Environmental claims in France: what is banned and checked

Greenwashing rules in France: banned wording, carbon neutral claims, labels, Directive 2024/825 and its transposition, DGCCRF checks and penalties.

Which environmental claims are banned in France?

French law already bans the words "biodegradable" and "environmentally friendly" on products and packaging, allows "carbon neutral" in advertising only if supporting information is published, and treats any false or misleading environmental claim as a misleading commercial practice, which is a criminal offence. Directive (EU) 2024/825 adds several environmental claims to the EU list of practices that are unfair in all circumstances, and Member States had to apply it from 27 September 2026. On 17 November 2026, France had not yet transposed it, but the French rules in force already catch most greenwashing.

Updated: November 2026. Key provisions: Articles L. 121-2, L. 121-4, L. 132-2, L. 512-15 and L. 521-1 of the French Consumer Code; Articles L. 229-68, L. 229-69, L. 541-9-1 and L. 541-9-4-1 of the French Environmental Code; Directive (EU) 2024/825 of 28 February 2024.

The DGCCRF (the French authority for competition, consumer affairs and fraud control) and its local offices, the DDPP (departmental directorates for the protection of populations), check environmental claims on packaging, labels, websites, social media and advertising. They can order a business to bring its claims into line, impose an administrative fine where a text provides for one, or report the case to the public prosecutor. For a foreign brand selling in France, the main risk is to rely on claims accepted in its home market. A lawyer for DGCCRF and DDPP inspections can review your claims before an inspection, or assist you once one has started.

Would you like to discuss your situation? Book a consultation:

CLICK HERE TO BOOK YOUR ONLINE CONSULTATION

What counts as an environmental claim

A wide definition

Directive 2024/825 defines an environmental claim as any message or representation that is not mandatory under EU or national law, in any form, including text, pictorial, graphic or symbolic representation, such as labels, brand names, company names or product names, made in a commercial communication, which states or implies that a product, product category, brand or trader has a positive or zero impact on the environment, is less damaging than others, or has improved its impact over time (Article 2, point (o), of Directive 2005/29/EC as amended). A green leaf on a pack, a product name built around "nature" or a corporate slogan can therefore all be claims.

Brand names and claims about the business

Because brand names, company names and product names are expressly covered, a brand whose identity rests on an environmental promise should review its own name, not only its packaging. Claims about the trader as a whole, such as a sustainability page, a corporate report reused in advertising or a social media post, are also covered when made in a commercial communication.

Generic and specific claims

A generic environmental claim is a written or oral claim, not included on a sustainability label, whose specification is not given in clear and prominent terms on the same medium (Article 2, point (p)). The directive's recitals give examples such as "environmentally friendly", "eco-friendly", "green", "ecological" and "climate friendly". A claim that states precisely what it covers, on the same medium, is not generic, but it must still be accurate and supported by evidence.

The timetable: what applies now, and what the directive changes

French rules already in force

France legislated before the EU. The anti-waste law (Law No. 2020-105 of 10 February 2020) introduced the ban on "biodegradable" and "environmentally friendly" on products and packaging, in force since 1 January 2022 (Article L. 541-9-1 of the Environmental Code). The Climate and Resilience Law (Law No. 2021-1104 of 22 August 2021) introduced the rules on "carbon neutral" advertising (Articles L. 229-68 and L. 229-69). Above all, the general rule on misleading commercial practices expressly covers a product's environmental impact (Article L. 121-2 of the Consumer Code).

Directive (EU) 2024/825

The directive of 28 February 2024 amends the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (2005/29/EC) and the Consumer Rights Directive (2011/83/EU). Published in the Official Journal on 6 March 2024, it entered into force on the twentieth day after publication. Member States had to adopt and publish their transposition measures by 27 March 2026 and apply them from 27 September 2026 (Article 4).

Where French transposition stands

On 17 November 2026, no French law transposing the directive had been published in the Official Journal, and Articles L. 121-2 and L. 121-4 of the Consumer Code were still in their version in force since 28 May 2022. A directive that has not been transposed does not, by itself, impose obligations on businesses. French authorities and courts may nonetheless read the existing rules in the light of the directive, and a transposition law could be adopted at any time. Preparing now is therefore the prudent course, without treating the new bans as already enforceable.

