17/11/26

Resale at a loss in France: the ban, thresholds and fines

Resale at a loss in France: Article L. 442-5, fines of up to 0.4% of French turnover, the 10% food uplift until April 2028, private labels, exceptions.

Is resale at a loss illegal in France?

Yes. Under Article L. 442-5 of the French Commercial Code, any trader who resells a product in the state in which it was bought, or advertises such a resale, at a price below its effective purchase price commits a criminal offence. Since 15 April 2025, the fine can reach 0.4% of the trader's annual turnover in France, excluding VAT, and for food and pet food sold to consumers the threshold is raised by 10% until 15 April 2028.

Updated: November 2026. Key provisions: Articles L. 442-5, L. 441-7, L. 450-1 to L. 450-3, L. 470-1 and L. 490-2 to L. 490-5 of the French Commercial Code; Article 125 of Law No. 2020-1525 of 7 December 2020; Articles 112-1, 131-38 and 131-39 of the French Criminal Code; Article 8 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure.

The rule is enforced by the DGCCRF (the French authority for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control) and its local offices, the DDPP (departmental directorates for the protection of populations). It concerns retailers, buying groups, wholesalers and online sellers, and foreign suppliers too: their invoices, rebates and private-label contracts are the raw material of the calculation. Law No. 2025-337 of 14 April 2025 replaced the former €75,000 fine with a fine based on turnover, extended the ban to certain private-label products and kept the 10% uplift for food until 2028. A lawyer for DGCCRF and DDPP inspections can review a pricing operation before it starts, or the file after an inspection report.

Would you like to discuss your situation? Book a consultation:

CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION

A criminal offence under Article L. 442-5 of the Commercial Code

Where the rule sits

The ban has been in Article L. 442-5 since 26 April 2019, following Ordinance No. 2019-359 of 24 April 2019. Older contracts and internal price policies sometimes still cite a former article number: update them. The article sits in Book IV of the code, on prices and competition, so investigations follow the Book IV rules (Articles L. 450-1 and following), even when the buyer is a consumer.

What the offence covers

The text targets "any trader", whether it sells in a shop, online or to other businesses: resales by a wholesaler or a buying group are covered too. It concerns products resold in the state in which they were bought, without processing, so a manufacturer selling its own production is not covered for that production. It punishes the resale and also the mere announcement: a leaflet, a website banner or a shelf label showing a price below the threshold is enough, even before any sale. Where an advertisement shows such a price, the fine can be raised to half of the advertising spend.

Not the same as the promotion caps or the 30-day reference price

  • Promotion caps. Under Article 125, II of Law No. 2020-1525, promotional benefits on fast-moving consumer goods (produits de grande consommation) cannot exceed 34% of the consumer price, or an equivalent increase in quantity; the cap is 40% for non-food consumer goods. Promoted products also cannot exceed 25% of the forecast turnover in the annual agreement with the supplier (or of the forecast volume in a private-label contract). A breach carries an administrative fine of up to €75,000 for an individual and €375,000, or half of the advertising spend, for a company. These are the figures often wrongly attributed to resale at a loss.
  • The 30-day reference price. Under Article L. 112-1-1 of the French Consumer Code, an announced price reduction must show the prior price, which is the lowest price charged to all consumers in the 30 days before the reduction. See our guide to product and price labelling in France.

One operation can fall under all three regimes. A fictitious "two for the price of one" offer on a food product exceeds the 34% cap, may take the unit price below the threshold and, if presented as a price reduction, must show the prior price. Each regime has its own procedure and penalties: an answer that mixes them up weakens your position.

The effective purchase price: how the threshold is calculated

The statutory formula

The threshold is not the supplier's list price. Article L. 442-5 defines the effective purchase price as the unit net price on the purchase invoice, minus all other financial benefits granted by the seller, expressed as a percentage of the unit net price, plus turnover taxes, specific taxes on the resale and the cost of transport. Off-invoice benefits, such as year-end rebates, are deducted if they can be expressed as a percentage of the unit net price.

