Cosmetic claims in France: clean, vegan and Made in France

What a cosmetics brand can claim in France: EU claim criteria, natural, clean, vegan, without claims, animal testing, Made in France and the evidence.

What can a cosmetics brand claim in France?

A cosmetics brand selling in France can make a claim only if it is true, supported by evidence kept in the product information file, and compliant with the six common criteria of EU Regulation No 655/2013. Words such as "natural", "clean" and "vegan" have no legal definition, so the brand must be able to explain what it means by them and show that they are accurate. The French authorities treat "not tested on animals" and many "without" claims (allégations « sans ») as unacceptable, and an inaccurate claim can be prosecuted as a misleading commercial practice.

Updated: November 2026. Key provisions: Articles 4, 11, 18, 19 and 20 of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 on cosmetic products; Commission Regulation (EU) No 655/2013 and its Annex; Articles L. 121-2, L. 121-4, L. 132-1 and L. 132-2 of the French Consumer Code; Articles L. 5431-2 and L. 5431-6 of the French Public Health Code.

In France, cosmetic claims are checked by the DGCCRF (the French authority for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control) and its local offices, the DDPP (departmental directorates for the protection of populations), and by the ANSM (the French national agency for the safety of medicines and health products), whose inspectors can also record offences under the cosmetics provisions of the French Public Health Code (Article L. 5431-1). A brand based abroad is judged like a French one, on what a consumer in France reads on the pack, the website or a social media post. A lawyer for DGCCRF and DDPP inspections can review your claims before launch, or help you answer the authority once it has started asking questions.

Would you like to discuss your situation? Book a consultation:

CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION

The legal framework for cosmetic claims

Article 20 of the Cosmetics Regulation

Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 on cosmetic products applies directly in every EU country. Its Article 20(1) sets the basic rule: in the labelling, making available on the market and advertising of cosmetic products, text, names, trade marks, pictures and other signs must not be used to imply that the products have characteristics or functions which they do not have.

The six common criteria of Regulation 655/2013

Commission Regulation (EU) No 655/2013, which applies from 11 July 2013, lays down six common criteria for claims: legal compliance, truthfulness, evidential support, honesty, fairness and informed decision-making (Annex). It applies to any claim, explicit or implicit, in the form of text, names, trade marks, pictures or other signs, whatever the medium, the function claimed or the target audience (Article 1). The responsible person must ensure that the wording of each claim complies with these criteria and is consistent with the documentation proving the effect claimed in the product information file (Article 2). A claim must meet all six: one that is true can still fail because it is unclear or because it denigrates other products.

Criterion (Annex to Regulation 655/2013) What it requires Typical question for a claim
1. Legal compliance No claim of approval by an EU authority; no legal minimum presented as a specific benefit; judged by the average end user in the market concerned Does the claim sell something every lawful product already has?
2. Truthfulness Ingredients claimed are deliberately present; ingredient properties are not attributed to the product when it lacks them; opinions are not presented as verified claims Is the highlighted ingredient really doing what the pack suggests?
3. Evidential support Adequate, verifiable evidence reflecting the state of the art, relevant to the product and proportionate to the claim Is there a relevant study or document for this exact wording?
4. Honesty No performance beyond the evidence; no "unique" feature that similar products share; conditions of use stated Is a common feature presented as exclusive?
5. Fairness Objective claims; no denigration of competitors or legally used ingredients; no confusion with a competitor's product Does the claim cast doubt on authorised ingredients or other products?
6. Informed decision-making Clear and understandable to the average end user; adapted to the target audience Would the claim still be understood correctly without the small print?

Commission guidance: useful, but not binding

A working group set up under the European Commission has published a technical document on cosmetic claims (version of 3 July 2017), with examples for each criterion and guidance on "without" and "hypoallergenic" claims. The DGCCRF and the ANSM point out that it is not legally binding, but that it explains the reasoning behind the criteria. Treat it as guidelines.

French consumer law applies on top

Under Article L. 121-2 of the French Consumer Code, a commercial practice is misleading if it relies on false or misleading claims, indications or presentations about, among other things, the essential characteristics of the product: its substantial qualities, composition, origin, method of manufacture, properties, the results expected from its use and the results of tests carried out on it. Article L. 121-4 lists practices deemed misleading in all cases, including displaying a certificate, a quality label or an equivalent without the necessary authorisation (2°). For a business based abroad, the offence is committed as soon as the practice is carried out in France or produces its effects there (Article L. 132-1). On labels and awards in advertising generally, see our article on awards, labels and rankings in advertising in France.

Who answers for the claims when the brand is based abroad

A cosmetic product can be placed on the EU market only if a natural or legal person established in the EU is designated as the "responsible person" (Article 4(1) of Regulation 1223/2009). For an imported product, each importer is the responsible person for the products it places on the market, unless it designates another EU-based person by written mandate (Article 4(5)). A distributor becomes the responsible person when it sells the product under its own name or trade mark, or modifies it in a way that may affect compliance (Article 4(6)).