Rule Legal basis Status on 17 November 2026 Sanction
False or misleading environmental claims Consumer Code, L. 121-2, 2°, b and e In force (version since 28 May 2022) Criminal offence: L. 132-2 (fine up to 80% of advertising costs)
Displaying a certificate or quality label without authorisation Consumer Code, L. 121-4, 2° In force Criminal offence: L. 132-2
"Biodegradable", "environmentally friendly" on a product or packaging; recycled content; "compostable" Environmental Code, L. 541-9-1 In force since 1 January 2022 Administrative fine up to €3,000 / €15,000 (L. 541-9-4-1)
"Carbon neutral" in advertising Environmental Code, L. 229-68 In force Administrative fine €20,000 / €100,000, up to the full cost of the operation (L. 229-69)
New blacklisted claims: generic claims, offsetting claims, whole-product claims, legal requirements as a feature, uncertified labels Directive (EU) 2024/825, Annex (points 2a, 4a, 4b, 4c, 10a of Annex I to Directive 2005/29/EC) To be applied from 27 September 2026; not transposed in France Under French law once transposed
Future performance claims without a verified plan Directive 2005/29/EC, Article 6(2)(d), as amended To be applied from 27 September 2026; not transposed in France Under French law once transposed; meanwhile L. 121-2 may apply

French rules that already apply

"Biodegradable" and "environmentally friendly" on products and packaging

Article L. 541-9-1 of the Environmental Code prohibits the words "biodégradable", "respectueux de l'environnement" (environmentally friendly) "or any other equivalent wording" on a product or its packaging. When a product is described as recycled, the percentage of recycled material actually incorporated must be stated. Plastic products and packaging that can only be composted industrially cannot be labelled "compostable", and compostable plastics must carry the words "Ne pas jeter dans la nature" (do not discard in nature).

DGCCRF officers can record breaches of this article (Article L. 511-7, 28°, of the Consumer Code). Breaches of the information obligations in Article L. 541-9-1 are punishable by an administrative fine of up to €3,000 for a natural person and €15,000 for a legal person, imposed under the Consumer Code procedure (Article L. 541-9-4-1 of the Environmental Code).

"Carbon neutral" in advertising

Article L. 229-68 of the Environmental Code prohibits stating in an advertisement that a product or service is carbon neutral, or using any wording of equivalent meaning or scope, unless the advertiser makes the following readily available to the public:

  • a greenhouse gas emissions assessment covering the direct and indirect emissions of the product or service;
  • the approach by which emissions are first avoided, then reduced and finally offset, with a reduction trajectory described by quantified annual targets;
  • the arrangements for offsetting residual emissions, which must meet minimum standards set by decree.

A breach can lead to an administrative fine of €20,000 for a natural person and €100,000 for a legal person, which can be raised to the full amount spent on the unlawful operation (Article L. 229-69). Once the directive is transposed, a claim of neutral, reduced or positive impact based on offsetting would be banned outright, whatever information is published.

Misleading commercial practices: the general rule

Independently of these specific texts, a commercial practice is misleading when it relies on false or misleading claims about the essential characteristics of a product or service, which expressly include its environmental impact, or about the scope of the advertiser's commitments, notably environmental ones (Article L. 121-2, 2°, b and e, of the Consumer Code). Article L. 121-4 already treats as misleading the display of a certificate, quality label or equivalent without the necessary authorisation (2°), and the presentation of rights given to consumers by law as a distinctive feature of the trader's offer (10°). For labels and certifications in general, see our article on awards, labels and ranking claims in France.

What the directive adds

A blacklist: no need to show an effect on consumers

Annex I of Directive 2005/29/EC lists commercial practices that are "in all circumstances" regarded as unfair (Article 5(5)). For other misleading practices, the authority must show that the practice causes, or is likely to cause, the average consumer to take a decision he or she would not otherwise have taken (Article 6). Directive 2024/825 adds twelve practices to the list, five of which are discussed below. In France, the list is transposed in Article L. 121-4 of the Consumer Code, which had not yet been amended on 17 November 2026.

Generic claims without recognised excellent performance

Making a generic environmental claim will be banned where the trader cannot demonstrate recognised excellent environmental performance relevant to the claim (Annex I, point 4a). That performance means compliance with the EU Ecolabel Regulation (EC) No 66/2010, with EN ISO 14024 type I ecolabelling schemes officially recognised in the Member States, or top environmental performance under other applicable EU law (Article 2, point (s)). Without one of these, a generic claim would have to give way to a specific claim, stated on the same medium and supported by evidence.

Offsetting, partial claims and legal requirements

Three other practices will be banned outright:

  • claiming, on the basis of offsetting greenhouse gas emissions, that a product has a neutral, reduced or positive impact on the environment in terms of emissions (point 4c); on the wording of this point, describing an offsetting programme as such is not within the ban, but it must not be turned into a claim about the product's impact;
  • making a claim about the entire product, or the trader's entire business, when it concerns only one aspect of the product or one activity (point 4b), such as a real improvement to the packaging presented as a benefit of the whole product;
  • presenting requirements imposed by law on all products of the category on the EU market as a distinctive feature of the offer (point 10a).

