Abuse of weakness and aggressive selling in France: risks

Abuse of weakness and aggressive selling in France: doorstep and phone sales, prison, turnover-based fines, void contracts, liability for sales agents.

What does a company risk for abuse of weakness or aggressive selling in France?

Two offences of the French Consumer Code apply when sales pressure meets a consumer who cannot resist it. An aggressive commercial practice is punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine; abuse of weakness by three years and €375,000, rising to five years and €500,000 after telephone canvassing. Fines can reach 10% of average annual turnover and are multiplied by five for companies, contracts obtained this way are void, and a company can answer for offences committed by its sales staff and, in some cases, by its intermediaries.

Updated: November 2026. Key provisions: Articles L. 121-6 to L. 121-10, L. 132-10 to L. 132-15, L. 221-10 and L. 223-1 of the French Consumer Code; Articles 121-2, 121-7, 131-38, 131-39 and 223-15-2 of the French Criminal Code.

This article is for groups that sell to French consumers through doorstep selling (démarchage à domicile), telephone canvassing, fairs and exhibitions, or networks of sales agents and business introducers. These offences are investigated by the DGCCRF (the French authority for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control) and the DDPP (departmental directorates for the protection of populations), whose reports go to the public prosecutor (procureur de la République). The offence is usually committed in the field, by a salesperson, a subcontracted call centre or a business introducer, but liability can travel up to the company and its managers. A lawyer for DGCCRF and DDPP inspections can assess your exposure, from the first request for documents to the criminal court.

Would you like to discuss your situation? Book a consultation:

CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION

Abuse of weakness under the Consumer Code

Three situations covered by the law

Article L. 121-8 of the French Consumer Code prohibits abusing a person's weakness or ignorance to make them enter into commitments, for cash or on credit, through home visits, where the circumstances show that the person could not assess the scope of the commitments or detect the tricks used to persuade them, or was subjected to pressure.

Article L. 121-9 extends the prohibition to commitments obtained:

  • after canvassing by telephone or fax (1°);
  • after a personalised invitation, made at home and combined with special benefits, to come to a sales venue (2°);
  • at meetings or excursions organised by the offender or for its benefit (3°);
  • in places not intended for selling the goods or services concerned, or at fairs and exhibitions (4°);
  • in an emergency that made it impossible for the victim to consult one or more qualified professionals not party to the contract (5°).

Article L. 121-10 covers obtaining cash, transfers, cheques, card payments or securities without any real consideration in return, by abusing a person's weakness or ignorance. No contract is needed: a deposit collected for work never carried out can be enough.

What must be shown

The text requires a state of weakness or ignorance and a commitment or payment obtained by abusing it. Courts generally require that the weakness exist before the sales approach, rather than being created by the sales technique itself, and that the trader knew of it and meant to take advantage of it. That knowledge is often inferred from facts: the person's apparent condition, repeated orders, disproportionate amounts, prospect lists targeting elderly customers. The text does not require proof of a financial loss.

Who counts as vulnerable

The Code gives no list, and courts assess each case. Advanced age, isolation, illness, cognitive impairment, disability, recent bereavement or a poor command of French may count, but age alone is not proof: what matters is the person's actual ability to understand what they sign and to resist pressure. Ignorance is a separate notion. It covers a person who, without being frail, cannot check what they are told, such as a customer who does not know the usual price of a lock replacement, or a homeowner told about a regulatory obligation that does not exist.

Aggressive commercial practices

The general definition

Under Article L. 121-6, a practice is aggressive when, through repeated and insistent solicitation or physical or moral coercion, and taking account of the circumstances, it significantly impairs or is likely to significantly impair a consumer's freedom of choice, vitiates or is likely to vitiate their consent, or hinders the exercise of their contractual rights. The factors taken into account include the timing, place, nature and persistence of the practice, threats, significant or disproportionate obstacles to ending the contract, and the trader's knowing exploitation of any misfortune or circumstance serious enough to impair the consumer's judgement. The text derives from Directive 2005/29/EC on unfair commercial practices (Article 8). For the wider framework, including misleading practices, see our guide to unfair commercial practices in France.

