DGCCRF inspection report (procès-verbal): its legal weight

What a DGCCRF or DDPP inspection report (procès-verbal) proves in France, what it does not, and why you should read it before answering the authority.

What is a DGCCRF inspection report worth?

An inspection report (procès-verbal) drawn up by DGCCRF or DDPP officials is an investigation record, not a decision and not a sanction. Under Article L. 512-2 of the French Consumer Code, it is proof of the facts it records until proven otherwise. That presumption covers what the official personally observed; it does not turn the official's legal assessment into a proven fact.

Updated: November 2026. Key provisions: Articles L. 511-1 to L. 511-3, L. 512-2, L. 512-5 to L. 512-11, L. 522-2 to L. 522-5 and R. 512-1 of the French Consumer Code; Article L. 450-2 of the French Commercial Code; Articles 429 to 431 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure.

The DGCCRF (the French authority for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control) and its local offices, the DDPP (departmental directorates for the protection of populations), record what they find during an inspection in a written report, in French. That report becomes the basis of everything that follows: an injunction, an administrative fine, a settlement or a criminal case. It should be read not as an audit report but as a legal object with its own rules: who may sign it, what it must contain, what it proves and where its weight stops. A lawyer for DGCCRF and DDPP inspections can read it with you before you answer anything.

Would you like to discuss your situation? Book a consultation:

CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION

What an inspection report is, and what it is not

An investigation record, not a decision

Book V of the Consumer Code is organised in two parts. Title I deals with investigating and recording breaches; Title II deals with the measures that follow an inspection, such as injunctions, administrative fines and transactions. The report belongs to the first part. It fixes a set of facts at a given moment. It imposes nothing by itself, but it is the evidence on which any later measure will rely. That is why it should be read first.

Several kinds of reports

The word covers different documents, each with its own rules:

  • the report recording an offence or a breach, governed by Article R. 512-1;
  • the interview report, which must contain the questions asked and is read and signed by the person heard (Article L. 512-10);
  • the sampling report, which the owner or holder of the goods is invited to sign (Article R. 512-11);
  • the report of a visit authorised by a judge, drawn up on the spot with an inventory of what was seized (Article R. 512-40). On that procedure, see our article on DGCCRF dawn raids and legal privilege.

Reading one with the rules of another is a common source of error.

What the report is not

It is not a sanction: an administrative fine requires a later procedure, with a written notice, the right to be assisted by counsel and a reasoned decision (Article L. 522-5). It is not a final view either. The legal classification it proposes is a proposal; the decision belongs to the authority that sanctions or, in criminal matters, to the prosecutor and the court. A report can end with no further action, or with a procedure that keeps only part of the alleged breaches.

Where the rules are

Article L. 512-2: proof until proven otherwise

Article L. 512-2 states that offences and breaches are recorded in reports, which are proof until the contrary is shown. Three points follow from the wording. It covers both criminal offences and breaches punished by administrative fines, which the same report often mixes. It attaches the weight to the report as a record, not to the opinions of its author. And it expressly allows contrary evidence. The French Commercial Code has the same rule for investigations under its Book IV: the reports are sent to the competent authority, a copy goes to the persons concerned, and they are proof until proven otherwise (Article L. 450-2).

Article R. 512-1: the mandatory content

A report recording an offence or a breach must state the nature, the date and the place of the findings or checks, and it must be signed by the officials who made them (Article R. 512-1). These requirements look minimal, but each one decides whether you can check the report and answer it usefully.

The rules of the Code of Criminal Procedure

When the report goes to a criminal court, three general rules apply. A report has evidential value only if it is formally regular and its author acted in the course of their duties, on a matter within their competence, and reported what they saw, heard or found personally (Article 429 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). Unless the law provides otherwise, reports recording a délit (a mid-level criminal offence) are only information (Article 430). Where a special provision of law gives officials the power to record délits in reports, contrary evidence can only be brought in writing or through witnesses (Article 431).

