its behalf, and the presumption applies to the business that profits from them. The call centre, as the business that actually made the calls, can also be pursued for the breaches it committed. Nothing in Article L. 242-16 requires the authority to choose between them.
A commercial agent is an independent agent who, on a permanent basis, negotiates and possibly concludes contracts in the name and on behalf of a principal (Article L. 134-1 of the French Commercial Code). That status governs the relationship between agent and principal, such as notice and end-of-contract indemnity. It does not change the position under consumer law: when the agent calls consumers to sell the principal's products, the principal profits from the calls and falls within the presumption, and the agent may also be pursued for the calls it made.
Some businesses do not commission calls at all: they buy appointments, leads or signed contracts generated by others, sometimes under a white-label arrangement. The presumption is drafted broadly enough to reach them, since it targets any business that has profited from unlawful calls, whether or not it ordered them. Buying leads without checking how they were obtained is therefore a legal risk, not only a commercial one.
The texts make no exception for calls placed from abroad. Call hours are set in the consumer's time zone (Article D. 223-9), and the prohibition covers calls made through any third party acting for the business. Where the provider is out of reach, the business that profits from the calls is likely to be the most accessible target, especially if it is established or has assets in France. The position of brands based abroad is discussed below.
Several provisions place obligations on the business on whose behalf the calls are made, not only on the caller. They matter when liability is allocated within a chain of providers.
The question "who must hold the proof of consent?" therefore has a legal answer: the business that calls, or has calls made for it, must be able to produce it, even when a provider collected it.
Agreements with call centres, agents and lead providers increasingly include compliance commitments: how consent is collected and stored, call hours and frequency, scripts, a ban on undisclosed subcontracting, audit rights, termination for non-compliance and indemnities. Between the parties, these terms have real effect. They define who must do what, can support a contractual claim against a provider in breach and show the care taken by the business. Commitments that still refer to screening call files against the national opposition list should be updated: that list was abolished on 11 August 2026.
A contract creates obligations only between the parties (Article 1199 of the French Civil Code). It does not bind the authority, which imposes the fine on the business designated by the Consumer Code. A clause stating that the provider "alone bears any sanction" will not prevent the DDPP from fining the business that profited from the calls. At most, it may allow that business to claim from the provider afterwards, if the provider is solvent and the breach can be attributed to it under the contract. Whether an indemnity can cover the administrative fine itself, rather than other losses, is not settled by the texts and should be assessed case by case.
A contract alone does not rebut the presumption. What the authority is likely to examine is how the relationship worked in practice: the instructions given, the files supplied, the checks made and the reaction to complaints. Clauses that were never applied carry little weight. How these documents are used in a defence, without turning against the business, is a matter to settle with counsel; this article does not offer model clauses.
Any breach of Articles L. 223-1 to L. 223-5 can lead to an administrative fine of up to €75,000 for an individual and €375,000 for a company (Article L. 242-16). The fine is imposed after a written adversarial procedure: the authority informs you of the intended sanction, tells you that you may be assisted by counsel and gives you one month to submit observations (Articles L. 522-5 and R. 522-2). How to answer is explained in our guide to the DGCCRF notice of intended fine.
The presumption against the business that profits does not remove the liability of the provider that made the calls. Each can face its own procedure and its own fine. Where several sanctions are imposed on the same business for concurrent breaches, they are executed cumulatively (Article L. 522-7). The ceiling applies to "any breach", but the text does not say how breaches are counted in a campaign. Whether each unlawful call is a separate breach is a question of assessment, and the authority sets the amount within the ceiling.
Most consumer law fines may or may not be published. A fine under Article L. 242-16 is published at the expense of the business sanctioned. The authority may postpone publication, publish it in anonymised form or not publish it only where publication would cause serious and disproportionate harm, or would seriously disrupt an ongoing investigation or inspection (Article L. 242-16). For a brand, publication can matter as much as the amount.
Any contract concluded with a consumer following a call made in breach of Article L. 223-1 is void (Article L. 223-1). The business that sold through the campaign carries that risk, whoever made the calls.
