What is an exclusion clause? - Definition and purpose
The exclusion clause is a contractual provision, inserted into articles of association or shareholders' agreements, that allows for the exclusion of a shareholder or member of a company under specific conditions and organizes the buyout of their shares. At the heart of governance strategy and dispute prevention, it addresses the need for protection against deadlocks or conflicts of interest while preserving the company's continuity.
Why include an exclusion clause in the articles of association?
- To avoid company paralysis in the event of internal conflicts, loss of trust, or serious misconduct by a shareholder.
- To regulate the conditions for the forced exit of a shareholder and prevent legal pitfalls.
- To secure share capital by protecting common interests against shareholders who have become detrimental or incompatible with the collective project.
Practical example: In a SAS, a shareholder engages in a competing activity in violation of the statutory non-compete clause: the exclusion clause then provides for their forced exit, with their shares bought back according to the chosen terms.
What are the grounds for excluding a shareholder? - Legal and practical foundations
The legitimacy of an exclusion clause always relies on the clarity of the grounds for exclusion, which must be precise, objective, and non-discriminatory to rule out any risk of majority abuse or arbitrary action.
The most common grounds:
- Serious breach of statutory or contractual obligations (e.g., repeated absence from meetings, fraud, embezzlement).
- Unfair competition : acquiring an interest in a competing company, violation of a non-compete clause.
- Loss of an essential qualification : expired mandate, withdrawal of a required professional license.
- Resignation or voluntary withdrawal under the conditions provided.
- Statutory expulsion for "incompatibility of temperament," provided it is precisely described in the articles of association.
Recent case law: The Court of Cassation has reaffirmed the requirement for serious grounds for exclusion and the necessary respect for the rights of the defense (Cass. com. October 24, 2018, No. 17-26.402).
Conditions for the validity of an exclusion clause
To ensure legal certainty, the exclusion clause must:
- be drafted clearly and precisely,
- specify the detailed grounds and the procedural requirements,
- respect the adversarial principle (the shareholder concerned must be able to present their defense),
- govern the valuation of the buyout price of the shares,
- specify the authority of the body responsible for the exclusion (General Meeting, board, third party).
Drafting examples:
"Any shareholder who, through their conduct, causes serious harm to the company or repeatedly violates their statutory obligations may be excluded. Exclusion is decided by the other shareholders, following the summoning and hearing of the individual concerned, with the required majority set at 2/3 of the votes present or represented. The shares of the excluded shareholder shall be repurchased at a value determined in accordance with Article 1843-4 of the Civil Code…".
How is the exclusion clause applied in practice?
The exclusion procedure
- Summons and notification: The targeted shareholder is informed of the grounds and the date of the meeting called to decide on their exclusion.
- Adversarial proceedings: The shareholder concerned may present their arguments and be assisted by counsel.
- Voting: Depending on the articles of association, the shareholder may be excluded from the vote, but not from the discussions.
- Reasoned decision: The decision to exclude must be justified and formally notified.
What happens to the shares of the excluded shareholder?
The shares of the excluded shareholder become immediately transferable: they may be repurchased by the other shareholders, the company itself, or a designated third party, according to the mechanisms provided for in the articles of association. The valuation of the shares follows the pre-determined method (expert appraisal, statutory formula, or agreement between parties).
Variations by legal form: SAS, SARL, SCI, SA
Exclusion clause in an SAS
- High degree of drafting freedom.
- Possibility of providing for exclusion based on objective or subjective grounds.
- Removal of the unanimity requirement to amend a clause or adopt a new one (majority as provided by the articles of association, Soilihi Law of July 2019).
- Procedure detailed in the articles of association (competent body, respect for adversarial rights, repurchase price).
Exclusion clauses in SARLs
- Less common; insertion via statutory amendment requires unanimity.
- Strictly limited grounds.
- Enhanced protection for minority shareholder rights.
Exclusion clauses in SAs
- Possible via approval clauses, most often used to manage withdrawal in the event of a change of control or serious disagreement.
- Requires a strict procedure and adequate compensation.
Exclusion clauses in SCIs
- Approval and exclusion clauses: tailored arrangements, but with an obligation to respect the corporate purpose and common interest.