Practices deemed aggressive in all cases

Article L. 121-7 lists seven practices deemed aggressive, with no need to show their effect. Three concern doorstep and distance selling directly:

  • giving the consumer the impression that they cannot leave the premises until a contract has been concluded (1°);
  • making personal visits to the consumer's home while ignoring their request to leave or not to come back (2°);
  • making repeated and unwanted solicitations by telephone, fax, email or any other distance tool (3°).

The others concern obstruction of insurance claims, advertising that directly urges children to buy, telling the consumer that the trader's job or livelihood is at risk if they do not buy, and false prize claims.

Where the line falls between the offences

The method on one side, exploited vulnerability on the other

An aggressive practice can target any consumer, including an informed buyer: what is punished is insistence, coercion or undue influence. Abuse of weakness requires an identified victim who was vulnerable before the approach, and a trader who knowingly exploited that vulnerability. The same scene can fall under both: a salesperson who refuses to leave the home of a confused elderly person until they sign commits a practice deemed aggressive (Article L. 121-7, 1° and 2°) and, if the conditions are met, an abuse of weakness.

Abuse of weakness under the Criminal Code

Article 223-15-2 of the French Criminal Code punishes the fraudulent abuse of the ignorance or weakness of a minor, or of a person whose particular vulnerability, due to age, illness, infirmity, physical or mental disability or pregnancy, is apparent or known to the offender, to lead them to an act or omission seriously prejudicial to them. The base penalties are three years and €375,000, rising to five years and €750,000 when the offence is committed online or through a digital medium, and to seven years and €1 million for an organised gang.

The two offences do not overlap: the Criminal Code requires a particular vulnerability and a seriously prejudicial act, but no specific sales method; the Consumer Code requires no serious harm, but one of the situations of Articles L. 121-8 to L. 121-10. The prosecutor chooses the qualification that fits the file, which determines what must be proved, the penalties and access to a settlement.

Criterion Aggressive commercial practice Abuse of weakness (Consumer Code) Fraudulent abuse of weakness (Criminal Code)
Legal basis L. 121-6 and L. 121-7; penalties L. 132-10 to L. 132-12 L. 121-8 to L. 121-10; penalties L. 132-13 to L. 132-15 Article 223-15-2
Who is protected Any consumer A person in a state of weakness or ignorance A minor, or a person whose particular vulnerability is apparent or known to the offender
Conduct Repeated and insistent solicitation or coercion, or a practice on the list of L. 121-7 Commitment obtained in a situation listed by law, or payment obtained without real consideration Inducing the person to a seriously prejudicial act or omission, whatever the sales method
Base penalty (individual) 2 years and €300,000, or up to 10% of average annual turnover 3 years and €375,000, or up to 10% of average annual turnover 3 years and €375,000
Aggravated penalty 3 years if contracts were concluded; 7 years for an organised gang 5 years and €500,000 after telephone canvassing 5 years and €750,000 online; 7 years and €1 million for an organised gang
Effect on the contract Void (L. 132-10) Void (L. 132-13) No specific rule in the article

Doorstep selling, fairs and telephone canvassing

Off-premises contracts: no payment for seven days

For an off-premises contract (contrat hors établissement), Article L. 221-10 prohibits the trader from receiving any payment or consideration, in any form, from the consumer before seven days have passed from the conclusion of the contract. Demanding or obtaining such a payment is punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €150,000 fine (Article L. 242-7), and the rule is laid down on pain of nullity of the contract (Article L. 242-1). The exceptions include urgent maintenance or repair work at the consumer's home expressly requested by them, limited to the spare parts and work strictly necessary to deal with the emergency (Article L. 221-10, 4°). Irregular doorstep selling is often how investigators reach an abuse of weakness case.

