Director liability for misleading practices in France

Can a director be prosecuted personally for misleading practices in France? Company and director liability, prison, fines, bans and delegation of powers.

Can a company director be personally liable for misleading practices in France?

Yes. A company's criminal liability does not exclude that of the individuals who committed the same facts or were accomplices to them (Article 121-2 of the French Criminal Code). A director who took part personally in a misleading commercial practice faces up to two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine, or five years and €750,000 when the offence is committed online, and a ban on managing any commercial company for up to five years.

Updated: November 2026. Key provisions: Articles 113-2, 121-1, 121-2, 121-7, 131-27, 131-38 and 131-39 of the French Criminal Code; Articles L. 121-2 to L. 121-4 and L. 132-2 to L. 132-4 of the French Consumer Code.

The DGCCRF (the French authority for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control), the DDPP (departmental directorates for the protection of populations) and the DREETS (regional directorates for the economy, employment, labour and solidarity) inspect businesses and record breaches. The same inspection can lead to administrative measures against the company and to criminal proceedings against both the company and its director. Many directors only realise that they are personally concerned when they are summoned for an interview or find their name in the inspection report. This guide explains how an offence is attributed to a director, what a delegation of powers can and cannot do, the penalties a director faces personally and the moments in the procedure when the director is directly exposed. A lawyer for DGCCRF and DDPP inspections can assess, early on, whether the procedure targets the company alone or its director as well.

Would you like to discuss your situation? Book a consultation:

CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION

Two liabilities, one investigation

What Article 121-2 of the Criminal Code says

Companies are criminally liable for offences committed on their behalf by their organs or representatives. That liability does not exclude the liability of the individuals who committed the same facts or were accomplices to them (Article 121-2). The text does not offer a choice between the company and its director: both can be prosecuted. At the same time, no one is criminally liable except for their own conduct (Article 121-1). The director's exposure therefore depends on what the director personally did or failed to do.

Prosecuting the company does not shield the director, and prosecuting the director does not spare the company. Prosecution of both is more likely where the practice reflects a commercial choice rather than an isolated error in carrying it out.

One file, two tracks

Inspectors do not run one investigation for the company and another for its director. They collect findings, documents and statements and record them in an inspection report (procès-verbal). The same material serves to establish the breach and to identify who decided, who approved and who knew. A report sent to the public prosecutor (procureur de la République) may therefore name an individual even where the company thought it was dealing with a routine administrative inspection.

How an offence is attributed to the director

Holding the title is not enough

A director is not criminally liable merely because of the position held (Article 121-1). In practice, the courts look for personal involvement: an act, an instruction, or a failure to act within the director's powers. This requirement protects less than it seems. In a company where the director approves the advertising, sets the pricing policy or validates the sales arguments, personal involvement may follow from the way the company works. The question then becomes the extent of that involvement rather than its existence.

Misleading practices are usually policy decisions

A commercial practice is misleading where it relies on false or misleading claims about, for example, the existence or nature of the product, its essential characteristics including origin and environmental impact, the price or price reductions, after-sales service, the trader's commitments, or the trader's identity and qualities (Article L. 121-2 of the French Consumer Code). It is also misleading where it omits, hides or presents unclearly material information (Article L. 121-3). Article L. 121-4 lists practices deemed misleading in all cases, such as false claims that a product is available only for a very limited time, or fake consumer reviews.

A reference price, an environmental claim, an origin claim or the way reviews are presented is rarely the initiative of a single employee. When the authority shows that the practice was decided at management level, attributing it to the director is the natural next step. For the substantive rules, see our guide to misleading commercial practices for business owners.

De facto directors and accomplices

Exposure is not limited to the legal representative shown in the trade register. A person who in fact runs the business without holding the title may be prosecuted in the same way if personal involvement is shown: for example, a shareholder who steers commercial policy without a corporate office, or a former director who kept an operational role after a sale. Conversely, a director in name only, with no real part in commercial decisions, is not in the same position as an operational director.

Complicity is a separate route. An accomplice is a person who knowingly, by aid or assistance, facilitated the preparation or commission of an offence, or who gave instructions to commit it, and is punished as the perpetrator (Articles 121-6 and 121-7 of the Criminal Code).

Omissions and failure to supervise

A director can also be exposed through what was not done: no checks on the material published, no procedure for verifying claims, or a practice left in place after a complaint or after a first inspection. Repetition weighs heavily. Once the company has received a warning or an injunction, the obligation is known, and keeping the practice going is likely to be treated as a choice.