- Can be used to remove an inactive or litigious partner, with mandatory buyback or transfer of their shares.
Exclusion clauses in insurance: a different approach
In insurance contracts, the exclusion clause does not target a partner but limits the scope of the coverage or the insured risk. It must be formal, limited, clear, and highly conspicuous to the policyholder in accordance with Article L. 113-1 of the Insurance Code. Example: exclusion of risks related to certain uses or the influence of narcotics.
The relationship between exclusion clauses, approval clauses, pre-emption clauses, and non-transferability clauses
Approval clause
- Makes the entry of new partners conditional upon the prior agreement of the collective; often complementary to the exclusion clause: the excluded partner must now have their replacement approved.
Pre-emption clause
- Grants existing partners a priority right to acquire the shares of the excluded partner - strengthening the stability of the shareholding structure.
Non-transferability clause
- Prohibits any transfer or assignment of shares for a specified period (max 10 years), unless unanimously agreed upon by the shareholders.
Recent case law: pillars, developments, and limitations
- Validity of "statutory" exclusion : Montpellier Court of Appeal (2020) validates the procedure due to the absence of abuse.
- Protection of the right to a defense : exclusion must respect the adversarial principle; the right to vote may be excluded, but not the right to participate in discussions.
- Litigation regarding abusive exclusions : focus on the necessity of serious grounds and the absence of discrimination.
- 2019 Soilihi Law : facilitates the adoption and modification of clauses in simplified joint-stock companies (SAS) by the majority provided for in the articles of association.
- Recent 2024 decisions (Court of Cassation) : further clarify the limits of the power of exclusion and refine the balance between statutory flexibility and individual protection.
Concrete examples and templates for exclusion clauses
Clause example:
"Any shareholder who commits a serious breach of their contractual obligations or acts against the company's interests may, by a decision of the Board of Directors taken by a two-thirds majority, be excluded from the company. The redemption price of their shares will be determined according to the valuation method set out in the articles of association or, failing agreement, by an expert appointed in accordance with Article 1843-4 of the Civil Code. The shareholder in question will be summoned by registered letter with acknowledgment of receipt, will have the opportunity to present their arguments, and may be assisted by legal counsel."
Practical guide: Key points for securing your exclusion clause
- Draft the clause with care and caution
- Define exhaustively the grounds for exclusion
- Specify the adversarial procedure
- Determine the terms for the buyout of shares
- Verify consistency with all other statutory provisions (approval, inalienability, pre-emption)
- Seek assistance from a corporate lawyer
- Update it whenever the legal form or case law evolves
FAQ: Frequently asked questions about the exclusion clause
What is an exclusion clause?
It is a contractual provision that allows for the exclusion of a partner or member for specific reasons by requiring them to sell their shares or units.
What are exclusion clauses?
Any clause that pre-establishes the conditions, grounds, and procedures for the forced exit of a partner to protect the company's interests.
What are the grounds for exclusion?
Serious misconduct, breach of statutory or contractual obligations, loss of essential status, serious conflict of interest, harmful behavior, or violation of a legal or regulatory provision.
What is an exclusion clause in a real estate investment company (SCI)?
A provision inserted into the articles of association to allow for the removal of a partner, particularly in cases of inactivity or misconduct, provided that the corporate purpose and collective interest are respected.
How does an exclusion clause work in insurance?
It specifies situations not covered by the contract (coverage exclusions) and must be formal, clear, limited, conspicuous, and unambiguous to remain valid.
How do exclusion clauses work for SARLs and SAs?
In a SARL, they are rare and require unanimous shareholder approval to be included. In an SA, they are primarily implemented through approval clauses and compensation.
Can a shareholder be excluded without a statutory clause?
This is nearly impossible: only amicable negotiation (voluntary buyout) or legal action in the event of serious misconduct can lead to such an outcome.
Is an exclusion clause the same as an approval or pre-emption clause?
No, they are complementary: exclusion governs forced exit, approval controls entry, and pre-emption prioritizes the acquisition of shares by existing shareholders.
About the author
Guillaume Leclerc, Attorney at the Paris Bar experienced in commercial contracts and business litigation.
Please feel free to contact me with any questions; I would be happy to assist you.