Text Subject What to check in the report
Consumer Code, L. 511-2 Powers exercised anywhere in France The service that drew up the report and the powers used
Consumer Code, L. 511-3 and L. 511-5 to L. 511-7 Matters for which officials are empowered That the provisions relied on fall within those powers
Consumer Code, L. 512-2 Proof until proven otherwise Which statements are findings, and which are classifications or inferences
Consumer Code, L. 512-5 and L. 512-6 Hours and premises Time, place and type of premises
Consumer Code, L. 512-7, L. 512-16 and L. 512-2-1 Late disclosure of capacity, borrowed identity online, official not identified by name Whether the conditions of each rule are met and stated
Consumer Code, L. 512-8, L. 512-10 and L. 512-11 Documents, interviews, computer data Origin of each annexed document; questions recorded in interview reports
Consumer Code, R. 512-1 Mandatory content Nature, date and place of the findings; signature of the officials who made them
Consumer Code, L. 522-4 Copy sent before an administrative fine That the copy received is the report relied on
Commercial Code, L. 450-2 Reports in Commercial Code investigations Same presumption; copy sent to the persons concerned
Code of Criminal Procedure, 429 to 431 Value of reports before the criminal court Regularity, competence, personal findings; contrary evidence in writing or by witnesses

The official's powers and competence

Powers by subject matter

Offences and breaches are investigated and recorded under the powers defined in Book V (Article L. 511-1). DGCCRF officials are empowered for the provisions listed in the relevant section of the code, under the conditions those provisions set (Article L. 511-3). The lists are long and divided by subject (Articles L. 511-5 to L. 511-7). Other officials can be empowered for certain matters by order of the minister for the economy (Article L. 511-21). The question for any report is simple to ask: do the provisions relied on fall within the powers invoked?

No departmental limit

Empowered officials can use their powers anywhere in France (Article L. 511-2). There is no departmental limit on investigation powers. The territorial questions are therefore different: which service drew up the report, which authority can impose a fine, and whether the place stated matches the site actually inspected. Fines under the Consumer Code are decided by the Director General of the DGCCRF, the head of its national investigation service, the director of the DREETS (regional directorates for the economy, employment, labour and solidarity) or the director of the DDPP, who may delegate signature to senior officials (Article R. 522-1).

Who signed, and when the official said who they were

The report must be signed by the officials who made the findings (Article R. 512-1). Officials may wait until they inform you of the finding before revealing their capacity, but only where the proof depends on it and cannot be obtained otherwise (Article L. 512-7): two conditions, both required. For online checks, they may use a borrowed identity, under conditions set by decree (Article L. 512-16). Since 2 July 2025, an official may also be authorised not to be identified by name where revealing their identity could endanger their life or physical safety. The official is then identified by an administrative registration number, and the courts have access to the name (Article L. 512-2-1).

Date, time and place

Why the date matters

The date first decides the time bar. Under the Consumer Code, the authority's power to sanction a breach lapses after three full years from the day it was committed, for breaches carrying a fine above €3,000 for an individual or €15,000 for a company, if no act aimed at investigating, recording or sanctioning it has taken place in that period (Article L. 522-2). Below those amounts, the period is one year (Article L. 522-3). The date also decides which version of the law applies to the facts.

Hours and premises

Officials can operate on the public highway and, between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m., enter premises used for business or for providing a service. Outside those hours they can enter when the premises are open to the public or when production, manufacturing, processing, packaging, transport or sales activities are under way (Article L. 512-5). If the premises are also a home, checks can only take place between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. and, if the occupant objects, with the authorisation of the liberty and custody judge (juge des libertés et de la détention) (Article L. 512-6).

The place, including online

The place required by Article R. 512-1 is more than an address. For a group with several sites, it tells you which establishment was inspected, which documents were there and which activity was carried out. For distance selling, there are two places: where the official was, and the website or app consulted. A report that does not identify that digital environment clearly makes it hard to reconstruct what was seen.

The adversarial process and signatures

Two stages not to confuse

During the inspection, there is no organised debate: the official observes, collects and samples, and you can have statements recorded. The adversarial stage that the law requires comes later, before any fine. A copy of the report recording the breaches is sent to the person concerned (Article L. 522-4). The authority must then inform you in writing of the sanction it intends to impose, tell you that you may be assisted by counsel of your choice and invite you to submit written and, where relevant, oral observations (Article L. 522-5), within one month (Article R. 522-2). Our article on the DGCCRF notice of intended fine explains that stage.

Statements recorded in the report

Many reports contain statements from a manager or an employee. Interview reports must include the questions asked; the person reads the report, can have observations added and signs it, and any refusal to sign is noted (Article L. 512-10). Where there are plausible reasons to suspect that the person committed an offence, the rights of Article 61-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure apply, including the right to remain silent. In principle, the report proves that a statement was made in the terms recorded; whether the statement is accurate is another matter. A hasty answer given by someone who did not see the stakes can still weigh heavily later, because it will be read as an admission.