The responsible person keeps the product information file and must ensure that the wording of the claims complies with the criteria. The brand that writes the claims and the EU responsible person that has to defend them therefore need the same documents, in the same version. The label must also show the name and address of the responsible person and, for an imported cosmetic, the country of origin (Article 19(1)(a)), and what French consumers read must comply with the French language requirements for labels and instructions.

The six criteria in practice

Legal compliance: no legal minimum sold as an advantage

A claim must not state that the product has been authorised or approved by a competent authority in the EU, and must not present mere compliance with minimum legal requirements as a specific benefit (Annex, criteria 1(1) and 1(3)). Acceptability is judged from the point of view of the average end user, reasonably well informed and reasonably observant and circumspect, taking into account social, cultural and linguistic factors in the market concerned, here France (criterion 1(2)). Claiming that a product does not contain a substance that is banned in cosmetics anyway is the standard example of a breach of criterion 1(3) given by the French authorities.

Truthfulness and evidential support

If a product is said to contain an ingredient, the ingredient must be deliberately present, and the properties of an ingredient must not be attributed to the finished product when it does not have them (criterion 2). Every claim, explicit or implicit, must be supported by adequate and verifiable evidence reflecting the state of the art; studies must be relevant to the product and to the benefit claimed, and the level of evidence must match the type of claim (criterion 3). Obvious exaggeration that no average user would take literally needs no proof, but a claim that extends an ingredient's properties to the finished product needs evidence, such as the presence of the ingredient at an effective concentration (criteria 3(5) and 3(6)).

Honesty and fairness

The presentation of a product's performance must not go beyond the available evidence, and a claim must not present as unique a characteristic that similar products share (criterion 4). Claims must be objective, must not denigrate competitors or ingredients legally used, and must not create confusion with a competitor's product (criterion 5). Messages built on fear of authorised ingredients raise fairness questions.

Informed decision-making

Claims must be clear and understandable to the average end user and allow an informed choice, and marketing communications must take account of the target audience's capacity to understand them (criterion 6). A prominent "100% natural" on the front of the pack, qualified by small print elsewhere, is the kind of claim that can fail this test even if the small print is accurate.

"Natural", "clean" and "vegan"

"Natural"

No EU or French text defines a "natural" cosmetic. A voluntary international standard, ISO 16128, offers definitions and a method for calculating the natural origin of ingredients and products. Using it helps to document a percentage claim, but it does not make the claim lawful by itself: the percentage must be accurate, the method should be stated where the reader needs it to understand the figure, and the rest of the pack must not say more, for instance "100% natural" next to a lower calculated figure (criteria 2, 3 and 6).

"Clean"

"Clean" has no legal or standard definition. Each brand gives it its own meaning, usually a list of excluded ingredients that the consumer cannot know unless the brand explains it. The word carries two risks: ambiguity (criterion 6), and implied denigration of products that are not "clean" and of the authorised ingredients they contain (criterion 5). A brand using it should be able to show a precise, public definition and check each formula against it.

"Vegan"

"Vegan" has no legal definition for cosmetics either. In their recommendations, the DGCCRF and the ANSM treat a claim that a product contains no ingredients or substances of animal origin, which they regard as the equivalent of "vegan", as information that can be useful to consumers who avoid such ingredients for ethical reasons. The claim must be accurate for every ingredient, including raw materials bought from suppliers, which means getting written statements from them. If the pack carries the logo of a private certification scheme, the brand must actually hold that certification for the product: displaying a certificate or quality label without the necessary authorisation is deemed misleading in all cases (Article L. 121-4, 2° of the Consumer Code). No text says whether "vegan" also covers animal testing.

"Without" claims (allégations « sans »)

Claims that a product does not contain an ingredient are the area where the French authorities have been most precise. In recommendations based on Regulation 655/2013, the DGCCRF and the ANSM consider that:

  • a claim of absence of a substance banned in cosmetics breaches criterion 1(3) and is not acceptable;
  • claims that cannot be verified, such as the absence of "endocrine disruptors", for which there is no official definition, breach criteria 2 and 3;
  • claims of absence of a regulated or authorised substance that is the subject of controversy should be avoided where the consumer can check its absence in the ingredients list, because they denigrate the authorised substance (criterion 5);
  • a claim covering a whole chemical family, some members of which are banned and others authorised, should be withdrawn, and "without parabens" is the example given;
  • some claims can be accepted case by case where they give useful information to people who want to avoid a substance for health reasons, lifestyle or convictions, for example the absence of alcohol, perfume, colourants or preservatives, provided they are accurate.

