Unfair contract terms in France: banned consumer clauses

French unfair contract terms: the 12 banned and 10 presumed unfair consumer clauses, fines of up to €75,000 and how to fix your terms.

Which clauses are banned in consumer contracts in France?

French law treats as unfair any clause in a consumer contract that creates a significant imbalance between the parties' rights and obligations to the consumer's detriment. Such a clause is deemed unwritten, and the contract applies without it. Twelve types of clause are banned in all cases (the black list), ten more are presumed unfair unless the business proves otherwise (the grey list), and a black-listed clause can cost a company an administrative fine of up to €75,000.

Updated: November 2026. Key provisions: Articles L. 212-1, L. 212-2, L. 241-1, L. 241-1-1, L. 241-2 and R. 212-1 to R. 212-5 of the French Consumer Code.

This guide is for any business that contracts with consumers in France, whether it is French or based abroad: online shops, subscription services, installers, training providers, retailers. Terms written years ago, or adapted from business-to-business models or from another country's law, often contain wording that French law prohibits, such as "delivery dates are indicative only", "our liability is limited to the order value" or "a €29 cancellation fee applies". The rules are enforced by the courts, by consumer associations and by the DGCCRF (the French authority for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control) and its local offices, the DDPP (departmental directorates for the protection of populations). A lawyer for DGCCRF and DDPP inspections can review your terms before an inspector or a customer does.

Would you like to discuss your situation? Book a consultation:

CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION

What makes a clause unfair under French consumer law

The significant imbalance test

Under Article L. 212-1 of the Consumer Code, a clause in a contract between a business and a consumer is unfair if its object or its effect is to create a significant imbalance between the parties' rights and obligations, to the consumer's detriment. "Object or effect" matters: a clause you have never enforced can still be unfair. The assessment is made as at the date the contract was concluded, by reference to all the circumstances of its conclusion and to all the other clauses of the contract, and of any contract legally linked to it. A harsh clause may be balanced by another one; an ordinary clause may become unfair because of what the rest of the terms say.

What is not reviewed: the main subject matter and the price

The test does not apply to the definition of the main subject matter of the contract, or to whether the price is adequate for the goods or services, provided those clauses are drafted in clear and comprehensible language (Article L. 212-1, third paragraph). A customer cannot argue that your price is unfair because it is high. An obscure price clause, however, falls back within the test. More generally, every clause offered to consumers must be presented and drafted clearly and comprehensibly, and any doubt is resolved in the consumer's favour (Article L. 211-1).

Who is protected

A consumer is any natural person acting for purposes outside their commercial, industrial, craft, liberal or agricultural activity. A non-professional is any legal person that does not act for professional purposes (preliminary article of the Consumer Code). The test and both lists also apply to contracts with non-professionals (Articles L. 212-2 and R. 212-5). A parents' association ordering equipment can therefore rely on the same rules as an individual; a tradesman buying a tool for the workshop cannot.

Every contractual document counts

The rules apply whatever the form or medium of the contract, including purchase orders, invoices, guarantee certificates, delivery notes and tickets, and whether or not the clauses were negotiated (Article L. 212-1, last paragraph). Website terms, order summaries, subscription forms, signed quotes and confirmation emails are all covered.

Your company is based outside France

Choosing another country's law in your terms does not remove this protection. Whatever the contract says, a consumer cannot be deprived of the protection given by the rules an EU Member State has adopted under the Unfair Terms Directive (Directive 93/13/EEC) where the contract has a close connection with the territory of a Member State (Article L. 232-1). That connection is presumed in several cases, including where you direct your activity to the Member State where the consumer lives and the contract falls within that activity (Article L. 231-1). A foreign business selling to consumers in France should therefore read its terms against the French lists. For the other obligations, see our guide to selling to French consumers from abroad.