Signatures and copies

Article R. 512-1 requires the signature of the officials, not that of the business. A report recording a breach is not deprived of value because the manager did not sign it. Other reports follow other rules: the owner or holder of sampled goods is invited to sign the sampling report, and a refusal is noted (Article R. 512-11); a visit report is signed by the officials, the criminal police officer (officier de police judiciaire) present and, as the case may be, the occupant, their representative or two witnesses (Article R. 512-40). A copy of the report is sent before an administrative fine (Article L. 522-4) and attached to any criminal transaction proposal (Article L. 523-2).

Stage Legal basis (Consumer Code) Time limit What happens
During the inspection R. 512-1, L. 512-10, R. 512-11 None set Findings, statements recorded, documents handed over, samples
Before an administrative fine L. 522-4, L. 522-5, R. 522-2 One month from the written notice Copy of the report; written and, where relevant, oral observations; assistance of counsel
Publication of the fine, if intended L. 522-6 Announced during the adversarial stage Nature and terms of the intended publication
Before an injunction L. 521-1 Reasonable time limit set by the officials Adversarial procedure; scope of the compliance required; possible daily penalty
Criminal transaction proposed L. 523-1, L. 523-2, R. 523-3 One month from notification Copy of the report attached; accept, negotiate or refuse

What the report proves, and where its weight stops

A rebuttable presumption

"Proof until proven otherwise" is a rebuttable presumption. The content is taken as accurate, but you can show the contrary. You do not need to prove that the official lied: it is enough to show that a recorded fact is inaccurate, or that it does not mean what the report says it means.

What the presumption covers

The presumption concerns the material findings the official made personally while exercising their powers: what they saw, measured or noted, the documents they received, the statements made in front of them. This is consistent with Article R. 512-1, which requires the signature of the officials who made the findings, and with Article 429 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. A fact reported to the official by a third party, information taken from a complaint, or data extracted from a system without checking its origin should not carry the same weight.

What it does not cover

Three kinds of statement often appear in reports without being findings. Legal classifications: saying that a practice is misleading or that a term is unlawful applies a rule to a fact, and that is for the deciding authority or the court. Inferences: concluding from one finding that a practice was habitual, deliberate or widespread is reasoning, and reasoning can be discussed. Assessments of seriousness: calling a breach systematic or deliberate is a judgement. Reading a report largely means sorting these layers. This distinction rests on the wording of the texts and on case law; how a court applies it depends on the file.

Contrary evidence

Contrary evidence can come from documents dating from the time of the facts, technical data, extracts from your systems, witnesses or contradictions within the report itself. Before the criminal court, however, it must be brought in writing or through witnesses (Article 431 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). What matters is that each piece of evidence answers a specific statement. Deciding which statements call for evidence, which should be answered on the law and which need no answer is the core of the work on the file.

Findings of fact and legal assessment

Where the line runs

A finding answers the question "what was observed?". A legal assessment answers "how should it be classified?". A report stating that a display carried a given wording, in a given place and font size, makes a finding. The same report concluding that the average consumer was misled about an essential characteristic makes a classification. The weight given by Article L. 512-2 goes with the first statement and stops at the second. The classification still matters, but it is discussed as a point of law, not of proof.

How the line gets blurred

The slip is rarely open. It takes the form of a sentence that joins a finding and a legal conclusion, of wording that looks factual but already contains the law ("did not inform" assumes the duty to inform and its scope are settled), or of a generalisation from a few situations checked to the whole business.

Why it decides the answer

Contradicting a finding requires documents; contesting a classification requires legal argument. Arguing law against a well-established fact costs credibility, and producing documents against a classification does not answer the question. Which points are worth raising depends on the file and on the measure the authority has in mind.

Categories of irregularities that may be discussed

Without turning into a checklist, the points that can be raised against a report fall into broad families:

  • the author: the scope of the official's powers for the matter recorded, the link between the signatory and the official who made the findings, joint action by several services, and the conditions of special rules such as Articles L. 512-7 or L. 512-16;
  • form and mandatory content: nature, date, place and signature (Article R. 512-1), and the specific requirements for sampling or visit reports (Articles R. 512-11 and R. 512-40);
  • how the evidence was gathered: hours and premises (Articles L. 512-5 and L. 512-6), the scope of requests for documents (Article L. 512-8) and access to computer data and algorithms (Article L. 512-11). In digital matters, the completeness of extracts, their time-stamping and whether the files used are those you supplied become central;
  • content: internal contradictions, findings too vague to be answered, confusion between what was seen and what was inferred, annexes that do not support the statements, or a finding extended beyond what was checked.

