18/11/26

Yacht compliance in France: owner and manager liability

Who answers for a yacht's crew, hours of rest, certificates and port State control in France: owner, operator, manager or master, and what contracts say.

Who is responsible for a yacht's compliance in France?

Under French law, the operator (armateur) is whoever operates the vessel in its own name, and the owner is presumed to be the operator. A management company takes on safety management if it has accepted the role of "company" under the ISM Code, and the master keeps duties of his own. Everything else depends on what the yacht management agreement says, and on whether it matches what each party actually does.

Updated: November 2026. Key provisions: Articles L. 5411-1, L. 5411-2, L. 5542-3, L. 5544-4, L. 5544-15, L. 5514-1 and L. 5241-3 of the French Transport Code; Articles 1984, 1992 and 1993 of the French Civil Code; Regulation (EC) No 336/2006 (ISM Code); Directive 2009/16/EC (port State control).

A yacht operated in charter or entrusted to a management company is subject to obligations from international conventions, EU law and the law of its flag State. When they are not met, the cost is immediate: a detained vessel in high season, crew claims, disputes with insurers. This article is for owners of yachts under the French flag or calling at French ports, and for management companies. It maps the obligations, shows how they are shared between owner, operator, manager and master, and what the management agreement should allocate. Charter-specific rules, such as the skipper's status as a seafarer and the commercial use of the flag, are covered in our legal guide to yacht charter in France. A yacht lawyer in France can review the structure and the contracts.

Would you like to discuss your situation? Book a consultation:

CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION

What yacht compliance covers

Four areas, four sets of documents

Compliance covers the vessel (construction, safety equipment, statutory certificates, maintenance), the crew (employment agreements, qualifications, medical fitness, hours of work and rest, social protection), operations (safety management, emergency procedures, logbooks, drills) and administration (port formalities, personal data, charter accounts). Each area has its own documents, and the risk lies in not being able to produce them when asked.

Detention: the most immediate sanction

Under EU law, where an inspection reveals deficiencies clearly hazardous to safety, health or the environment, the port State authority must detain the ship, or stop the operation concerned, until the hazard is removed (Article 19 of Directive 2009/16/EC). For a charter yacht, a few days' detention in high season can mean cancelled weeks and refunds to guests.

Liability and insurance

A compliance failure can also weigh on a claim. Depending on the policy terms, an insurer may rely on the vessel's condition or on lapsed certificates at the time of the event to dispute or reduce cover. After an accident, investigators can be expected to look at hours of rest and safety drills. These consequences depend on the contracts and the facts, which is why the allocation of tasks matters.

Who answers for what: owner, operator, manager, master

The owner and the presumption of operation

French law separates ownership and operation. The operator (armateur) is whoever operates the vessel in its own name, whether or not it owns it (Article L. 5411-1 of the French Transport Code). The owner or co-owners are presumed to be the operator, and a charterer becomes the operator if the charter party so provides and has been duly published (Article L. 5411-2). An owner who organises nothing and lets others run the vessel in practice may therefore carry the operator's obligations. Where the yacht is held through a company, that company is the owner; on the tax side of that choice, see owning a yacht through a company in France.

The operator: crew and safety

The operator is the natural debtor of the obligations towards the crew and of safety obligations. It is named in each seafarer's employment agreement, which must state the health and social security benefits it provides and the right to repatriation (Article L. 5542-3). For seafarers on ships making international voyages, it guarantees the payment of repatriation and medical costs through a financial guarantee, insurance or an equivalent arrangement (Article L. 5542-32-1). The owner, operator, charterer, master and their employees may limit their liability for damage occurring on board or directly linked to the navigation or use of the vessel, unless the damage results from their personal act committed intentionally or recklessly and with knowledge that it would probably result (Articles L. 5121-2 and L. 5121-3). That limitation cannot be raised against the claims of the master and crew arising from their employment (Article L. 5121-4).

The manager: agent or operator?

The manager's position is where disputes start. If it acts in the owner's name and on the owner's behalf, it is an agent under a mandate (Article 1984 of the French Civil Code). If it runs the vessel in its own name, recruits the crew, takes out the insurance and declares itself responsible for safety management, it may become the operator, or the "company" within the meaning of the ISM Code. The company is the owner or any other organisation or person, such as the manager or bareboat charterer, who has assumed responsibility for operating the ship and agreed to take over all the duties and responsibilities imposed by the Code (Article 2 of Regulation (EC) No 336/2006). In principle, what counts is the powers actually exercised rather than the title of the contract, so the agreement should match the declarations made to the authorities.