Sustainability labels

Displaying a sustainability label that is not based on a certification scheme or not established by public authorities will also be banned (point 2a). A sustainability label is any voluntary trust mark, quality mark or equivalent, public or private, that sets apart a product, process or business for its environmental or social characteristics, excluding mandatory labels. A certification scheme must be open to all traders on transparent, fair and non-discriminatory terms, have requirements developed in consultation with relevant stakeholders, provide for withdrawal or suspension of the label in case of non-compliance, and rely on monitoring by a third party independent of both the scheme owner and the trader (Article 2, points (q) and (r)). A label created by a brand for its own products, without such third-party monitoring, would not meet these criteria.

Claims about future performance

A claim about future environmental performance, such as a "net zero" target, is not on the blacklist. It becomes a misleading action, assessed case by case, if it is made without clear, objective, publicly available and verifiable commitments set out in a detailed and realistic implementation plan, with measurable and time-bound targets, regularly verified by an independent third party whose findings are made available to consumers (Article 6(2)(d)). Advertising benefits to consumers that are irrelevant and do not result from any feature of the product or business is treated the same way (Article 6(2)(e)).

Comparison tools and scores

Where a trader provides a service comparing products on environmental or social characteristics or on circularity aspects such as durability, reparability or recyclability, information on the comparison method, the products compared, their suppliers and how the information is kept up to date is material information (Article 7(7)). Omitting it can make the practice misleading.

Claim or practice French law on 17 November 2026 Once Directive 2024/825 is transposed
"Biodegradable", "environmentally friendly" on a product or packaging Prohibited (Environmental Code, L. 541-9-1) Still prohibited on products and packaging; on other media, banned as a generic claim unless recognised excellent environmental performance is shown (point 4a)
"Carbon neutral" based on offsetting Allowed in advertising only with the published information required (L. 229-68) Banned in all circumstances (point 4c)
In-house label without third-party certification Misleading if it misleads consumers (L. 121-2); label without authorisation (L. 121-4, 2°) Banned in all circumstances unless based on a certification scheme or established by public authorities (point 2a)
Claim about the whole product based on one aspect Assessed case by case (L. 121-2) Banned in all circumstances (point 4b)
Legal requirement presented as a distinctive feature Assessed case by case (L. 121-2); consumers' legal rights presented as a feature are already blacklisted (L. 121-4, 10°) Banned in all circumstances (point 10a)
Future target such as "net zero by 2030" Assessed case by case (L. 121-2) Misleading, case by case, without a detailed and realistic plan regularly verified by an independent third party (Article 6(2)(d))

Substantiation: the burden is on the business

When investigating misleading practices, officers can require the person responsible for the practice to provide all the evidence that supports its claims, including where that evidence is held by a manufacturer established outside France, and can require the advertiser, the agency or the medium to provide the advertisements broadcast (Article L. 512-15 of the Consumer Code). They can also require documents of any kind and take copies of them (Article L. 512-8). For a foreign brand, this means the evidence behind each claim must be producible in France, in a usable form, when asked. The same applies when it is your French distributor that is inspected: see our guide for foreign suppliers whose French customer has been summoned by the consumer authority.

A useful file shows the exact scope of each claim, the method used to support it, and documents dated at the time the claim was made. Inspections often concern claims made several years earlier, and evidence that was not kept is hard to rebuild. Once the directive is transposed, no evidence will save a claim that falls within the blacklist.

How the DGCCRF checks environmental claims

Inspections can cover every medium: packaging, labels, websites, social media, catalogues, shop windows and in-store advertising. After the inspection, the authority chooses among several routes, which can be combined:

  • Injunction: after an adversarial procedure, officers can order a business to comply with its obligations or stop an unlawful practice within a set time (Article L. 521-1 of the Consumer Code). A daily penalty of up to €3,000 can be attached, capped at €300,000 in total. Where the breach carries a fine of at least €75,000, the daily penalty can instead be set at up to 0.1% of the company's worldwide turnover excluding tax, capped at 5% in total. The injunction can be published at the business's expense (Article L. 521-2).
  • Administrative fine: only where a text provides for one, such as Article L. 541-9-4-1 or Article L. 229-69 of the Environmental Code. A fine imposed under the Consumer Code procedure can be published (Article L. 522-6).
  • Report to the public prosecutor (procureur de la République): for a misleading commercial practice, which carries no administrative fine and is tried by the criminal court (tribunal correctionnel).

Some sectors have their own claim rules on top of these. For cosmetics, see our article on cosmetic claims in France.