These categories do not have the same effect. An irregularity may affect the validity of the record, only remove the weight of one statement, or have no useful effect if it caused no harm and the fact is established otherwise. The same flaw may also be treated differently in an administrative, transactional or criminal procedure. Selecting and ordering these points is work on the file, with counsel.

Why reading the report shapes everything that follows

The report decides the route

The same report can lead to several outcomes. If it records breaches punished by an administrative fine, it can open the procedure of Articles L. 522-1 and following: copy of the report, written notice, one month for observations, reasoned decision and possible publication (Articles L. 522-4 to L. 522-6 and R. 522-2). If it records a criminal offence, it is sent to the public prosecutor (procureur de la République), and the authority may propose a criminal transaction with the prosecutor's agreement (Article L. 523-1). See our article on a DGCCRF report sent to the prosecutor. It can also support an injunction to comply, which may carry a daily penalty (Article L. 521-1).

The report sets the scope and the clock

The report defines the facts relied on, the period covered, the entities concerned and the documents attached. An answer that goes beyond that scope opens questions no one had asked. An answer that ignores it leaves statements standing that may become the basis of the decision. And time is short: one month for observations on an intended fine (Article R. 522-2) is little when internal documents must be gathered and several alleged breaches analysed.

Frequently asked questions

Can I challenge a DGCCRF inspection report in court?

In principle, not on its own. The report is a preparatory investigation record that does not by itself change your legal position. Its regularity and weight are discussed when you challenge the measure based on it: an administrative fine (Articles L. 522-1 and following of the Consumer Code), an injunction (Article L. 521-1) or a criminal prosecution. That is why the report should be read with the later dispute in mind.

What does "proof until proven otherwise" mean for a DGCCRF report?

The material findings made personally by an empowered official are presumed accurate, but the presumption can be rebutted (Article L. 512-2). You do not have to show that the official lied, only that the fact is inaccurate or does not have the meaning given to it. The presumption does not extend to legal classifications or inferences. Before the criminal court, contrary evidence must be in writing or come from witnesses (Article 431 of the Code of Criminal Procedure).

Does the company's manager have to sign the report?

No. Article R. 512-1 requires the signature of the officials who made the findings, not that of the business. Interview reports are different: the person heard reads and signs them, and any refusal is noted (Article L. 512-10). Sampling and visit reports also have their own signature rules (Articles R. 512-11 and R. 512-40).

How long do we have to respond after a DGCCRF inspection?

If the authority intends to impose a fine under the Consumer Code, it must first inform you in writing and invite your observations (Article L. 522-5). The time limit is one month (Article R. 522-2) and runs from that written notice, not from the inspection. Fines under the Commercial Code, such as late payment fines, follow a different procedure with a longer time limit.

Can inspectors come at any time and enter any premises?

No. Business premises can be entered between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m., and outside those hours only if they are open to the public or activities are under way (Article L. 512-5). Premises that are also a home can only be checked between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. and, if the occupant objects, with a judge's authorisation (Article L. 512-6). Searches and seizures against your will follow a different procedure, authorised by a judge.

Can a DGCCRF inspector refuse to give their name?

Since July 2025, yes, in one case: an official can be authorised not to be identified by name where revealing their identity could endanger their life or physical safety. They are then identified by an administrative registration number, and the courts can access their name (Article L. 512-2-1).

How long can the DGCCRF wait before sanctioning a breach?

Three full years from the day the breach was committed, or one year for breaches carrying a fine of at most €3,000 for an individual or €15,000 for a company, if no act aimed at investigating, recording or sanctioning it has taken place in that period (Articles L. 522-2 and L. 522-3). The date in the report therefore matters.

Key actions

  • Report received: have it translated if needed, and check its type, date, place, signatures and the powers invoked.
  • Before answering: sort what was observed from what was inferred or classified, and list the documents that answer each finding.
  • Notice of intended fine: note the one-month time limit and ask for the file.
  • Criminal route: if the report is sent to the prosecutor or a transaction is proposed, take advice before replying.

Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.