Product recall in France: who acts and who pays?

Unsafe or non-compliant product in France: complaints register, RappelConso, telling customers, DGCCRF orders, penalties and who bears the recall cost.

Non-compliant or recalled product in France: who must tell customers, who runs the recall and who pays between manufacturer, own-brand retailer, shop and installer?

When a product sold in France is unsafe, the manufacturer must act first: take corrective action, including withdrawal or recall, inform consumers and notify the authorities (Article 9(8) of Regulation (EU) 2023/988 on general product safety, the GPSR). A retailer selling a product under its own brand is treated as the manufacturer (Article 13). Importers have similar duties; distributors must alert their supplier and make sure action is taken. Any business that recalls a product must declare the recall on the French public website RappelConso and keep a numbered record of the products withdrawn or recalled (Article L. 423-3 of the French Consumer Code). As for the final bill, the seller first owes the consumer a repair, replacement or refund, then turns to its supplier and the producer (Article L. 217-31), under the Civil Code and the terms of its supply contract.

Updated: November 2026. Key provisions: Articles 3, 9, 11 to 14, 19, 20, 22, 35 to 37 and 52 of Regulation (EU) 2023/988; Articles L. 217-3 to L. 217-31, L. 411-1, L. 423-3, L. 441-1, L. 452-5-1, L. 452-7, L. 454-1 to L. 454-4, L. 521-1 to L. 521-17, L. 531-6, L. 532-1 and L. 532-3 of the French Consumer Code; Articles 1245 to 1245-16 of the French Civil Code; Article 131-38 of the French Criminal Code.

Getting this wrong is expensive. A manufacturer or importer that fails to take the required measures for an unsafe product faces five years' imprisonment and a fine of 600,000 euros, which can be raised to 10% of average annual turnover (Article L. 452-5-1). The DGCCRF (the French authority for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control) and the DDPPs (the local consumer protection directorates in each French département) can also order withdrawal, recall or destruction at the expense of the businesses they designate. If you discover a defect in a product already sold in France, involve a lawyer for DGCCRF and DDPP inspections early, before the first exchanges with the authorities. The texts cited were read on 16 November 2026; the case study is fictitious.

Would you like to discuss your situation? Book a consultation:

CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION

Non-compliant, unsafe, withdrawal, recall: the words that trigger the duties

A non-compliant product does not match what was promised or what regulations require: a different composition, incomplete labelling, a lower grade than ordered. An unsafe (in the Regulation's words, "dangerous") product presents a risk to health or safety. The two often overlap, but not always. The heaviest GPSR duties (immediate corrective action, informing consumers, notifying authorities) are triggered by danger. A non-compliance without danger is first a contractual and legal guarantee issue, but French authorities may still order the withdrawal or recall of products that do not comply with regulations, even without danger (Article L. 521-7 of the Consumer Code).

The Regulation defines a withdrawal as any measure aimed at preventing a product in the supply chain from being made available on the market, and a recall as any measure aimed at achieving the return of a product already made available to the consumer (Article 3). The GPSR has applied since 13 December 2024 (Article 52). It does not cover medicines, food or animal feed (Article 2(2)). For products covered by sector-specific EU harmonisation legislation, such as toys, part of the Regulation is disapplied, including the detailed duties of manufacturers, importers and distributors in Chapter III, Section 1, but the rules on distance sales, accidents, online marketplaces and consumer recalls still apply (Article 2(1)).

Who does what

The manufacturer

Where a manufacturer considers or has reason to believe that a product it has placed on the market is dangerous, it must immediately take effective corrective measures, including withdrawal or recall where appropriate, inform consumers (Articles 35 and 36) and notify the market surveillance authorities of the Member States concerned through the EU Safety Business Gateway portal (Article 9(8)). The threshold is low: having reason to believe is enough; certainty is not required. A series of similar complaints or one injured customer can trigger the duty. The manufacturer must also report serious accidents caused by its products (Article 20).

The own-brand retailer

Any person who places a product on the market under its own name or trademark is considered a manufacturer and bears all the duties of Article 9 (Article 13(1)). It makes no difference that the retailer never made the product or bought it through a sourcing office. French civil law takes the same approach for damage: a business that presents itself as producer by affixing its name or brand is treated as the producer (Article 1245-5 of the Civil Code).

The importer, the distributor and the online seller

An importer that has reason to believe an imported product is dangerous must inform the manufacturer, ensure corrective action is taken and take it itself if it has not been, ensure consumers are informed and notify the authorities (Article 11(8)). A distributor (wholesaler, shop, reselling website) must not supply a product it believes non-compliant; if it has reason to believe a product it sold is dangerous, it must immediately inform the manufacturer or importer, ensure corrective action is taken and ensure the authorities are informed (Article 12(3) and (4)). Online sellers have the duties of their status, plus mandatory information in the online offer (Article 19). Online marketplaces must directly inform all affected consumers who bought through their interface when a safety recall comes to their knowledge (Article 22(12)). Foreign sellers should note that these duties apply to products sold to French consumers wherever the seller is based, as explained in our article on selling to French consumers from abroad.