Disputes rarely concern the principle and almost always concern the documents: which invoice, which benefits were actually earned at the date of resale, their link to the product. Conditional rebates whose condition was not yet met, payments for commercial cooperation services and global benefits not allocated by product each raise different questions. How rebates are drafted in the annual agreement with the supplier therefore weighs directly on the threshold.

A worked example (fictitious)

A DIY retailer buys a drill at €40.00 excluding VAT, net invoice price. The supplier grants a 5% year-end rebate, earned and linked to the product (€2.00), and transport costs €0.80 per unit. The effective purchase price is €38.80 excluding VAT, or €46.56 with 20% VAT. A catalogue price of €45.90 is an advertised resale at a loss, unless an exception applies. If the rebate was not yet earned at the date of sale, or could not be linked to the product, the result may change: that is where the discussion with the authority takes place.

The 0.9 coefficient for wholesalers

The effective purchase price is multiplied by 0.9 for a wholesaler that sells exclusively to independent professionals who are retailers, processors or end service providers. A business is independent if it sets its own commercial policy and has no capital link or affiliation with the wholesaler. In the example, such a wholesaler could resell the drill down to €34.92 excluding VAT. A buying group supplying stores affiliated to its own network will often struggle to rely on this coefficient.

The 10% uplift on food (SRP+10) until 15 April 2028

Legal basis and duration

The uplift, known in France as "SRP+10", comes from the EGalim reform of food pricing. Its legal basis is Article 125 of Law No. 2020-1525. Under paragraph I, the effective purchase price is multiplied by 1.10 for food and pet food resold as is to consumers, except drinks subject to excise duties under Article 403 of the French General Tax Code. The mechanism has applied since 2019. In the version in force since 15 April 2025, paragraph VIII provides that paragraphs I, II and IV apply until 15 April 2028: the uplift and the promotion caps run to the same date. Unless the law is extended again, the ordinary threshold will apply to food after that date. A decree may also suspend the uplift and the promotion caps if buyers' behaviour undermines the objectives of the reform (paragraph VI).

Which products, and how the coefficient works

Three conditions must all be met: food or pet food, resold as is, to a consumer. Household, hygiene and beauty products are not covered by the uplift, even when the promotion caps apply to them, and neither are sales between businesses. Fictitious example: a supermarket buys a box of cereal at €2.00 excluding VAT, receives a €0.10 benefit linked to the product and pays €0.05 of transport. The effective purchase price is €1.95 excluding VAT, about €2.06 with 5.5% VAT. The 1.10 coefficient brings the threshold to €2.27, rounded up. A shelf price of €2.19 is a resale at a loss, unless an exception applies.

Alcoholic drinks, fruit and vegetables, overseas territories

For drinks subject to excise duties, paragraph I bis adds 0.1 times a value P, equal to the effective purchase price minus the excise duties and the social security contribution under Article L. 245-7 of the French Social Security Code. If a bottle of spirits has an effective purchase price of €12, including €3 of duties and contribution (fictitious figures), P is €9 and the threshold is €12.90. Under paragraph I ter, the uplift does not apply to products listed in Parts IX (fruit and vegetables) and XI (bananas) of Annex I to Regulation (EU) No 1308/2013, unless a ministerial order brings some of them back at the request of the trade body. The article does not apply in Guadeloupe, French Guiana, Martinique, La Réunion, Mayotte, Saint-Barthélemy, Saint-Martin and Saint-Pierre-et-Miquelon (paragraph V).

The annual report under paragraph IV bis

Each distributor of fast-moving consumer goods must send the ministers for the economy and agriculture, before 1 September each year, a document showing how much of the extra turnover generated by the uplift was passed on to suppliers through higher purchase prices, and answer any request for details within fifteen days. Failure carries an administrative fine of up to 0.4% of annual turnover in France, imposed under Article L. 470-2 of the Commercial Code. This fine is administrative; the resale-at-a-loss fine is criminal, although the ceiling is the same.