Directors based outside France

Living abroad does not remove the exposure. French criminal law applies to offences committed in France, and an offence is deemed committed in France if one of its constituent facts took place there (Article 113-2 of the Criminal Code). A misleading practice aimed at consumers in France would in most cases meet that test, wherever the director lives. How a summons would be served and how a judgment could be enforced abroad depend on the case and on the country concerned. Our article on directors based outside France covers that situation.

Penalties for the director personally

Imprisonment and fine

Misleading commercial practices are punished by two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine. The fine can be raised, in proportion to the benefits derived from the offence, to 10% of average annual turnover over the last three years, or to 50% of the cost of the advertising or practice, a rate raised to 80% for certain environmental claims. When the offence is committed through an online public communication service or a digital or electronic medium, the penalties rise to five years' imprisonment and a €750,000 fine (Article L. 132-2). Imprisonment rises to three years when the practice was followed by one or more contracts (Article L. 132-2-1). Within these limits, the court sets the penalty according to the circumstances of the offence, the offender's personality and his or her material, family and social situation (Article 132-1 of the Criminal Code).

Bans on working and on managing a company

Individuals convicted of the offence also face, as additional penalties, either a ban on the professional or social activity in the course of which the offence was committed, or a ban on carrying on a commercial or industrial profession and on directing, administering, managing or controlling, directly or indirectly, any commercial or industrial business or commercial company. These bans cannot exceed five years and can be combined (Article L. 132-3, referring to Article 131-27 of the Criminal Code). A management ban applies to every business the person runs, not only the one concerned by the facts. In practice, it is often the penalty with the heaviest consequences.

Publication of the judgment

On conviction, the court orders the judgment, or a notice of its grounds and operative part, to be displayed or published, and may order corrective announcements at the convicted person's expense (Article L. 132-4). The director's name may then be publicly linked to the conviction.

Deception (tromperie)

An inspection can also lead to a charge of deception: misleading a contracting party as to the nature, origin, substantial qualities or composition of goods or services, among other things (Article L. 441-1 of the Consumer Code). It carries three years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine, which can be raised to 10% of average annual turnover (Articles L. 454-1 and L. 454-4). Individuals face the same types of bans. Article L. 454-5 sets no five-year limit for them, so the general rule of Article 131-27 of the Criminal Code would apply: a ban on managing a company can then be permanent or last up to fifteen years.

What the company faces at the same time

For a company, the maximum fine is five times that for individuals (Article 131-38 of the Criminal Code). The company also faces the penalties listed in 2° to 9° of Article 131-39, including a ban on the activity concerned, judicial supervision, closure of establishments, exclusion from public contracts, confiscation and publication of the decision. The penalties in 2° to 7° cannot exceed five years (Article L. 132-3). For a business that depends on public contracts or on a distribution network, these penalties can weigh more than the fine.

Penalty Director (individual) Company Legal basis
Imprisonment Two years; three years if contracts followed; five years if committed online Not applicable Consumer Code, L. 132-2 and L. 132-2-1
Fine €300,000, or €750,000 if committed online; can be raised to 10% of average annual turnover or 50% of the cost of the practice (80% for certain environmental claims) Five times the maximum for individuals Consumer Code, L. 132-2; Criminal Code, 131-38
Ban on the activity concerned Up to five years Up to five years Consumer Code, L. 132-3; Criminal Code, 131-39, 2°
Ban on directing, managing or controlling a business Up to five years; can be combined with the activity ban Not applicable Consumer Code, L. 132-3; Criminal Code, 131-27
Publication of the judgment Ordered on conviction; corrective announcements possible Ordered on conviction Consumer Code, L. 132-4; Criminal Code, 131-39, 9°
Other penalties for companies Not applicable Judicial supervision, closure of establishments, exclusion from public contracts (five years at most), confiscation Consumer Code, L. 132-3; Criminal Code, 131-39, 2° to 9°
For comparison: deception (tromperie) Three years and €300,000 (up to 10% of turnover); bans under Article 131-27, without a five-year limit Five times the fine; penalties of 131-39, 2° to 9° Consumer Code, L. 441-1, L. 454-1, L. 454-4 and L. 454-5

Delegation of powers: what it can and cannot do

A rule built by the courts

No general statute defines the delegation of powers in criminal matters. The rules come from the case law of the criminal courts. In substance, a director may avoid liability for a breach of regulations by proving that powers were delegated to a member of staff with the competence, authority and means needed to ensure compliance. The burden of proof lies with the director who relies on the delegation, and a delegation that cannot be documented is of little help. Delegation is not confined to health and safety and can, in principle, be relied on in economic regulation.