Fairs and exhibitions

Fairs and exhibitions are expressly listed in Article L. 121-9, 4°. Before a contract is concluded at a fair, an exhibition or a similar commercial event, the trader must tell the consumer that there is no withdrawal period (Article L. 224-59). An elderly visitor who signs at a stand, with no way back, matches the profile the law protects. Meetings, demonstrations and promotional trips organised by the seller fall under Article L. 121-9, 3°.

Telephone canvassing

Telephone canvassing is the first situation listed in Article L. 121-9. Since 2 July 2025, abuse of weakness committed in that situation is punishable by five years' imprisonment and a €500,000 fine, which can be raised to 10% of average annual turnover (Article L. 132-14-1). Since 11 August 2026, Article L. 223-1 prohibits canvassing a consumer by telephone, directly or through a third party, without their prior consent, which the trader must prove. Telephone canvassing for energy-saving work, renewable energy production or the adaptation of homes to old age or disability is banned outright, outside the performance of an existing contract. A trader that profited from calls made in breach of these rules is presumed responsible unless it shows that it did not cause the breach, and a contract concluded after unlawful canvassing is void.

Sectors under scrutiny

Elderly customers living alone, energy renovation (high amounts, technical arguments the customer cannot check, often a linked loan) and emergency home repairs account for many cases. Emergency repairs fall under Article L. 121-9, 5°: a person locked out late at night cannot compare offers.

Investigation and prosecution

How a case starts

These cases usually start with a complaint: a relative who discovers a parent's bank statements, a court-appointed guardian, a bank alarmed by unusual cheques, or consumer reports. Inspectors can require documents of any kind useful to their work, wherever they are held (Article L. 512-8): contracts, order forms, collection dates, sales scripts, pay plans and prospect lists. They interview customers, salespeople and managers, and build the file customer by customer.

Interviews

Managers and salespeople are usually summoned. A person suspected of an offence can only be heard freely, in a voluntary interview (audition libre), after being informed of the offence, of the right to leave at any time and of the right to remain silent, and, for offences punishable by imprisonment, as all those discussed here are, of the right to be assisted by a lawyer (Article 61-1 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure, repealed with effect from 1 January 2029 by Ordonnance No. 2025-1091 of 19 November 2025). Statements are recorded and weigh heavily. Improvised explanations about bonuses or spontaneous admissions of targeting are common mistakes; the interview should be prepared with counsel.

After the investigation

Abuse of weakness and aggressive practices are criminal offences: the DGCCRF cannot punish them with an administrative fine. The report goes to the prosecutor, who decides what follows, from no further action or an alternative to prosecution to trial before the criminal court (tribunal correctionnel). As long as prosecution has not started, the authority can also propose a criminal transaction, with the prosecutor's agreement, for offences under the Consumer Code punishable by up to three years' imprisonment (Article L. 523-1). Simple abuse of weakness and aggressive practices, even followed by contracts, qualify; abuse of weakness after telephone canvassing (five years) and aggressive practices by an organised gang (seven years) do not. See our article on what happens when a DGCCRF report is sent to the prosecutor.

Penalties for the company and its managers

Main penalties

Abuse of weakness is punishable by three years' imprisonment and a €375,000 fine, which can be raised, in proportion to the benefits derived from the offence, to 10% of average annual turnover calculated on the last three known annual turnovers (Article L. 132-14). After telephone canvassing, the penalties rise to five years and €500,000, with the same turnover-based ceiling (Article L. 132-14-1).

An aggressive practice is punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine, which can also be raised to 10% of average annual turnover (Article L. 132-11). Imprisonment rises to three years if the practice was followed by contracts (Article L. 132-11-1) and to seven years for an organised gang (Article L. 132-11-2). On conviction, the court must order the display or publication of the decision or of a statement (Article L. 132-11).

Fines for companies

For a company, the maximum fine is five times that for individuals (Article 131-38 of the Criminal Code): €1,875,000 for abuse of weakness, €2,500,000 after telephone canvassing and €1,500,000 for an aggressive practice. The court sets the amount within these limits.