The master

The master holds authority on board and is the inspectors' first contact. The master keeps on board, for the crew, a copy of their employment agreements and the texts that govern them, and hands them to flag or port State authorities on request (Article L. 5542-5-1). In principle, a contract between owner and manager cannot shift the master's own responsibility for his acts onto others. In yachting, the master also often manages the charter guest's advance and holds the records in practice.

Role Who it is What falls on it Legal basis
Owner Holds the vessel Presumed operator, unless a published charter party makes the charterer the operator Transport Code, L. 5411-2
Operator (armateur) Operates the vessel in its own name Named in crew agreements; repatriation and medical costs guarantee; may limit liability, but not against crew claims L. 5411-1, L. 5542-3, L. 5542-32-1, L. 5121-3, L. 5121-4
Manager acting as agent Acts in the owner's name and on its behalf Performs the mandate, accounts for all sums received, liable for faults in its management Civil Code, 1984, 1991, 1992, 1993
ISM company Has assumed responsibility for operating the ship and accepted the duties of the Code Safety management system; document of compliance (up to five years) Regulation (EC) No 336/2006, Article 2 and Annex I
Master Holds authority on board Keeps the crew agreements and governing texts on board and hands them to authorities on request Transport Code, L. 5542-5-1

The yacht management agreement

Agency or service contract

French law does not define the yacht management agreement; its legal nature depends on its content. Where the manager acts in the owner's name and on its behalf, signs crew agreements, pays suppliers and represents the operator, it is in principle a mandate (Article 1984). Where it provides technical services in its own name, it is closer to a contract for services.

Accounting for the money

Every agent must account for its management and hand over to the principal everything received under the mandate (Article 1993 of the Civil Code), and is liable not only for fraud but also for faults in its management (Article 1992). For a yacht, this covers cash movements, yard invoices, any commissions received from suppliers and charter guests' funds.

Liability caps and their limits

Management agreements often cap the manager's liability, for example at the annual fee. Courts generally accept such caps in principle, but the Civil Code sets two limits. A debtor is liable only for the damages foreseen or foreseeable when the contract was made, except where non-performance results from gross or wilful misconduct (Article 1231-3). And a clause that deprives the debtor's essential obligation of its substance is deemed unwritten (Article 1170). A token cap in a contract whose very purpose is to keep the vessel compliant is exposed to that rule.

Insurance, termination and return of documents

Three clauses deserve attention: the manager's professional liability insurance (amount, territory, yearly proof); termination, with a notice period compatible with the season and the transfer of certificates; and the return of documents and data at the end of the contract (crew records, maintenance history, logbooks, accounts).

Crew compliance

The seafarer's employment agreement

Any employment contract between a seafarer and an operator or other employer, for service on board a ship, is a seafarer's employment agreement (contrat d'engagement maritime) (Article L. 5542-1 of the Transport Code). It must be in writing and state, among other things, the name and address of the operator and, where different, the employer, the seafarer's duties, pay, paid leave, the health and social security benefits provided, the right to repatriation, the applicable collective agreements and, for a fixed term, its end date (Article L. 5542-3). The seafarer must have enough time to read it and take advice, and signs it and receives a copy before embarking (Article L. 5542-5).

Repatriation

The employer organises repatriation in the cases listed by law, including the end of a fixed-term contract in a port outside metropolitan France, dismissal, illness or injury, shipwreck, the sale of the vessel, and the end of a maximum period of six months on board, which a collective agreement may extend to nine (Article L. 5542-29). The employer bears the cost, and no advance can be required from the seafarer (Article L. 5542-32), subject to the exceptions of Article L. 5542-33.

The maritime labour certificate

To go to sea, any vessel of 500 gross tonnage or more making international voyages, other than traditional ships and public vessels without commercial activity, must hold a valid maritime labour certificate. It certifies that living and working conditions on board comply with the flag State's rules implementing the Maritime Labour Convention, 2006, is valid for up to five years and must be shown to flag and port State authorities on request (Article L. 5514-1).

Hours of work and rest

The limits under French law

On a vessel other than a fishing vessel, hours of work may not exceed 14 in any 24-hour period and 72 in any seven-day period (Article L. 5544-4). Seafarers are entitled to at least ten hours of rest in any 24-hour period, in no more than two periods, one of at least six consecutive hours, with no more than 14 hours between two rest periods (Article L. 5544-15). Collective agreements may adapt these rules, but must then provide for watchkeeping, consecutive rest to prevent fatigue, compensatory leave and checks on actual working time (Article L. 5544-4).

