Countdown timers and "only 2 left" messages are lawful in France only if true. Rules, DGCCRF checks, fines and the EU Digital Fairness Act proposal.

A stock counter or a countdown timer is lawful on a website selling to French consumers if it is true. French law does not prohibit telling customers that only two items remain, nor showing when a sale ends. It prohibits false statements: stock shown as almost sold out when the warehouse is full, a timer that restarts at every visit, a "limited" offer renewed every week. Under Article L. 121-2 of the French Consumer Code, a commercial practice is misleading if it relies on false or misleading claims about the existence, availability or nature of the product. Under Article L. 121-4, 7°, falsely stating that a product will only be available for a very limited time, in order to obtain an immediate decision, is misleading in all circumstances.
The penalty is criminal: two years' imprisonment and a fine of 300,000 euros, raised to five years and 750,000 euros when the offence is committed online (Article L. 132-2), with the maximum fine multiplied by five for a company. On 11 November 2026, the European Commission also proposed a Digital Fairness Act that would expressly target fake scarcity claims. Businesses preparing for Black Friday on 27 November 2026, or answering a request from the DGCCRF (the French authority for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control) or its local offices, the DDPP, may wish to work with a lawyer for DGCCRF and DDPP inspections.
CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION
Article L. 121-1 of the French Consumer Code prohibits unfair commercial practices, meaning practices contrary to professional diligence that materially distort, or are likely to distort, the economic behaviour of the average consumer. Misleading practices are one category. Article L. 121-2 covers false or misleading claims about, among other things, the availability of the product, its price, the promotional nature of the price and the conditions of sale. An "only 2 left" banner is a claim about availability. A countdown timer is a claim about the conditions of the offer and, almost always, about the promotional nature of the price.
Two questions are enough to assess an urgency message. Is it false or misleading? Could it lead a customer to buy, or to buy sooner, than they otherwise would? Urgency messages are designed to speed up decisions, so once the message is shown to be false, the second condition is rarely difficult for the authority to establish.
Article L. 121-4 lists practices deemed misleading in all circumstances. Point 7° covers falsely stating that a product or service will only be available for a very limited time, or on particular terms for a very limited time, in order to obtain an immediate decision and deprive consumers of the opportunity or time to make an informed choice. It transposes point 7 of Annex I to the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (2005/29/EC). For these practices, the authority does not need to show any effect on the average consumer: proving that the time limit was false is sufficient.
Point 5° of the same article targets offers at a stated price where the trader does not disclose that it has reasonable grounds to believe it will not be able to supply the product, or an equivalent, in reasonable quantities and for a reasonable period. The answer is a precise statement such as "limited to 50 units" when that is the case. Article L. 121-3 adds that omitting, hiding or providing in an unclear or untimely way a material piece of information, such as the real end date of a "limited" offer, is also misleading. Under Article L. 121-5, these rules also apply to practices aimed at business customers.
The message is lawful if it reflects the stock actually available for that variant (size, colour) when it is displayed. It becomes misleading if the number is fixed, random, or based on a small reserve while hundreds of units are available. Dropshippers, who hold no stock, are particularly exposed: they should only show stock levels if their supplier provides reliable, up-to-date data. The DGCCRF lists "fake stock" among the deceptive interface designs it regards as unlawful.
A timer is lawful if it reflects a real end date and time, the same for every visitor, and if the offer actually ends then. It is misleading if it restarts at each visit or page reload, if it is calculated from each visitor's arrival, or if the same offer resumes on the same terms once the deadline has passed. The DGCCRF expressly cites a countdown that restarts indefinitely as an example of false time urgency. An extension remains possible if it is exceptional, announced as an extension and not planned from the start.
Activity notifications are lawful if they are accurate and measured over the stated period for the product concerned. Invented or inflated figures fall within what the DGCCRF calls "fake activity". The same applies to pop-ups announcing purchases by named customers who do not exist.
A "last day" that comes back every week is not a last day, and a six-month "launch offer" is not a launch offer. When urgency comes with a price reduction, Article L. 112-1-1 adds a second rule: the previous price shown must be the lowest price applied by the trader to all consumers during the 30 days before the reduction. During Black Friday, inspectors often find both problems together.
In a practical guide written on 8 November 2023 and still online, the DGCCRF publishes a non-exhaustive list of deceptive interface designs it considers unlawful, assessed case by case. The first three categories concern urgency directly: false time urgency, fake stock and fake activity.
Under Article L. 512-16 of the Consumer Code, authorised officers may use a borrowed identity to check online sales and commercial practices. In practice, an inspector can visit the site as an ordinary customer over several days, open the same page in two browsers, place an order and record that the timer restarts or that the displayed stock never goes down. Two screenshots taken a few minutes apart showing two different deadlines are often enough.
Under Article L. 512-15, officers may require the trader to provide all evidence supporting its claims, including evidence held by a manufacturer outside France. For urgency messages, that means the history of displayed stock against actual stock, the timer settings, the real start and end dates of each campaign and the source of activity figures. A business that cannot produce anything is in a weak position, even if its messages were accurate.