Private labels: paragraph IV, in force since 15 April 2025

The text and its scope

Law No. 2025-337 added a paragraph IV to Article L. 442-5: the ban "applies to products sold under a distributor's brand acquired under the conditions laid down in Article L. 441-7". Article L. 441-7 governs the contract between a supplier and a distributor for the design and production of food products to the buyer's specific requirements, sold under the distributor's brand. As an extension of a criminal offence, paragraph IV applies only to sales and announcements from 15 April 2025: under Article 112-1 of the Criminal Code, only acts that were an offence when committed can be punished. For private-label food sold to consumers, the 1.10 coefficient also applies.

What it means for retailers, buying groups and manufacturers

For the retailer, the floor price of a private-label food product is now calculated like that of a national brand, from the manufacturer's invoice and the benefits it grants; entry-level products used to draw customers are the most exposed. A buying group reselling to the stores of its network appears to fall within paragraph I, without the 1.10 coefficient (consumer sales only) and without the 0.9 coefficient if the stores are not independent. The position of a store that does not itself buy under the Article L. 441-7 contract is not expressly settled.

The manufacturer, often based abroad, is not the offender when it sells its own production. But its invoices, rebates and any payments to the distributor are the inputs of the calculation. Article L. 441-7 also provides that no cost linked to promotions on a private-label product can be charged to the manufacturer, on pain of an administrative fine of up to €75,000 for an individual and €375,000 for a company. Investigators may ask for the contract documents on both sides.

The seven exceptions in Article L. 442-5

Paragraph II lists seven situations in which the ban does not apply: closing down or change of activity; seasonal products at the end of the season; products outdated by fashion or technical progress; identical products restocked at a lower price, where the new invoice price replaces the old one; price alignment by shops under 300 m² (food) or 1,000 m² (non-food) on the price lawfully charged by another trader in the same trading area; perishable products threatened with rapid deterioration, provided the reduced price is not advertised outside the point of sale; and goods sold during the official sales periods under Article L. 310-3. The list is closed and each exception is read strictly.

Two points cause frequent mistakes. Sales periods are set by ministerial order, and the goods must have been offered for sale and paid for at least one month before the period starts; Black Friday and private sales are not official sales. A perishable product promoted through an app, a website or a leaflet loses the exception. The exceptions appear to apply in the same way to food covered by the uplift, which only adjusts the effective purchase price.

Each exception rests on evidence you must be able to produce at the time of the inspection: markdown records, restocking invoices, competitors' price surveys, dates of entry into stock. An exception raised afterwards, without contemporaneous documents, rarely convinces.

No. Situation Conditions in the text What to document
1° Closing down or change of activity Voluntary or forced sales motivated by the closure or change of a commercial activity The closure or change itself and its date
2° Seasonal products Marked seasonal character; end of the selling season and period between two seasons The end date of the season; overstock alone is not enough
3° Outdated products No longer meeting general demand because of fashion or technical improvements Why demand has gone; a range change for margin reasons is not covered
4° Restocking at a lower price Identical products; the new invoice price replaces the effective purchase price The new invoice, dated before the sale, for the same product
5° Price alignment Food: shop under 300 m²; non-food: under 1,000 m²; alignment on the price lawfully charged for the same products by another trader in the same trading area The competitor's price, its lawfulness and the shared trading area
6° Perishable products Threatened with rapid deterioration; no advertising or announcement outside the point of sale Dates and the absence of any outside communication (app, website, leaflet)
7° Sales (soldes) Sales goods under Article L. 310-3: official period set by ministerial order; products offered for sale and paid for at least one month before it starts Dates of the period and date of entry into stock; Black Friday is not a sales period
Limit Insolvency The exceptions do not prevent the application of Articles L. 653-5, 2° and L. 654-2, 1° Situation of a business in difficulty to be reviewed separately

Penalties since the law of 14 April 2025

A fine based on turnover in France

Until 14 April 2025, the fine was €75,000. It can now reach 0.4% of the annual turnover in France, excluding VAT, for the last closed financial year: the turnover of the business prosecuted, not the margin on the products or the sales of one store. For a fictitious retailer with €600 million of turnover in France, the ceiling rises from €75,000 to €2.4 million. For a foreign group, only the turnover achieved in France by the trader prosecuted counts. Where a low price is advertised, the fine can instead reach half of the advertising spend, and the court can order the advertising to stop. The court may also order display or publication of the decision (Article L. 490-2 of the Commercial Code), a penalty companies face under Article 131-39, 9° of the Criminal Code. For a retail brand, publication often costs more than the fine.