The black list: twelve clauses banned outright

Article R. 212-1 lists twelve clauses that are irrebuttably presumed unfair and therefore prohibited. No evidence to the contrary is allowed, and the text covers any clause with the object or effect described, so a reworded version is caught too. The twelve fall into four groups:

  • Content of the contract (1° to 4°): binding the consumer to clauses that are not in the document they accept and were not brought to their attention before signing; limiting your duty to honour commitments made by your staff or agents; reserving the right to change the duration, characteristics or price on your own; giving yourself alone the right to decide whether goods or services conform, or to interpret the contract.
  • Performance and liability (5° to 7°): requiring the consumer to pay while you fail to deliver, guarantee or provide the service; removing or reducing the consumer's right to compensation for a breach of any of your obligations; preventing the consumer from terminating or rescinding the contract when you do not perform.
  • Termination (8° to 11°): a discretionary right to terminate for you but not for the consumer; keeping sums paid for services not provided when you terminate at your discretion; in open-ended contracts, a longer notice period for the consumer than for you, or a fee for the consumer to terminate.
  • Evidence (12°): placing on the consumer a burden of proof that the applicable law would normally place on you.

Item 6° is often found in terms adapted from business-to-business models. "Our liability is limited to the order value" and "we accept no liability for late delivery" both reduce the consumer's right to compensation. The text covers reduction as well as exclusion, so a cap is caught even if it is high. Item 11° catches any fee for leaving an open-ended subscription, whatever it is called: closing fee, administration fee or fixed indemnity.

The grey list: ten clauses presumed unfair

Article R. 212-2 lists ten clauses that are presumed unfair unless the business proves otherwise. In a dispute over a contract containing one of them, the business must prove that the clause is not unfair (Article L. 212-1, fifth paragraph). The ten clauses are:

  • a firm commitment from the consumer while your own performance depends on a condition within your sole control (1°);
  • keeping sums paid by a consumer who withdraws, without giving the consumer an equivalent amount if you withdraw, or twice that amount where the payment was made as arrhes within the meaning of Article L. 214-1 (2°);
  • a manifestly disproportionate indemnity payable by a consumer who fails to perform (3°);
  • a right for you to terminate without reasonable notice (4°);
  • a right to assign the contract without the consumer's consent where this may reduce the consumer's rights (5°);
  • a right to change on your own the other clauses on the parties' rights and obligations, duration, characteristics and price being black-listed (6°);
  • an indicative performance date, except where the law allows it (7°);
  • stricter conditions or formalities for the consumer than for you to terminate or rescind (8°);
  • unduly restricting the evidence the consumer may use (9°);
  • removing or hindering the consumer's access to the courts, in particular by requiring exclusive use of an arbitration not covered by legal provisions or of an alternative dispute resolution process (10°).

"Delivery times are indicative only" is the classic grey-list clause (7°), often paired with an exclusion of liability for delay, which is black-listed (6°). Telling consumers that they may use consumer mediation is an obligation when a written contract is concluded (Article L. 211-3); making mediation the only route and closing access to the court falls under 10°.

Rebutting the presumption, and the permitted exceptions

To keep a grey-list clause, you must show that, read with the rest of the contract and the circumstances at signature, it does not create a significant imbalance: a counterpart in another clause, a notice period that is genuinely reasonable, an economic justification for an indemnity, clear information at the time of the order. That case is built when the terms are drafted, not once a dispute starts. Whether to delete, rewrite or keep a grey-list clause with a counterpart depends on your business model and margins, and is worth settling with counsel.

Article R. 212-4 relaxes some prohibitions. In an open-ended contract, you may provide for price changes if the consumer is told within a reasonable time, so that they can terminate. Changes linked to technical developments are also allowed if they bring no price increase or loss of quality and the characteristics the consumer relied on could be stated in the contract. Articles R. 212-3 and R. 212-4 add rules for financial services and for products whose price depends on a rate or index the business does not control. A clause outside these conditions falls back into the lists.

The table below sets out the 22 clauses, each with a fictional example of wording to avoid.