On 30 January 2023, the European Commission and consumer authorities from 23 Member States, Norway and Iceland published the results of a coordinated screening of 399 online shops: 148 used at least one of the practices examined, and 42 used fake countdown timers. In France, a DGCCRF investigation carried out in 2021 among 42 telecom and internet businesses found subscription offers presented as limited in time, sometimes with a countdown, which followed or overlapped each other so as to form a permanent offer. In a press release of 23 February 2021, the DGCCRF also reported that a dropshipping company had agreed to pay 10,000 euros under a criminal settlement approved by the public prosecutor, for several misleading practices including a fictitious end-of-sale countdown.
Misleading practices are punishable by two years' imprisonment and a 300,000 euro fine, which may be raised, in proportion to the benefit obtained, to 10% of average annual turnover or 50% of the advertising spend. When committed online, the penalties rise to five years and 750,000 euros (Article L. 132-2), and the prison term is raised to three years where contracts were concluded as a result (Article L. 132-2-1). For a company, the maximum fine is five times that for individuals (Article 131-38 of the French Criminal Code): 3,750,000 euros for an online offence. The offence applies whenever the practice is carried out or has effects in France (Article L. 132-1), which covers foreign websites targeting French consumers.
Without going to court, the authority may also issue a compliance order after an adversarial procedure, with a daily penalty of up to 3,000 euros, or up to 0.1% of worldwide turnover per day for offences punishable by a fine of at least 75,000 euros (Article L. 521-1), and may publish the order at the trader's expense (Article L. 521-2). Our article on responding to a DGCCRF compliance order explains that procedure. Where the trader cannot be identified or ignores an order, the authority may require warning messages, delisting or domain-name blocking (Article L. 521-3-1). Before prosecution, a criminal settlement may be proposed with the prosecutor's approval, for an amount below the maximum fine (Article L. 523-1).
Article 25(1) of the Digital Services Act (Regulation (EU) 2022/2065) prohibits online platforms from designing their interfaces in a way that deceives or manipulates users. Under Article 25(2), however, that prohibition does not apply to practices covered by the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive or the GDPR. A fake stock counter or fake timer on a marketplace therefore remains a misleading commercial practice under the French Consumer Code. In principle, each party answers for the messages it designs or configures: the seller for the stock and offer duration it declares, the platform for banners and counters it generates itself.
On 11 November 2026, the European Commission presented a proposal for a regulation on fair business-to-consumer commercial practices, the Digital Fairness Act (COM(2026) 1100 final). It would repeal the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive and replace it with a directly applicable regulation. According to the Commission's questions and answers, the updated blacklist would include fake claims that a product is running out or that other customers are interested, messages shaming consumers who decline an offer, and default options consumers must reject.
The annex to the proposal keeps the existing ban on false "very limited time" offers (point 13) and adds announcing very limited availability without stating how long the offer lasts (point 14), false or insufficiently qualified claims about availability or popularity (point 53) and persistently displaying availability or popularity messages throughout the ordering process to create a sense of scarcity (point 54). The numbering may change during negotiations. The proposal also provides for a reminder and active consent before a free trial becomes a paid contract, an online termination function and a right to reach a human in customer service. France already requires an online cancellation function for contracts that can be concluded online (Article L. 215-1-1, in force since 1 June 2023), as explained in our article on consumer subscriptions in France.
A companion revision of the Consumer Protection Cooperation Regulation would allow the Commission to investigate and fine directly in large-scale cases affecting consumers in at least two-thirds of Member States, representing at least two-thirds of the EU population, where the company is not an SME, with fines of up to 6% of worldwide annual turnover. None of this is adopted yet: the European Parliament and the Council must examine the proposal, and the date of application will depend on the final text. The current French rules already apply to fake stock and fake timers.
Yes, if they reflect a real deadline that applies to every visitor and the offer actually ends then. A timer that falsely announces a very limited offer is misleading in all circumstances under Article L. 121-4, 7° of the French Consumer Code.
Yes, if the figure matches the stock actually available for the variant shown. A fixed, random or inflated figure is a false claim about availability under Article L. 121-2.
Up to five years' imprisonment and 750,000 euros for an online misleading practice, which may be raised to 10% of average annual turnover; the maximum fine is multiplied by five for a company. The authority may also issue a published compliance order with daily penalties.
No. The Commission presented its proposal on 11 November 2026. It still has to be examined and adopted by the European Parliament and the Council.
The business running the website answers for what it displays. It may then have a claim against the agency or app provider under its contract, but that does not remove its own exposure to the authority.
Yes, when the practice is carried out or has effects in France, for instance a site in French delivering to French customers (Article L. 132-1).
Stock counters, activity notifications and countdown timers are allowed in France when they are true and the business can prove it. When false, they are misleading commercial practices, punishable online by up to 3,750,000 euros for a company, in addition to published compliance orders and daily penalties. The proposed Digital Fairness Act confirms and details this approach without changing the basic rule. Before Black Friday, reviewing every urgency message on your site and the tools that generate it is the simplest step. The firm advises online sellers on their purchase journeys and represents businesses inspected by the DGCCRF or a DDPP, from the first request for documents to challenging a penalty.
CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION
Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.