What a delegation does not cover

A delegation transfers defined powers within a defined scope. It is unlikely to protect the director for decisions that belong to general management and cannot be handed over, such as a commercial policy decided at the top. Nor would it protect a director who took part personally in the facts, gave contrary instructions or let a known situation continue. For misleading practices, which are often policy decisions, this is the main limit.

Weak points found in practice include undated documents or documents drawn up after the facts, a scope described in general terms, a delegate with no real budget, team or authority to stop a campaign, sub-delegations that were not authorised, overlapping delegations and delegations not updated after a reorganisation. Whether an existing delegation would hold up should be reviewed before it is produced to an investigator or a court, on the basis of the organisation chart, the corporate documents and the real chain of decisions.

Prosecuting the company and the director together

Two defences that may diverge

For the director, joint prosecution has two consequences. The director appears in his or her own name, and any fine imposed on the director is a personal penalty. And the director's defence and the company's do not necessarily coincide: what clears one may weigh on the other. When the legal representative is prosecuted for the same or related facts, he or she can ask the president of the judicial court to appoint a court representative (mandataire de justice) to represent the company (Article 706-43 of the French Code of Criminal Procedure). Representation should be organised at the start of the procedure, not on the eve of the hearing.

Criminal liability is not civil liability

Directors often reason with company law in mind. Under civil law, a director's personal liability towards third parties is generally considered to require a fault separable from the director's functions, a demanding test developed by the courts. No such filter applies in criminal law, where the question is personal involvement in the offence. A director may therefore escape civil liability towards a third party and still be convicted for the same facts. Assessing an inspection only through company law tends to underestimate the risk.

The administrative route

The same facts can lead, on the administrative side, to an injunction to comply, which may carry a daily penalty (Article L. 521-1 of the Consumer Code), or to an administrative fine, and on the criminal side to prosecution. Before an administrative fine, the authority informs the person concerned in writing of the intended sanction and of the right to be assisted by counsel, and invites observations within one month (Articles L. 522-5 and R. 522-2). Administrative fines are imposed on the trader that committed the breach, usually the company. Their ceilings distinguish individuals from companies (for example, Article L. 131-1), a distinction that would mainly concern traders operating in their own name. A company director's main personal exposure therefore lies in criminal law.

For misleading practices, the authority can also propose a criminal transaction, with the prosecutor's agreement, as long as prosecution has not started (Article L. 523-1). A position taken in one procedure has effects in the other: a letter sent to the authority may end up in the criminal file. The administrative and criminal sides need one consistent approach from the first exchanges.

When the director is directly exposed

The inspection visit

During an inspection, the director is often the inspectors' first contact. Inspectors can gather information and documents on site or by summons, and interview any person likely to provide useful information; the statements are recorded in a report that the person reads and signs (Article L. 512-10 of the Consumer Code). The director speaks as the company's representative, but explanations about who designed a campaign, who approved a sales pitch or what was known internally feed directly into the attribution of the offence. Cooperating on documents and making statements about responsibilities are not the same thing. Obstructing the inspectors is itself an offence, punished by two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine (Article L. 531-1).

The voluntary interview (audition libre)

A summons to an interview as a suspect marks a clear shift. When the person heard is suspected of an offence, the voluntary interview rules of the Code of Criminal Procedure apply (Article L. 512-10 of the Consumer Code, referring to Article 61-1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The person must first be told of the suspected offence and of their rights, including the right to leave at any time, to remain silent and, for offences punishable by imprisonment, to be assisted by a lawyer. The interview, and its link with what has already been said to the authority, should be prepared beforehand.

The inspection report and what follows

The inspection report records the findings and identifies the persons concerned. Reading it closely shows whether the director is named, in what capacity, and on what evidence. It also shapes what happens next: no further action, a transaction, or referral to the criminal court (tribunal correctionnel). What the prosecutor can do with the report is explained in our article on a DGCCRF report sent to the prosecutor.