Penalties

The criminal offence of misleading commercial practice

A misleading commercial practice is punishable by two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine. The fine can be raised, in proportion to the benefits derived, to 10% of average annual turnover over the last three years, or to 50% of the cost of the advertising or practice; that rate rises to 80% for misleading practices under points b and e of 2° of Article L. 121-2 that rely on environmental claims. Where the offence is committed online or through a digital medium, the penalties rise to five years' imprisonment and a €750,000 fine (Article L. 132-2 of the Consumer Code). Imprisonment rises to three years where the practice was followed by the conclusion of contracts (Article L. 132-2-1), and the maximum fine for a company is five times that for natural persons (Article 131-38 of the French Criminal Code).

Publication of the conviction

On conviction, the court orders the display or broadcast of all or part of the decision, or of a statement of its grounds and operative part, and can order corrective notices at the convicted person's expense (Article L. 132-4). For a brand built on a responsible image, this publicity can cost more than the fine. Directors also face personal penalties, including a ban on running a business (Article L. 132-3).

Administrative penalties

The administrative fines are those of the specific texts: up to €3,000 or €15,000 for breaches of the information obligations in Article L. 541-9-1, and €20,000 or €100,000, up to the full cost of the operation, for "carbon neutral" advertising. To these are added injunctions and their daily penalties.

Existing stock and materials already in circulation

The directive does not itself contain a transitional rule for products already placed on the market; whether the French transposition law will provide one is not known. Claims are usually spread across product pages, distributor visuals, printed catalogues, technical sheets, old social media posts still online, packaging in production and stock already shipped. The practical work is to find every medium carrying a claim that is or will become unlawful, decide what can be corrected and when, and keep a dated record of the steps taken. How to deal with stock already on the market should be decided with counsel, in the light of the transposition text once published.

Frequently asked questions

What are the penalties for greenwashing in France?

Greenwashing is mainly prosecuted as a misleading commercial practice: two years' imprisonment and a €300,000 fine, five years and €750,000 online, with a fine that can reach 80% of the advertising costs for environmental claims (Article L. 132-2 of the Consumer Code). Companies face five times the fine. Specific administrative fines apply to "carbon neutral" advertising (Article L. 229-69 of the Environmental Code) and to breaches of the information rules for products and packaging (Article L. 541-9-4-1).

Does Directive 2024/825 already apply in France?

Member States had to apply it from 27 September 2026. On 17 November 2026, France had not published a transposition law, and the Consumer Code articles on misleading practices were unchanged. The directive does not by itself bind businesses, but the existing French rules already cover most misleading environmental claims, and transposition could follow at any time.

Can we still say "carbon neutral" about a product in France?

Today, only in compliance with Article L. 229-68 of the Environmental Code: the advertiser must make available an emissions assessment, the avoid-reduce-offset approach with quantified annual targets, and the offsetting arrangements. Once the directive is transposed, a neutral, reduced or positive impact claim based on offsetting would be banned in all cases.

Is "biodegradable" allowed on packaging in France?

No. Article L. 541-9-1 of the Environmental Code prohibits "biodégradable", "respectueux de l'environnement" or any equivalent wording on a product or its packaging. On other media, a vague "biodegradable" claim may still be a misleading practice under Article L. 121-2 of the Consumer Code.

Can we use our own sustainability label?

Under the directive, a sustainability label must be based on a certification scheme with independent third-party monitoring, or be established by public authorities. A label created by a brand for its own products would not qualify once the directive is transposed. Under current French law, displaying a label without the necessary authorisation is already a misleading practice (Article L. 121-4, 2°), and any label that misleads consumers can be caught by Article L. 121-2.

Does our brand name count as an environmental claim?

It can. The directive's definition expressly covers brand names, company names and product names when they state or imply a positive or reduced environmental impact. A brand name built on an environmental promise should be reviewed together with the evidence that supports it.

Our products are made outside France. Who has to substantiate the claims?

The person responsible for the practice in France. Officers can require it to provide all the evidence supporting the claims, including evidence held by a manufacturer established outside France (Article L. 512-15 of the Consumer Code). Make sure that evidence can be produced quickly.

What happens after a DGCCRF inspection of environmental claims?

Depending on the case: an injunction to comply, with a possible daily penalty (Article L. 521-1), an administrative fine where a specific text provides for one, or a report to the public prosecutor for a misleading commercial practice. The routes can be combined, and the injunction or the fine can be published.

Key actions

  • List your claims on every medium, brand and product names included, and check them against Articles L. 541-9-1 and L. 229-68 of the Environmental Code and L. 121-2 of the Consumer Code.
  • Keep dated evidence for each claim, producible in France on request.
  • Prepare for the directive: identify generic claims, offsetting claims and in-house labels that will have to change once it is transposed.
  • Inspection or request for documents received: take advice before answering, as the first answer frames the rest of the procedure.

Article written by Guillaume Leclerc, lawyer at the Paris Bar, 34 avenue des Champs-Élysées, Paris. Working languages: French and English.