Why the records matter

The EU agreement on seafarers' working time requires records of daily hours of work or rest, with a copy for each seafarer endorsed by the master and by the seafarer (clause 8 of the annex to Directive 1999/63/EC). During an inspection, the records can be compared with the logbook, the crew list and the port calls. In a dispute, a party claiming performance of an obligation must prove it, and a party claiming to be released must prove the payment or event that released it (Article 1353 of the Civil Code). An operator who says that rest periods were respected or overtime paid needs continuous, signed and dated records. Records completed after the event, or not signed by the seafarer, would be easy to challenge.

The vessel: safety management and certificates

The ISM Code

The ISM Code requires the company operating a ship to run a documented safety management system, and the company receives a document of compliance valid for no more than five years (Annex I to Regulation (EC) No 336/2006). The EU regulation applying the Code excludes cargo ships under 500 gross tonnage, and pleasure yachts and pleasure craft unless they are crewed and carry more than 12 passengers for commercial purposes (Article 3). Whether a given charter yacht falls within the regulation, or within the ISM rules applied by its flag State, must be checked vessel by vessel. Where the Code does not apply, a written safety system remains useful evidence.

Safety and pollution certificates

A French vessel cannot go to sea without the safety and pollution prevention certificates required for its type (Article L. 5241-3). They are issued by the authorities or by authorised classification societies, can be suspended or withdrawn, and their issue, renewal and endorsement depend on surveys of the vessel. For vessels under 24 metres, other than passenger vessels and certificates issued by classification societies, they are issued without time limit (Article L. 5241-4).

Drills and logbooks

Abandon-ship, fire and man-overboard drills, and the deck and engine logbooks, are the evidence of how the vessel is run. A drill that was carried out but not recorded will be hard to prove (Article 1353 of the Civil Code).

Port State control

How inspections work

The EU port State control directive applies to any ship and its crew calling at a port or anchorage of a Member State, but excludes pleasure yachts not engaged in trade (Article 3 of Directive 2009/16/EC). Inspections are coordinated under the Paris Memorandum of Understanding on Port State Control, signed on 26 January 1982 (Article 2). In France, foreign-flagged vessels calling at a French port or anchorage may be inspected, and the inspection costs fall on the owner or operator (Articles L. 5241-4-3 and L. 5241-4-4 of the Transport Code).

What to have ready

  • statutory certificates and survey reports, with their expiry dates;
  • where the ISM Code applies, the documents it requires;
  • where required, the maritime labour certificate (Article L. 5514-1);
  • seafarers' employment agreements and the texts governing them (Article L. 5542-5-1), qualifications and medical certificates;
  • records of hours of work or rest, and proof of payment of wages;
  • logbooks, drill records and the follow-up of non-conformities.

Deficiencies, detention and refusal of access

Deficiencies must be rectified in accordance with the conventions. Where they are clearly hazardous to safety, health or the environment, the ship is detained until the hazard is removed (Article 19 of Directive 2009/16/EC). Repeated detentions of a ship whose flag is on the black or grey list can lead to a refusal of access to EU ports (Article 16).

Area Document or record Legal basis
Crew Written employment agreements, copy given before embarking, kept on board Transport Code, L. 5542-3, L. 5542-5, L. 5542-5-1
Repatriation Financial guarantee, insurance or equivalent (international voyages) Transport Code, L. 5542-32-1
Labour certification Maritime labour certificate (500 gross tonnage or more, international voyages), up to five years Transport Code, L. 5514-1
Hours of work and rest Limits of 14 hours' work per 24 hours and 72 per seven days; at least ten hours' rest per 24 hours; records of hours Transport Code, L. 5544-4, L. 5544-15; Directive 1999/63/EC, annex, clause 8
Safety Safety and pollution prevention certificates, issued after surveys Transport Code, L. 5241-3, L. 5241-4
Safety management Safety management system and document of compliance, where the ISM Code applies Regulation (EC) No 336/2006
Charter funds Account of the APA with receipts; return of the balance Civil Code, 1993
Personal data Processing agreements with providers; breach notification within 72 hours where feasible GDPR, Articles 28 and 33

Charter: the advance provisioning allowance

Charter agreements commonly provide for an advance provisioning allowance (APA), paid by the guest before boarding to cover variable costs such as fuel, food and drink, port fees and communications. The master spends it, reports to the guest during the charter and returns the unspent balance with the account at the end. These funds do not belong to the operator. Where the master or the manager handles them on the guest's behalf, the arrangement is in principle a mandate, with the duty to account for and hand over everything received (Article 1993 of the Civil Code). An expense that cannot be backed by a receipt linked to the charter is exposed to repayment.