Companies and repeat offences

For a company, Article 131-38 of the Criminal Code sets the maximum fine at five times the rate for individuals. How that multiplier applies to a ceiling expressed as a percentage of turnover is not settled by any text, and the point deserves to be argued. If the offence is committed again within two years of a conviction, the maximum is doubled (Article L. 490-3) and, for a company, the maximum rate is ten times the rate for individuals (Article L. 490-4), which gives 4% of turnover on an arithmetic reading.

Facts committed before 15 April 2025

If your turnover in France is below €18.75 million, 0.4% of it is below €75,000: the new ceiling is lower for you, and under Article 112-1 of the Criminal Code a more lenient law applies to earlier offences not yet finally judged. For a larger business, the new law is harsher and applies only to facts from 15 April 2025. In a file covering campaigns on both sides of that date, the dating of each announcement and sale decides the amount at stake. Prosecution is time-barred six years after the facts (Article 8 of the Code of Criminal Procedure).

Competitors and trade bodies

Competitors may claim compensation for the harm caused by prices below the threshold, and trade organisations can go to the civil or commercial courts to defend the collective interest of their sector or fair competition (Article L. 490-10). This risk does not depend on the authorities.

DGCCRF investigation and what follows

Who investigates and how

Investigations are carried out by officials authorised by the minister for the economy (Article L. 450-1, II), in practice DGCCRF and DDPP agents. They can enter professional premises between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m., or outside those hours when the premises are open to the public or activity is under way, demand and copy invoices and business documents, collect information on site or by summons, and access software and data (Article L. 450-3). An inspection often starts from a price survey, a catalogue or a competitor's complaint; the agents then rebuild the effective purchase price from your invoices and supplier agreements.

The inspection report

The report (procès-verbal) is sent to the competent authority, with a copy to the persons concerned, and stands as evidence until proven otherwise (Article L. 450-2). It is for you to bring contrary evidence, line by line. You may also be summoned to an interview: see why a DGCCRF summons is not a formality.

Injunction, settlement or prosecution

After an adversarial procedure, the agents can order the business to comply or stop the practice within a reasonable time, and the injunction can be published at its expense (Article L. 470-1, I; see our guide to DGCCRF injunctions). The authority can also propose a settlement (transaction) for offences that carry no prison sentence, which is the case here, as long as prosecution has not started and with the public prosecutor's agreement; once you have performed it, prosecution is barred (Article L. 490-5). Otherwise, the report goes to the prosecutor, who may drop the case, choose an alternative or bring the business before the criminal court (tribunal correctionnel).