A "without" claim must be checked against the full formula, including substances that have the same effect without being listed for that function: according to the same recommendations, "without preservatives" requires that no substance in the product protects it against micro-organisms, and "without perfume" that no perfuming substance is present, whatever its other functions. The claims should be reviewed whenever the formula or the rules on a substance change.

"Not tested on animals"

EU law prohibits animal testing of finished cosmetic products and of their ingredients carried out to meet the requirements of the Cosmetics Regulation, and the placing on the market of products whose final formulation or ingredients have been tested on animals for that purpose, under the conditions and timetable of Article 18, whose last deadline expired on 11 March 2013. In France, breaching these prohibitions is an offence punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €30,000 fine (Article L. 5431-2, 3° of the Public Health Code).

The Regulation does not prohibit every reference to the absence of animal testing. Article 20(3) allows the responsible person to mention it only if the manufacturer and its suppliers have not carried out or commissioned any animal tests on the finished product, its prototype or any of its ingredients, and have not used ingredients tested on animals by others for the purpose of developing new cosmetic products. The French authorities take a stricter view: their recommendations list "not tested on animals" as a claim that presents a legal requirement as a specific benefit, contrary to criterion 1(3), and therefore as not acceptable. A brand selling in France should expect a plain "not tested on animals" claim to be challenged, and should not use any animal-testing claim without documents covering every supplier.

"Made in France" on a cosmetic

An origin claim on a cosmetic follows the general EU rule: where several countries are involved, the product originates where it underwent its last substantial, economically justified processing (Article 60(2) of the Union Customs Code), and simple filling, labelling or packaging does not confer origin on its own (Article 34 of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/2446). For a cosmetic, the question will usually be where the formula itself (the bulk) was made, rather than where it was filled and packed. An inaccurate origin claim is a misleading practice under Article L. 121-2, 2° b of the Consumer Code, which refers expressly to "made in France" and to the customs rules on non-preferential origin. The origin rules, and what a brand that manufactures elsewhere can write, are explained in our guide to Made in France claims when you manufacture abroad.

Claim What the texts and the French authorities say What to keep on file
"Natural", "X% of natural origin" No legal definition; ISO 16128 is a voluntary method; criteria 2, 3 and 6 Calculation ingredient by ingredient, supplier data, method used
"Clean" No legal or standard definition; risks under criteria 5 and 6 Written definition, check of each formula against it
"Vegan" No legal definition; absence of animal-derived ingredients treated as useful information (DGCCRF and ANSM); logo only if certified (Consumer Code, L. 121-4, 2°) Supplier statements for each ingredient; certificate if a logo is used
"Without X" Not acceptable for banned substances, unverifiable claims and families such as parabens; possible case by case where useful (DGCCRF and ANSM) Full formula, supplier statements, reasoning for each claim
"Not tested on animals" Strict conditions of Article 20(3) of Regulation 1223/2009; treated as not acceptable by the French authorities (criterion 1(3)) If used at all, documents covering the manufacturer and every supplier
"Hypoallergenic" Acceptable only if the product is designed to minimise its allergenic potential and the responsible person can prove it (DGCCRF and ANSM) Formulation rationale, allergen review, tolerance data
Organic or other certification logo Displaying a certificate or label without authorisation is deemed misleading (Consumer Code, L. 121-4, 2°) Valid certificate covering the product
"Made in France" Last substantial processing in France (Union Customs Code, Article 60, restated in Article 169 of Regulation 2026/2108 from 21 September 2027); filling, labelling or packing alone is not enough (Delegated Regulation 2015/2446, Article 34) Manufacturing contract, production records for the formula, supplier invoices

Evidence: the product information file

The responsible person must keep a product information file for each product, for ten years after the last batch was placed on the market (Article 11(1)). Among other items, it contains, where justified by the nature or the effect of the product, proof of the effect claimed (Article 11(2)(d)). The file must be readily accessible, in electronic or other format, at the responsible person's address shown on the label, in a language that the competent authorities can easily understand (Article 11(3)). In France, placing a product on the market without keeping the file available at that address, or with a file lacking the mandatory items, is an offence punishable by one year's imprisonment and a €15,000 fine (Article L. 5431-6 of the Public Health Code).

Every claim on the pack, the website and in advertising should be matched to the evidence that supports it, in the version actually used: efficacy or tolerance studies, supplier certificates on raw materials, the calculation behind a percentage, the certificate for any label displayed, or the written definition behind a word such as "clean". Supplier contracts should require prompt notice of any change, because a "without" or "vegan" claim becomes false the day a supplier changes a raw material.