Personal data on board

A yacht processes personal data all the time: crew identity and payroll, passenger lists, CCTV images. Where the GDPR applies (its territorial scope is set by its Article 3), roles must be defined between controller and processors, and each processor must be bound by a contract setting out the subject matter, duration, nature and purpose of the processing, the types of data and the parties' obligations (Article 28 of Regulation (EU) 2016/679). Medical certificates, accident reports and treatment records are health data, whose processing is prohibited unless an exception applies, such as obligations under employment and social security law (Article 9). A data breach must be notified to the supervisory authority without undue delay and, where feasible, within 72 hours, unless it is unlikely to result in a risk, and the people concerned must be told where the risk is high (Articles 33 and 34). The most serious breaches carry fines of up to €20 million or 4% of worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higher (Article 83).

Evidence: electronic records

Writing consists of letters, characters, figures or other intelligible signs, whatever the medium (Article 1365 of the Civil Code). An electronic document has the same evidential value as paper, provided its author can be properly identified and it is created and kept in conditions that guarantee its integrity (Article 1366). An electronic signature uses a reliable identification process linked to the document, and its reliability is presumed when the conditions set by decree are met (Article 1367). A digital register that identifies who made each entry, timestamps it, prevents later changes and keeps a history is therefore much easier to rely on than a spreadsheet. The burden of proof makes this concrete: the operator must prove that rest periods were respected, the manager that it performed its mission, and whoever handled the APA that the balance was returned (Article 1353).

What the management agreement should say

The agreement should list the services one by one and state, for each, who decides, who performs, who checks and who pays. It should say expressly whether the manager is designated as the ISM company, whether it employs the seafarers or acts as the operator's agent, and whether it may handle guests' funds. Owners commonly ask for:

  • dated periodic reports on certificates, upcoming deadlines and open non-conformities;
  • read access to the vessel's records and operating accounts;
  • the return of all documents and data at the end of the contract, in a usable format and within a set time;
  • yearly proof of the manager's liability insurance and its territorial cover;
  • an audit right, and a written allocation of data protection roles.

Frequently asked questions

Who is liable if a yacht is not compliant in France?

It depends on the organisation. The operator is whoever operates the vessel in its own name, and the owner is presumed to be the operator (Articles L. 5411-1 and L. 5411-2 of the Transport Code). A manager that has accepted to act as the ISM company takes on the duties of the Code (Regulation (EC) No 336/2006, Article 2). The master keeps his own responsibilities in all cases.

What must a yacht crew contract contain under French law?

A seafarer's employment agreement must be in writing and name the operator and, where different, the employer, and state the duties, pay, paid leave, health and social security benefits, right to repatriation, applicable collective agreements and, for a fixed term, the end date (Article L. 5542-3). The seafarer receives a signed copy before embarking (Article L. 5542-5).

Can a yacht management company limit its liability?

Yes, within limits. Damages are limited to those foreseeable when the contract was made, except for gross or wilful misconduct (Article 1231-3 of the Civil Code), and a clause that deprives the essential obligation of its substance is deemed unwritten (Article 1170).

What happens if a yacht fails a port State control inspection?

Deficiencies must be rectified. Where they are clearly hazardous to safety, health or the environment, the vessel is detained until the hazard is removed (Article 19 of Directive 2009/16/EC). Repeated detentions can lead to a refusal of access to EU ports (Article 16).

Does the APA have to be accounted for?

Yes. Whoever handles the guest's advance on the guest's behalf must, in principle, account for it and return what was not spent (Article 1993 of the Civil Code). Unjustified expenses are exposed to repayment.

Is a digital logbook or register valid evidence in France?

Yes, if its author can be identified and it is created and kept in conditions that guarantee its integrity (Article 1366 of the Civil Code).

Is a maritime labour certificate required on every yacht?

No. Under French law, it is required for vessels of 500 gross tonnage or more making international voyages, with limited exceptions (Article L. 5514-1). The substantive rules on employment agreements, repatriation and hours of work apply under the conditions of each text.

Key actions

  • Map the roles: decide who is the operator, who is the ISM company if the Code applies, and who employs the crew, and make the contracts match.
  • Check the crew file: employment agreements, repatriation guarantee, maritime labour certificate where required, hours records signed by each seafarer.
  • Check the vessel file: certificates, survey dates, drill records and logbooks, ready for inspection.
  • Review the management agreement: allocation of tasks, liability cap, insurance, reporting, return of documents and handling of guests' funds.

Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.