List and item What the clause does Wording to avoid (fictional example)
Black list, R. 212-1, 1° Binds the consumer to clauses not in the document accepted and not made known before signing "The customer confirms having read the special conditions, available on request in store."
Black list, R. 212-1, 2° Limits the duty to honour commitments made by staff or agents "Information given orally by our advisers does not bind the company."
Black list, R. 212-1, 3° Lets the business change the duration, characteristics or price on its own (exceptions in R. 212-4) "The price shown at the time of order may be adjusted until dispatch."
Black list, R. 212-1, 4° Lets the business alone decide whether goods or services conform, or interpret the contract "Conformity is assessed by our quality department, whose decision is final."
Black list, R. 212-1, 5° Requires the consumer to perform while the business does not deliver, guarantee or provide the service "The balance is payable on the due date even if installation has not taken place."
Black list, R. 212-1, 6° Removes or reduces the right to compensation for a breach of any obligation "Our liability is limited to the order value."
Black list, R. 212-1, 7° Prevents the consumer from terminating or rescinding when the business does not perform "No cancellation is possible, including in the event of late delivery."
Black list, R. 212-1, 8° Gives the business, but not the consumer, a discretionary right to terminate "We may end the service at any time without reason; the customer is committed for twelve months."
Black list, R. 212-1, 9° Keeps sums paid for services not provided when the business terminates at its discretion "If we discontinue the programme, sums paid are not refunded."
Black list, R. 212-1, 10° Imposes a longer notice period on the consumer than on the business (open-ended contracts) "Three months' notice for the customer, one month for the company."
Black list, R. 212-1, 11° Makes termination by the consumer subject to a payment to the business (open-ended contracts) "Any cancellation incurs a €29 administration fee."
Black list, R. 212-1, 12° Places on the consumer a burden of proof that should normally fall on the business "The customer must prove that the defect existed on delivery."
Grey list, R. 212-2, 1° Firm commitment for the consumer, performance by the business subject to a condition in its sole control "The order is firm on payment; delivery depends on our decision to keep the model in our range."
Grey list, R. 212-2, 2° Keeps sums paid by a consumer who withdraws, with no equivalent payment (or double, for arrhes) if the business withdraws "The 30% deposit is kept if the customer cancels."
Grey list, R. 212-2, 3° Imposes a manifestly disproportionate indemnity on a consumer who fails to perform "Any late payment incurs a penalty of 50% of the instalment."
Grey list, R. 212-2, 4° Allows the business to terminate without reasonable notice "The company may terminate the contract by email with immediate effect."
Grey list, R. 212-2, 5° Allows assignment of the contract without consent where the consumer's rights may be reduced "The company may transfer this contract to any third party of its choice."
Grey list, R. 212-2, 6° Allows the business to change on its own the other clauses on rights and obligations "We may amend these terms at any time; they apply to existing contracts once published."
Grey list, R. 212-2, 7° Sets an indicative performance date, except where the law allows it "Delivery times are given for guidance only."
Grey list, R. 212-2, 8° Imposes stricter conditions on the consumer than on the business to terminate or rescind "The customer cancels by registered letter; the company cancels by email."
Grey list, R. 212-2, 9° Unduly restricts the evidence available to the consumer "Only our computer records are admissible as evidence."
Grey list, R. 212-2, 10° Removes or hinders access to the courts, for example exclusive arbitration or exclusive alternative dispute resolution "Any dispute will be settled exclusively by arbitration."

Subscriptions, services and online sales: the clauses that come up

Subscriptions

Open-ended subscriptions are directly targeted by three black-list items: discretionary termination reserved to the business (8°), a longer notice period for the consumer (10°) and a termination fee (11°). A price increase during the contract falls under 3° unless the R. 212-4 exception is met. Fictional example: a monthly baby-products box at €24.90 allows price rises "at any time", charges €15 to cancel, and accepts cancellation by registered letter only, while the company may cancel by email. The first clause is caught by black-list item 3°, the second by black-list item 11° and the third by grey-list item 8°.

Services

In building work, courses, maintenance or home services, the sensitive clauses concern deposits and non-performance. Fictional example: a bathroom renovation firm takes 40% on order; its terms say the deposit is kept if the customer cancels, that work starts "within an indicative six to eight weeks" and that the firm "cannot be held liable for delays". The first two clauses are grey-listed (2° and 7°), the third is black-listed (6°). An inspector or a consumer association would find three clauses in one document, before any dispute with a customer.

Online sales

Website terms often reuse wording from foreign templates or from business-to-business contracts: liability caps, indicative delivery times, changes to the terms "at any time", evidence limited to the seller's own system logs. "Photos are not contractual" appears in neither list. If it is used to refuse any complaint about a product that does not match its description, however, it amounts to letting the seller alone decide whether the product conforms (4°) and to excluding the seller's liability (6°).