The installer

An installer that supplies a product as part of its service makes it available on the market and is, depending on the facts, in a position comparable to a distributor. If it substantially modifies the product in a way that affects safety, it becomes a manufacturer for the modified part or the whole product (Article 13(2)). Under the French legal guarantee, a seller that repairs or replaces a non-conforming item must, where relevant, remove it and install the repaired or replacement item (Article L. 217-10 of the Consumer Code).

Business Status under Regulation (EU) 2023/988 Unsafe product: what it must do Complaints register Provisions
Manufacturer Manufacturer Immediate corrective action (including withdrawal or recall), inform consumers, notify authorities via Safety Business Gateway, report serious accidents Yes: complaints alleging a danger, recalls, corrective measures Art. 9(8), 9(12), 20
Retailer selling under its own brand Treated as manufacturer Same duties as the manufacturer; treated as producer for damage claims Yes Art. 13(1); Civil Code, Art. 1245-5
Importer Importer Inform the manufacturer, ensure corrective action and take it if missing, ensure consumers are informed, notify authorities Manufacturer's register or its own Art. 11(8), 11(10)
Distributor (wholesaler, shop, reselling website) Distributor Stop selling, inform the manufacturer or importer immediately, ensure corrective action and notification, pass the recall on to its customers Not required; internal safety processes required Art. 12(3), 12(4), 14, 35
Online marketplace Online marketplace provider Directly inform buyers of a recall it knows of, cooperate with authorities and businesses No Article 9 register Art. 22(12)
Installer Distributor if it supplies the product; manufacturer if it substantially modifies it Duties of its status; under the legal guarantee, removal and reinstallation Only if it has manufacturer status Art. 13(2); Consumer Code, L. 217-10
Any business withdrawing or recalling Economic operator Numbered record of products withdrawn or recalled; RappelConso declaration for recalls Not applicable Consumer Code, L. 423-3

The complaints register

The register is a duty of the manufacturer, and therefore of the own-brand retailer. Manufacturers must investigate complaints and information on accidents concerning the safety of their products where the complainant claims the product is dangerous, and keep an internal register of those complaints, of product recalls and of any corrective measures taken (Article 9(12)). The register does not cover every customer complaint, only those alleging a danger, plus recalls and corrective measures. Manufacturers must also provide public channels (telephone, email, a dedicated section of their website) for complaints and safety reports (Article 9(11)).

Importers record such complaints, recalls and corrective measures in the manufacturer's register or in their own (Article 11(10)). Distributors have no register duty, but every economic operator must have internal processes for product safety (Article 14). Personal data in the register may be kept only as long as needed and no longer than five years after entry (Articles 9(13) and 11(11)).

French law adds a duty for all operators, distributors included: when a withdrawal or recall is carried out, they must keep an up-to-date numbered record of the products withdrawn or recalled, available to inspectors (Article L. 423-3, first paragraph). Failure is punishable by a fine of 5,000 euros (Article L. 452-7).

Notifying the authorities, declaring on RappelConso and informing customers

Safety Business Gateway

For non-food products, dangerous products are notified through Safety Business Gateway. The DGCCRF states that notifications are forwarded to the competent local office and that the acknowledgement of receipt does not validate the information provided or the adequacy of the measures announced.

RappelConso

Businesses that recall products must also declare the recall online on a dedicated public website run by the authorities (Article L. 423-3, second paragraph): RappelConso. The procedure is set by an order (arrêté) of 20 January 2021, in force since 1 April 2021 and amended by an order of 20 February 2026, applicable since 12 March 2026. The declaration is made when recall measures are implemented and updated as new information arrives; the business certifies that the competent authority has been informed; the recall notice is published only once the authority approves it. The DGCCRF states that the duty applies to all recalls carried out since April 2021.

Informing customers

All affected consumers who can be identified must receive a direct notification without undue delay, using customer data the business holds (Article 35). A written recall notice must carry the heading set by the Regulation (in French: « Rappel de produit pour des raisons de sécurité »), identify the product (picture, name, brand, batch or serial numbers), describe the danger clearly without terms that downplay it (the Regulation cites words meaning voluntary, precautionary, discretionary, in rare situations or in specific situations) or any statement that no accident has been reported, tell consumers to stop using the product immediately, describe the remedies, provide a free telephone number or interactive online service and encourage sharing (Article 36). The business responsible for the recall must offer an effective, free and timely remedy, with a choice of at least two of repair, replacement or a refund at least equal to the price paid; the consumer never pays shipping or return costs (Article 37).