Additional penalties

Individuals convicted of abuse of weakness face a ban, for up to five years, on the activity in which the offence was committed or on running a business (Article L. 132-15); for aggressive practices, a ban of up to five years on any commercial activity (Article L. 132-12). Companies face the penalties of Article 131-39, 2° to 9° of the Criminal Code, including a ban on the activity concerned, judicial supervision, closure of establishments, exclusion from public procurement, confiscation and publication of the decision; those of 2° to 7° are limited to five years. For a direct selling business, a ban on the activity amounts in practice to closing down.

Civil consequences: void contracts and linked credit

Contracts are void

A contract concluded following an abuse of weakness is void and of no effect (Article L. 132-13), as is one concluded following an aggressive practice (Article L. 132-10) or after telephone canvassing in breach of Article L. 223-1. The customer, their heirs or their legal representative can ask the court to declare it void. Nullity generally means returning the price received, while recovering the value of the goods or work supplied is uncertain, and damages may be added. A conviction, or an investigation known to customers' families, can trigger further claims.

Linked credit

Where the purchase was financed by a linked credit agreement, the credit is cancelled by operation of law when the main contract is judicially annulled, provided the lender has joined the proceedings or been brought into them by the seller or the borrower (Article L. 312-55).

Injunctions

Separately, after an adversarial procedure, the authority can order the trader to stop any unlawful conduct (Article L. 521-1), with a daily penalty of up to €3,000 and €300,000 in total or, where the breach is punishable by a fine of at least €75,000, a daily penalty of up to 0.1% of worldwide turnover excluding tax, capped at 5% in total.

Consequence Aggressive commercial practice Abuse of weakness Payment within 7 days (off-premises contract)
Imprisonment 2 years; 3 years if contracts were concluded; 7 years for an organised gang 3 years; 5 years after telephone canvassing 2 years (L. 242-7)
Fine (individual) €300,000 or up to 10% of average annual turnover €375,000 (€500,000 after telephone canvassing) or up to 10% of average annual turnover €150,000
Fine (company) Five times the maximum for individuals (Criminal Code, 131-38)
Additional penalties Individuals: ban on any commercial activity, up to 5 years (L. 132-12). Companies: Criminal Code 131-39, 2° to 9° Individuals: ban on the activity or on running a business, up to 5 years (L. 132-15). Companies: Criminal Code 131-39, 2° to 9° Individuals: ban on exercising the activity concerned, among others (L. 242-8)
Publication Mandatory on conviction (L. 132-11) Available against companies (Criminal Code, 131-39, 9°) Not covered here
Contract Void (L. 132-10) Void (L. 132-13) Nullity (L. 242-1)
Criminal transaction (L. 523-1) Possible, except for an organised gang Possible, except after telephone canvassing Possible
Administrative measure Injunction to stop the unlawful conduct, with a daily penalty (L. 521-1)

When the company answers for its sales force and intermediaries

Organs and representatives

A company is criminally liable for offences committed on its behalf by its organs or representatives (Article 121-2 of the Criminal Code). The legal representative is an organ; a sales director with a delegation of powers may be treated as a representative. The company's liability does not exclude that of the individuals who committed the offence or were accomplices, so company, manager and salesperson can be tried together. An employed salesperson without delegated powers is, in principle, neither an organ nor a representative. But in doorstep selling, methods, targets, prospect lists and bonuses are set by management: when the facts reveal a sales policy rather than an isolated lapse, prosecuting the company and its managers is the logical next step.

Agents, business introducers and outsourced canvassing

Acts of commercial agents, independent sellers, business introducers or call centres are not automatically attributed to the company under Article 121-2. The company can, however, be prosecuted as an accomplice if it knowingly facilitated the offence or gave instructions to commit it (Article 121-7 of the Criminal Code), and courts may treat it as a co-offender where the sales method is its own. Contracts concluded in its name remain exposed to nullity. For telephone canvassing, the presumption of Article L. 223-1 puts a company that buys leads or appointments in the front line from the start of an investigation, although abuse of weakness itself still requires intent.