Clauses outside the lists

The two lists are not exhaustive. A clause that appears in neither can still be held unfair under the general test of Article L. 212-1, and whoever relies on it must then show the imbalance. Fictional example: an online pram seller requires "any complaint within 48 hours of delivery, failing which no claim will be accepted". The clause matches no item word for word, but it restricts the customer's rights so severely that it may be held unfair, and it may conflict with the statutory guarantees owed by the seller. A clause that is acceptable in substance can also fail on form, for example tiny print or a reference to a document the customer cannot find, given the clarity requirement of Article L. 211-1.

What happens if your terms contain an unfair clause

The clause is deemed unwritten

Unfair clauses are deemed unwritten (réputées non écrites). The contract remains applicable in all its other provisions if it can survive without them, and this rule is a matter of public policy (Article L. 241-1). You cannot rely on the clause to refuse a refund, keep a deposit or cap compensation; the general law applies instead. A clause repeated in thousands of identical contracts multiplies the risk by the number of customers.

The judge raises it on their own motion

The judge must set aside, of their own motion and after hearing the parties, any clause whose unfairness emerges from the case (Article R. 632-1). When you sue a consumer for payment, the court can strike out the penalty or cancellation fee in your terms even if the customer does not challenge it. Before starting recovery proceedings against consumers, check the clauses on which the claim rests.

Consumer associations and the DGCCRF in court

The consumer associations referred to in Article L. 621-1 can sue in the civil courts to stop or prohibit any unlawful conduct harming the collective interest of consumers (Article L. 621-7). The judge can then order, under a daily penalty where appropriate, the removal of an unlawful or unfair clause from any contract or model contract offered to consumers, including contracts in progress. At the association's request, the judge can also declare the clause deemed unwritten in all identical contracts concluded by the same business with consumers, and order the business to inform those consumers at its own expense (Article L. 621-8). After an inspection, the DGCCRF can ask the civil or administrative court for the same three measures against an unlawful, prohibited or unfair clause (Article L. 524-1). This route covers grey-list clauses and clauses outside the lists, which the administrative fine does not.

The civil fine for re-using a clause already held unfair

A business that continues to use, in identical contracts, clauses already held unfair by a court decision that has become final against it may be ordered to pay a civil fine of up to €15,000 for an individual and €75,000 for a company (Article L. 241-1-1, in its version in force since 3 May 2025). In large-scale infringements handled through EU cooperation between consumer authorities, the fine can rise to 4% of average annual turnover, or €2 million where turnover cannot be established. The authority, consumer associations, the public prosecutor or the consumer can ask for it, and the court may order publication at the business's expense. The text excludes clauses held unfair under the fourth paragraph of Article L. 212-1, that is, black-listed clauses, which carry the administrative fine described below.

DGCCRF inspections: administrative fine and injunction

The administrative fine for black-listed clauses

The mere presence of one or more black-listed clauses in a consumer contract is punishable by an administrative fine of up to €15,000 for an individual and €75,000 for a company (Article L. 241-2). The text does not require the clause to have been applied or a customer to have complained. In large-scale infringements handled through EU mutual assistance, the ceiling can rise to 4% of average annual turnover, or €2 million where turnover information is not available. The fine is imposed under the administrative sanction procedure of the Consumer Code, which starts with a written notice of the intended fine and a period for your observations.

The injunction to remove the clause

Inspectors can, after an adversarial procedure, order a business to remove any unlawful or prohibited clause within a reasonable time that they set (Article L. 521-1). The injunction can carry a daily penalty of up to €3,000, with a total cap of €300,000. Where the breach carries a fine of at least €75,000, the penalty can instead be set by reference to worldwide turnover, up to 0.1% per day and 5% in total. Inspectors often read the terms when they check a website or a shop, and one inspection can target several clauses at once. That is the point to bring in counsel, before you answer the authority.

Sanction Clauses concerned Who acts Amount or effect Legal basis (Consumer Code)
Clause deemed unwritten Any unfair clause: black list, grey list not rebutted, general test The court, including on its own motion The clause is disregarded; the contract survives if it can L. 241-1; R. 632-1
Removal and effect on identical contracts Unlawful or unfair clause Consumer association, before the civil court Removal, under a daily penalty where appropriate; clause deemed unwritten in all identical contracts; customers informed at the business's expense L. 621-7; L. 621-8
Removal and effect on identical contracts Unlawful, prohibited or unfair clause DGCCRF, before the civil or administrative court, after an inspection The same three measures L. 524-1
Civil fine Clause already held unfair by a final decision and still used in identical contracts (black-listed clauses excluded) The court, at the request of the authority, an association, the public prosecutor or the consumer Up to €15,000 (individual) or €75,000 (company); up to 4% of turnover or €2 million in large-scale cases L. 241-1-1
Administrative fine Black-listed clause (R. 212-1) The consumer authority (DGCCRF, DDPP) Up to €15,000 (individual) or €75,000 (company); up to 4% of turnover or €2 million in large-scale cases L. 241-2
Injunction Unlawful or prohibited clause DGCCRF or DDPP inspectors, after an adversarial procedure Removal within a set time; daily penalty up to €3,000, total €300,000, or by reference to worldwide turnover L. 521-1