Investigations can start from consumer reports filed through the public online reporting service run by the DGCCRF. A consumer rarely knows the name of the call centre, but usually knows the brand on whose behalf they were called. That is one reason why the brand tends to be the first business the DDPP contacts.
Officials can require documents of any kind that help them carry out their task, obtain or copy them by any means and on any medium, or seize them, whoever holds them (Article L. 512-8). In a cold calling case, this can cover service and agency agreements, invoices, call files, consent records, scripts and exchanges with providers. Through these documents, the DDPP identifies the successive providers and the volume of calls. See our article on DGCCRF requests for documents.
Officials can also gather information on site or by summons, and interview anyone likely to provide useful information. The answers are recorded in a written report (procès-verbal), which the person reads, may annotate and signs. Where there are plausible reasons to suspect that the person has committed an offence, the rules of the voluntary interview (audition libre) apply (Article L. 512-10). Questions usually concern who chose the provider, who supplied or approved the files, what instructions were given and how complaints were handled. Statements made at this stage weigh on the presumption, so interviews should be prepared.
The presumption can be rebutted: the business escapes it if it shows that it is not at the origin of the breach (Article L. 223-1). The text does not list the means of proof. A contract requiring the provider to comply, or a statement that the business did not know the provider's methods, is unlikely to be enough on its own. The question is how the business actually behaved: what it asked for, what it supplied, what it checked and how it reacted when problems surfaced.
Which documents to produce, in what order and with what explanation depends on the set-up, the consumer reports, what was said in interviews and the stage of the procedure. A poorly chosen argument can implicitly confirm a disputed fact. That work is done file by file with counsel, from the first request for documents to the observations on the intended fine.
Many campaigns aimed at French consumers are run from call centres outside France, sometimes outside the European Union, and some of the brands that benefit from them are themselves established abroad. Moving the calls abroad does not move the rules: the texts make no exception for calls placed from another country, and call hours follow the consumer's time zone (Article D. 223-9). It does make evidence harder to gather. Call files, scripts and consent records are held by the provider, which may not produce them, or may produce them in a form that is hard to verify. A business that cannot trace where the numbers called on its behalf came from will struggle to rebut the presumption.
Where the business that benefits is itself based outside the EU, the procedure follows the same steps, and the question becomes how a French fine can be enforced. This is covered in our article on enforcing a French fine against a company based outside the EU.
Because French law targets the business that benefits. Article L. 223-1 prohibits cold calls made directly or through a third party acting on your behalf, and presumes that any business which profited from unlawful calls is responsible, unless it shows that it is not at the origin of the breach. The fact that a provider dialled the numbers does not, by itself, release you.
No. The commercial agent status (Article L. 134-1 of the French Commercial Code) governs the relationship between agent and principal. When the agent calls consumers to sell the principal's products, the principal profits from the calls and falls within the presumption of Article L. 223-1. The agent can also be pursued for its own calls.
Not as against the authority. A contract binds only its parties (Article 1199 of the French Civil Code), so the DDPP can fine the business that profited from the calls whatever the contract says. Between the parties, an indemnity may allow a claim against the provider afterwards, but whether it can cover the fine itself is not settled by the texts.
Yes. The presumption against the brand does not remove the provider's own liability. Each can be fined up to €75,000 for an individual and €375,000 for a company for any breach (Article L. 242-16), after a procedure in which it has one month to submit observations (Articles L. 522-5 and R. 522-2).
The texts make no exception for calls placed from abroad to consumers in France: call hours follow the consumer's time zone (Article D. 223-9) and calls made through any third party are covered (Article L. 223-1). Offshore calling mainly makes it harder for the brand to obtain the evidence it may need.
The business. It bears the burden of proving consent (Article L. 223-1) and must have a system to keep the consent records for three years (Article R. 223-2). The consent request must name the business and, where relevant, the third party acting for it (Article R. 223-1).
You may be. The presumption applies to any business that has profited from calls made in breach of Article L. 223-1, whether or not it ordered them. If the leads come from unlawful calls, you would have to show that you are not at the origin of the breach.
Identify the legal basis and the deadline, then decide with counsel what to produce and how. The request is usually made under Article L. 512-8, and the documents you send will be used to reconstruct the call chain and assess the presumption.
Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.