Business customers must be told too. Where the authorities have ordered a measure, any operator aware of it must inform its supplier and the businesses to which it sold the products (Article L. 521-9). Keeping a known non-conformity from a business customer may also amount to deception as to substantial qualities (Article L. 441-1). On 12 November 2026, the DGCCRF published an injunction ordering two companies to inform, without delay, the business customers to which they had supplied steel of a different grade from the one ordered, without telling them although they knew of the substitution. The published notice does not state the legal basis of the injunction.

What the DGCCRF and DDPPs can order, and the penalties

After an adversarial procedure, inspectors may order a business to comply within a reasonable time limit (Article L. 521-1), with a daily penalty of up to 3,000 euros (300,000 euros in total) or, where the breach carries a fine of at least 75,000 euros, up to 0.1% of worldwide turnover per day (5% in total). The injunction may be published at the business's expense (Article L. 521-2). How to respond is covered in our guide to DGCCRF injunctions. Failing to comply leads to an administrative fine of up to 15,000 euros for an individual and 75,000 euros for a company, or the fine for the original breach if higher (Article L. 532-1).

Where products do not comply with regulations or are or may be dangerous, the authorities may order by decree (arrêté) the suspension of sales, withdrawal, recall and destruction, warnings, and a recall for exchange, modification or full or partial refund (Article L. 521-7). The costs are borne by the operators designated in the order (Article L. 521-8). In cases of serious or immediate danger, ministers may suspend a product for up to one year and order withdrawal, destruction or recall (Article L. 521-17). Inspectors' sampling and testing costs are charged to the person responsible for placing the product on the market where non-compliance is established (Article L. 531-6).

Breach Individual Company Provision
Manufacturer or importer failing to take required measures for an unsafe product; marketplace breaching Art. 22(12) 5 years and 600,000 euros, up to 10% of average annual turnover Up to five times the fixed fine (3 million euros) Consumer Code, L. 452-5-1; Criminal Code, 131-38
No up-to-date numbered record of withdrawn or recalled products 5,000 euros 25,000 euros Consumer Code, L. 452-7; Criminal Code, 131-38
Failing to carry out a withdrawal, recall or destruction ordered by the authorities 2 years and 15,000 euros, 30,000 euros where there is a danger 75,000 euros, 150,000 euros where there is a danger Consumer Code, L. 532-3; Criminal Code, 131-38
Failing to comply with an injunction in time Administrative fine up to 15,000 euros, or the fine for the original breach if higher Administrative fine up to 75,000 euros, or the fine for the original breach if higher Consumer Code, L. 532-1
Deception as to substantial qualities, fitness for use or risks 3 years and 300,000 euros (7 years and 750,000 euros if it made the goods dangerous to health), up to 10% of average annual turnover Up to five times the fine for individuals Consumer Code, L. 441-1, L. 454-1, L. 454-3, L. 454-4; Criminal Code, 131-38

Challenging these decisions is covered in our article on how to challenge a DGCCRF fine.

Who pays in the end?

Towards the consumer, the seller pays first. The seller owes conforming goods and is liable for defects appearing within two years of delivery (Article L. 217-3), presumed to exist at delivery if they appear within 24 months (Article L. 217-7). The consumer chooses between repair and replacement, which must be done within 30 days at most (Article L. 217-10) and free of charge (Article L. 217-11). A shop cannot send its customer to the manufacturer.

Upstream, the seller has a right of recourse. Article L. 217-31 allows the seller to bring a recourse action against any person upstream in the chain of commercial transactions, including the producer, in accordance with the Civil Code. It follows Civil Code rules (latent defects, delivery of conforming goods, contractual liability) and the clauses agreed between businesses, including any limitation of warranty.

For damage caused by the product, the producer is liable whether or not it has a contract with the victim (Article 1245 of the Civil Code). A product is defective when it does not provide the safety a person is entitled to expect (Article 1245-3). Own-brand retailers and EU importers are treated as producers (Article 1245-5). If the producer cannot be identified, the seller is liable unless it names its supplier or the producer within three months (Article 1245-6). Exclusion clauses are void, except between businesses for damage to property not mainly used privately (Article 1245-14). Claims are time-barred three years after the victim knew or should have known of the damage, the defect and the producer's identity (Article 1245-16), and liability ends ten years after the product was put into circulation, save for fault (Article 1245-15). Directive (EU) 2024/2853 must be transposed by 9 December 2026 and will apply to products placed on the market or put into service after that date; as of 16 November 2026, these Civil Code articles have not yet been amended.