Situation Legal basis Nature Maximum Procedure
Resale or advertised resale below the effective purchase price (facts from 15 April 2025) Commercial Code, L. 442-5, I and IV Criminal offence 0.4% of annual turnover in France excluding VAT; half of the advertising spend where advertised Report (L. 450-2); settlement possible before prosecution (L. 490-5); criminal court
Same offence, facts up to 14 April 2025 L. 442-5 in its previous version; Criminal Code, 112-1 Criminal offence €75,000, unless the new ceiling is lower for the business concerned Same; prosecution time-barred after six years (Code of Criminal Procedure, 8)
Company Criminal Code, 131-38 and 131-39, 9°; Commercial Code, L. 442-5, III Fine and additional penalty Five times the rate for individuals (application to a percentage not settled); display or publication of the decision Criminal court
Repeat offence within two years of a conviction Commercial Code, L. 490-3 and L. 490-4 Aggravation Maximum doubled; company: ten times the rate for individuals Criminal court
Injunction to stop the practice Commercial Code, L. 470-1, I Administrative measure No fine of its own; publication possible at the business's expense DGCCRF or DDPP agents, after an adversarial procedure
Annual report on the 10% uplift not sent or request not answered Law No. 2020-1525, art. 125, IV bis Administrative fine 0.4% of annual turnover in France excluding VAT; doubled for a repeat breach within two years Commercial Code, L. 470-2
For comparison: promotion caps exceeded Law No. 2020-1525, art. 125, II, E Administrative fine €75,000 (individual); €375,000 or half of the advertising spend (company); doubled for a repeat breach within two years Commercial Code, L. 470-2
For comparison: breach of the private-label contract rules (e.g. promotional costs charged to the manufacturer) Commercial Code, L. 441-7, IV and VI Administrative fine €75,000 (individual); €375,000 (company); €150,000 and €750,000 for a repeat breach within two years Administrative procedure

Preparing your response after an inspection

The first answer is often written too quickly, disputing the principle without redoing the calculation. Yet the file is won or lost on the effective purchase price. An independent reconstruction, product by product and period by period, shows the real gap, the lines where the complaint does not hold and those where an exception can be argued, and checks that the right text was applied at the right date. Which grounds to raise, and whether to accept or negotiate a settlement, should be decided with counsel before anything is sent.

Frequently asked questions

Is selling below cost illegal in France?

Yes, for resale. Article L. 442-5 of the Commercial Code prohibits any trader from reselling, or advertising the resale of, a product in the state in which it was bought below its effective purchase price, subject to seven exceptions.

What is the penalty for resale at a loss in France?

A criminal fine of up to 0.4% of annual turnover in France, excluding VAT, or half of the advertising spend where the price was advertised. The maximum is doubled for a repeat offence within two years, and for a company the rate can reach ten times that for individuals (Articles L. 490-3 and L. 490-4).

How do I calculate the resale-at-a-loss threshold?

Start from the unit net invoice price, deduct the other financial benefits granted by the seller, then add VAT, specific taxes and transport. For food and pet food resold to consumers, multiply by 1.10 until 15 April 2028; drinks subject to excise duties follow a different formula. A wholesaler selling only to independent professionals applies 0.9.

What is SRP+10 and how long does it apply?

The 10% uplift of the threshold for food and pet food sold to consumers, under Article 125 of Law No. 2020-1525. It has applied since 2019 and runs until 15 April 2028.

Can I sell below cost during the sales or on Black Friday?

During the official sales, yes, for goods offered for sale and paid for at least one month before the period (Article L. 310-3). Black Friday is not an official sales period: a sale below the threshold is lawful only if another exception applies.

Does the ban apply to private-label products?

Yes, since 15 April 2025, for private-label food acquired under a contract governed by Article L. 441-7. When resold to consumers, the 1.10 coefficient also applies.

We are a foreign supplier or online seller. Are we exposed?

A manufacturer selling its own production to a French retailer is not the offender, but its invoices, rebates and contracts are what investigators use. An online seller is a trader like any other: prices on product pages and in campaigns follow the same rules as in a shop. If you resell to customers in France, have your French pricing reviewed.

What should we do after a DGCCRF inspection on pricing?

Gather what the investigators noted and requested, rebuild the effective purchase price of each product, and have your first explanations reviewed by a lawyer before sending them. At Victoris, the file is explained to you in English and the exchanges with the authority are handled in French.

Key actions

  • Before a price operation: calculate the threshold product by product, apply 1.10 to food sold to consumers, and document any exception.
  • Private-label food: treat it like a national brand, and check the Article L. 441-7 contract on promotional costs.
  • Automated pricing: set a floor at the threshold in every tool that aligns your prices on competitors.
  • Inspection or report received: rebuild the calculation, date each sale and announcement, and decide on the strategy with counsel.
  • Distributors of consumer goods: send the annual report on the uplift before 1 September.

Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.