The manager

A manager cannot escape prosecution on the ground that they never met the customers when the sales method, its logistics and the contract documents are their own doing. On the personal exposure of managers, see our article on director liability for misleading practices in France.

Prevention: what investigators look at first

Investigators look at how salespeople are paid (variable pay, bonuses on large orders), sales scripts, how prospect lists are selected, the time between signature and collection, the share of elderly customers, cancellation rates and how complaints from families are handled. A company that cannot produce these documents, or produces documents that contradict what it says, risks having intent inferred from its own organisation. Training, scripts checked against Article L. 121-7, confirmation calls by a team independent of the sales force, records of consent and payment dates, and pay that does not reward pressure reduce exposure, provided they are applied in practice before any incident.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between abuse of weakness and an aggressive commercial practice in France?

An aggressive commercial practice (Articles L. 121-6 and L. 121-7 of the Consumer Code) punishes a sales method used on any consumer. Abuse of weakness (Articles L. 121-8 to L. 121-10) requires a victim who was weak or ignorant before the approach and a trader who knowingly took advantage of it. Both can be charged for the same facts.

What is the penalty for abuse of weakness for a company?

For an individual, three years' imprisonment and a €375,000 fine, or up to 10% of average annual turnover; five years and €500,000 after telephone canvassing (Articles L. 132-14 and L. 132-14-1). For a company, the maximum fine is five times higher (Article 131-38 of the Criminal Code), with additional penalties such as a ban on the activity or exclusion from public procurement. The contract is also void.

Is the customer's age enough to prove abuse of weakness?

No. Advanced age is an indication, not proof. Courts look at whether the person was actually unable to assess the commitment, detect the tricks used or resist pressure, and whether the seller knew it. Isolation, illness, a protective measure or a disproportionate amount complete the picture.

Can a contract signed after an abuse of weakness be cancelled?

Yes. Under Article L. 132-13 of the Consumer Code, such a contract is void and of no effect. If the purchase was financed by a linked loan, the loan is cancelled by operation of law once the main contract is judicially annulled, provided the lender is a party to the proceedings (Article L. 312-55).

Is a company liable for what its independent sales agents do?

Not automatically: Article 121-2 of the Criminal Code covers offences committed by the company's organs or representatives. But the company can be prosecuted as an accomplice if it gave instructions or knowingly facilitated the offence (Article 121-7), and contracts signed in its name remain exposed to nullity.

Can we take a deposit when selling door to door in France?

In principle, no. Article L. 221-10 prohibits any payment or consideration before seven days have passed from the conclusion of an off-premises contract, on pain of two years' imprisonment and a €150,000 fine (Article L. 242-7) and nullity of the contract (Article L. 242-1). Exceptions exist, notably for urgent repairs expressly requested by the consumer, limited to what is strictly necessary.

Is cold calling consumers still allowed in France?

Since 11 August 2026, only with the consumer's prior consent, which the trader must be able to prove, or within an existing contract (Article L. 223-1). Canvassing by telephone for energy-saving work, renewable energy or home adaptation is banned outside an existing contract. Contracts concluded after unlawful canvassing are void.

Can an abuse of weakness case be settled with the DGCCRF?

Sometimes. The authority can propose a criminal transaction, with the prosecutor's agreement and before prosecution starts, for offences punishable by up to three years' imprisonment (Article L. 523-1). Simple abuse of weakness qualifies; abuse of weakness after telephone canvassing, punishable by five years, does not.

Key actions

  • Before any incident: review pay plans, scripts, prospect lists and the timing of payments in doorstep and telephone sales.
  • Telephone canvassing: check that every call relies on documented prior consent, including calls made by subcontractors.
  • Request for documents or summons received: identify the offences targeted and prepare the answer and interviews with counsel.
  • Transaction proposed: weigh the amount and obligations against the strength of the file and the civil claims of customers.

Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.