The Commission on Unfair Terms

The Commission on Unfair Terms (Commission des clauses abusives) is attached to the minister responsible for consumer affairs and includes judges, consumer representatives and business representatives. It examines the model contracts that businesses usually offer and recommends deleting or amending clauses that create a significant imbalance. A judge can ask for its opinion on a clause during proceedings, and that opinion does not bind the court. The Commission does not settle individual disputes, and a consumer cannot bring a dispute before it. Its opinion is also required before the decrees that set the black and grey lists are adopted (Article L. 212-1). A clause is not banned merely because a recommendation mentions it, but judges, inspectors and associations use the recommendations as sector benchmarks. Check whether one covers your sector, for example telecoms, removals, letting or services, and compare your terms with it.

How to review your consumer terms

  1. List every document the customer actually receives or accepts: terms and conditions, subscription terms, quotes, order forms, confirmation emails and any help pages the terms refer to.
  2. Check each clause against the twelve black-list items, then against the ten grey-list items.
  3. Check that the wording is clear and that the documents are consistent: a compliant clause in the terms can be contradicted by a product page.
  4. Decide what to do about contracts already signed and sums already collected.

The last step is the delicate one. Correcting, informing subscribers, refunding or waiting depends on the number of contracts and on the risk of an inspection, and calls for advice fitted to your model rather than a generic fix.

Frequently asked questions

What clauses are prohibited in French consumer contracts?

The black list in Article R. 212-1 of the Consumer Code bans twelve clauses outright, including limits on the business's liability, unilateral changes to price, duration or characteristics, fees for terminating an open-ended contract, discretionary termination reserved to the business and shifting the burden of proof onto the consumer. No evidence to the contrary is allowed.

What is the difference between the black list and the grey list?

Black-list clauses (Article R. 212-1) are unfair in all cases. Grey-list clauses (Article R. 212-2) are presumed unfair, but the business can prove that they create no significant imbalance. Only black-list clauses trigger the administrative fine of Article L. 241-2.

Does an unfair term make the whole contract void?

No. The clause is deemed unwritten and the rest of the contract continues to apply if it can survive without it (Article L. 241-1).

What is the fine for an unfair term in French consumer contracts?

Up to €15,000 for an individual and €75,000 for a company for a black-listed clause (Article L. 241-2), plus a possible injunction to remove it under a daily penalty (Article L. 521-1). Continuing to use a clause already held unfair by a final decision, other than a black-listed one, can lead to a civil fine of the same amounts (Article L. 241-1-1).

Is a limitation of liability clause valid against a French consumer?

Not if it removes or reduces the consumer's right to compensation for a breach of any of the business's obligations: that is black-list item 6°. Wording such as "liability limited to the order value" or "no liability for delay" should not appear in terms used with consumers.

Do these rules apply if our terms are governed by foreign law?

The choice of law cannot deprive the consumer of the protection of the unfair terms rules adopted by an EU Member State under Directive 93/13/EEC where the contract has a close connection with the territory of a Member State. That connection is presumed in particular when you direct your activity to the country where the consumer lives (Articles L. 232-1 and L. 231-1).

Can a judge strike out a clause the customer has not challenged?

Yes. The judge must set aside of their own motion, after hearing the parties, a clause whose unfairness emerges from the case (Article R. 632-1).

Key actions

  • Before selling to consumers in France: check your terms against the 22 items in the table, starting with liability caps and termination fees.
  • Subscriptions: align notice periods and cancellation formalities for both sides, and frame any price change within Article R. 212-4.
  • Inspection or injunction received: have the clauses and the contracts already signed reviewed before you answer the authority.
  • Court decision against one of your clauses: correct every identical contract at once.

Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.