What an inaccurate claim can cost

Criminal penalties for a misleading practice

A misleading commercial practice is an offence punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine for an individual. The fine can be raised, in proportion to the benefits derived, to 10% of average annual turnover over the last three years, or to 50% of the cost of the advertising or practice. When the offence is committed online or through a digital medium, the penalties rise to five years and €750,000 (Article L. 132-2 of the Consumer Code). Imprisonment rises to three years when the practice was followed by one or more contracts (Article L. 132-2-1). For a company, the maximum fine is five times that for an individual (Article 131-38 of the French Criminal Code). On conviction, the court orders the publication of all or part of the decision, and can order corrective notices at the convicted party's expense (Article L. 132-4).

Offences under the Public Health Code

Some breaches of the Cosmetics Regulation are offences in their own right, whether or not anyone was misled: breaching the animal-testing prohibitions (Article L. 5431-2), placing a product on the market without a complete product information file available at the label address (Article L. 5431-6), or without the labelling information required by Article 19 of the Regulation, which carries a €15,000 fine (Article L. 5431-7).

Administrative measures

After an adversarial procedure, the DGCCRF can order a business to comply or stop an unlawful practice within a reasonable time, with a daily penalty payment of up to €3,000 or, where the breach carries a fine of at least €75,000, as a misleading practice does, up to 0.1% of worldwide turnover (Article L. 521-1 of the Consumer Code). According to the DGCCRF and the ANSM, their action on cosmetic claims usually consists in asking for the withdrawal of contested claims, and can go as far as administrative measures or a report of an offence where there is an intention to mislead.

If the DGCCRF questions your claims

Questions usually start with a request for documents (Article L. 512-8 of the Consumer Code), a visit or an inspection report (procès-verbal). The first answer fixes the brand's position on what each claim means and what supports it. Before sending anything, check that the documents match the claims as they appeared on the date of the findings, and identify the claims you cannot support. Whether to defend, adjust or withdraw a claim, and how to present the evidence, should be decided with counsel, because the same file may later be read by a prosecutor.

Frequently asked questions

Can I put "vegan" on a cosmetic sold in France?

Yes, if no ingredient or substance in the product is of animal origin and you can prove it with supplier statements. There is no legal definition; the DGCCRF and the ANSM accept a claim of absence of animal-derived ingredients as useful information. A certification logo can be used only if you hold the certification (Article L. 121-4, 2° of the Consumer Code).

Is "not tested on animals" allowed on cosmetics in the EU?

Article 20(3) of Regulation 1223/2009 allows a reference to the absence of animal testing only under strict conditions covering the manufacturer and all its suppliers. The French authorities go further and consider the claim unacceptable, because it presents a legal requirement as a specific benefit (criterion 1(3) of Regulation 655/2013). In France, expect it to be challenged.

Can I say "without parabens" or "no silicones" on my cosmetics in France?

The DGCCRF and the ANSM consider that "without parabens" should be withdrawn, because it covers a family of substances some of which are authorised. "Without silicones" is among the claims they regard as potentially useful information, assessed case by case. Any "without" claim must be accurate and must not denigrate authorised ingredients.

What does "clean beauty" mean legally in France?

Nothing specific: there is no legal or standard definition. A brand using it must be able to explain precisely what it means, apply that meaning to each formula and avoid suggesting that other products are unsafe (criteria 5 and 6 of Regulation 655/2013).

Can a cosmetic filled in France be labelled "Made in France"?

Not on the strength of filling, labelling or packing alone, which do not confer origin (Article 34 of Delegated Regulation 2015/2446). The product must have undergone its last substantial processing in France (Article 60 of the Union Customs Code), which for a cosmetic usually means manufacturing the formula there.

What evidence do I need for a cosmetic claim?

Evidence that is adequate, verifiable and proportionate to the claim (criterion 3), kept in the product information file where the nature or effect of the product justifies it (Article 11(2)(d) of Regulation 1223/2009). Keep the file for ten years after the last batch and available at the address on the label.

Who is responsible for cosmetic claims if our brand is outside the EU?

The responsible person established in the EU: the importer, or a person it designates by written mandate (Article 4). The brand itself remains exposed if its communication misleads consumers in France (Article L. 132-1 of the Consumer Code).

What are the penalties for a misleading cosmetic claim in France?

Up to two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine for an individual, five years and €750,000 online, with a fine five times higher for a company (Article L. 132-2 of the Consumer Code; Article 131-38 of the Criminal Code), plus publication of any conviction.

Key actions

  • Before launch: list every claim on the pack, the website, marketplaces and social media, and match each one to its evidence in the product information file.
  • Sensitive claims: check "without" and animal-testing claims against the French authorities' recommendations, and write down what "clean", "natural" or "vegan" means for each product.
  • Suppliers: obtain written statements on the nature and origin of raw materials, with a duty to report any change.
  • If the DGCCRF writes to you: note the deadline, gather the evidence for each contested claim and have the answer reviewed before it is sent.

Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.