Between businesses, the contract decides. A useful recall clause covers who alerts whom and how fast, who decides on a recall (an own-brand retailer cannot wait for its supplier's consent to meet its own duties), batch traceability, which costs are covered (logistics, refunds, destruction, communication, testing, lost margin, compensation of victims), proof of the origin of the defect, product liability and recall insurance, and approval of recall notices and RappelConso declarations.

A model internal procedure

  • Before any incident: batch or serial numbers on products (Article 9(5)), traceability from each batch to suppliers, warehouses and customers, public complaint channels, and a customer service team trained to spot complaints that mention a danger.
  • On the first alert: a small crisis team (management, quality, purchasing, logistics, customer service, communication, legal, outside counsel where the risk is serious) that decides on danger, batches, quantities, sales freeze, withdrawal or recall, notification, RappelConso, customer contact, suppliers and insurers, and keeps a written log of its decisions.
  • The customer message: the mandatory recall notice content, consistent with what was declared to the authorities and on RappelConso.
  • After the recall: numbered record, register, proof of customer information and detailed costs, which inspectors will ask for and which will support the claim against the supplier or insurer.

Case study (fictitious)

A garden centre chain with 45 shops and a website sells a folding metal garden chair under its own brand, made outside the EU by a subcontractor and imported by the group's sourcing office. Over one season it sold 8,400 chairs at 39 euros, in three batches. Customers report that the locking system gives way and the chair folds under the user; one customer fell and injured a wrist. Shops refund on a case-by-case basis and put the remaining chairs back on sale.

As an own-brand retailer, the chain is the manufacturer under the GPSR and a producer under the Civil Code. Converging complaints give it reason to believe the chair is dangerous. It must stop sales of the batches concerned, decide on a recall, notify the authorities through Safety Business Gateway, report the accident if serious, record the complaints and recall in its register, declare the recall on RappelConso and keep the numbered record. Customers identified through loyalty cards or online orders are notified directly; others through a recall notice in store and online, without describing the recall as precautionary. Each customer chooses between a safe replacement and a refund, with no return costs. Refunds alone could reach 327,600 euros if every chair comes back, before logistics, destruction, communication and possible compensation. The chain pays its customers, then claims against the sourcing office and the manufacturer under the right of recourse and its supply contract. Without a recall clause, or with a limitation of warranty accepted without negotiation, part of the cost may stay with the chain. Quietly refunding and reselling the remaining stock is exactly what exposes a manufacturer to the penalties of Article L. 452-5-1.

Would you like to discuss your situation? Book a consultation:

CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION

FAQ

Who pays for a product recall in France, the manufacturer or the retailer?

Towards consumers, the seller owes a free repair, replacement or refund, and the business responsible for the recall must offer a free remedy. The seller then has a right of recourse against its suppliers and the producer (Article L. 217-31). The final split depends on the origin of the defect and the supply contracts.

Is a complaints register mandatory under the GPSR?

Yes, for manufacturers, including own-brand retailers: an internal register of complaints alleging a danger, recalls and corrective measures (Article 9(12)). Importers use the manufacturer's register or their own; distributors have no register duty but need internal safety processes.

Is declaring a recall on RappelConso mandatory?

Yes. Any business that recalls a product in France must declare it on RappelConso (Article L. 423-3), in addition to notifying the authorities and informing customers directly.

Is an own-brand retailer liable like a manufacturer?

Yes. It is a manufacturer under Article 13 of the GPSR and a producer under Article 1245-5 of the Civil Code, for recall duties and for damage caused by the product.

What is the penalty for failing to recall an unsafe product in France?

Five years' imprisonment and a fine of 600,000 euros for a manufacturer or importer, up to 10% of average annual turnover (Article L. 452-5-1), and up to five times the fixed amount for a company. Failing to carry out a recall ordered by the authorities carries two years and 15,000 euros, or 30,000 euros where there is a danger (Article L. 532-3).

Must business customers be told about a non-compliant product?

Yes, where the authorities have ordered a measure (Article L. 521-9), and more generally because hiding a known non-conformity may amount to deception (Article L. 441-1). The DGCCRF injunction published on 12 November 2026 illustrates this.

Conclusion

When a product goes wrong in France, the duties follow quickly: the manufacturer, and the own-brand retailer that shares its status, takes corrective action and informs consumers and the authorities; the importer relays and steps in; the distributor alerts and stops selling. The recall is declared on RappelConso, tracked in a numbered record and logged in the complaints register. The cost is settled in two stages: the seller pays the customer, then turns upstream, where traceability, the register and recall clauses make the difference. Victoris advises manufacturers, retailers, importers, distributors and installers on recall procedures and contracts, on handling a recall with the French authorities and on recovering its cost.

CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION

Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.