The hearing before the criminal court

Before the court, the director appears in person. Any penalty must be individualised (Article 132-1 of the Criminal Code). This is where imprisonment, the fine and, above all, professional bans are argued; their effect on the director's life often outweighs that of the fine.

Stage What happens Why the director is exposed Legal basis
Inspection visit Information, documents and interviews, recorded in a signed report Statements made as the company's representative can be used to attribute the offence; obstruction is a separate offence Consumer Code, L. 512-10 and L. 531-1
Voluntary interview (audition libre) Interview of a person suspected of an offence The director is heard as a suspect; rights to be informed, to remain silent and, for offences punishable by imprisonment, to a lawyer Consumer Code, L. 512-10; Code of Criminal Procedure, 61-1
Administrative adversarial phase Written notice of an intended administrative fine; one month for observations The director usually answers for the company; what is written may reach the criminal file Consumer Code, L. 522-5 and R. 522-2
Criminal transaction Proposal by the authority, with the prosecutor's agreement, before prosecution starts Amount and obligations to assess before answering Consumer Code, L. 523-1
Joint prosecution Company and director prosecuted for the same facts Defences may diverge; a court representative can be appointed for the company Criminal Code, 121-2; Code of Criminal Procedure, 706-43
Hearing before the criminal court Trial of the director in person Imprisonment, fine, bans and publication; penalties are individualised Consumer Code, L. 132-2 to L. 132-4; Criminal Code, 132-1

Consequences beyond the sentence

  • Public exposure: publication ordered under Article L. 132-4 links the director's name to the conviction.
  • Other mandates: a management ban covers every commercial business, including those unrelated to the facts.
  • Financing: banks and investors may take a personal conviction of the director into account.
  • Directors' liability insurance: policies contain exclusions whose scope should be checked before, not after, the director is targeted.
  • Continuity: a ban can disrupt a business that relies on its director.

These effects are reasons to treat the director's personal exposure as a separate subject from the start of the procedure, alongside the company's defence.

Frequently asked questions

Can a director be prosecuted if the company is already being prosecuted?

Yes. A company's criminal liability does not exclude that of the individuals who committed the same facts or were accomplices to them (Article 121-2 of the Criminal Code). Prosecution of both is more likely when the practice was decided at management level.

Does a delegation of powers protect the director?

Not automatically. Under case law, the delegate must have the competence, authority and means needed, and the director must prove the delegation. It is unlikely to help where the director took part personally or where the practice reflects a policy that could not be delegated.

What penalties does a director face for a misleading commercial practice in France?

Two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine, or five years and €750,000 when the offence is committed online; three years' imprisonment when contracts followed. The fine can be raised to 10% of average annual turnover or 50% of the cost of the practice, 80% for certain environmental claims (Articles L. 132-2 and L. 132-2-1 of the Consumer Code). Bans and publication of the judgment can be added (Articles L. 132-3 and L. 132-4).

How long can a French court ban a director from managing a company?

For a misleading commercial practice, up to five years (Article L. 132-3). For deception, Article L. 454-5 sets no such limit, so under Article 131-27 of the Criminal Code the ban can be permanent or last up to fifteen years.

Can the company pay a fine imposed on its director?

A criminal fine imposed on an individual is a personal penalty. Payment by the company raises company law and tax questions of its own and may create a further risk. Take advice before any decision.

Can a director who did not take part in the facts be convicted?

Criminal liability does not follow from the title alone: personal involvement is required (Article 121-1). That involvement can, however, result from a failure to supervise or from keeping a practice in place after being told about it. The line between not knowing and negligence is narrow and depends on how the company actually works.

I live outside France. Can I be prosecuted in France?

Yes, if one of the constituent facts of the offence took place in France (Article 113-2 of the Criminal Code), which will often be the case for a practice aimed at French consumers. Distance changes how the procedure unfolds, not whether French law applies.

When should a director involve a lawyer?

As early as possible, ideally at the inspection or on receipt of a summons. Statements made during the investigation and letters sent to the authority go into the file and are hard to withdraw. Existing delegations should also be reviewed at that stage.

Key actions

  • Inspection under way: cooperate on documents; statements about who decided what are better made after preparation with counsel.
  • Summons received: check in what capacity you are summoned and prepare the interview with counsel.
  • Inspection report received: check whether you are named, in what capacity and on what evidence.
  • Before relying on a delegation: have it reviewed against the real organisation of the company.

Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.